JohnKyle

Despite having been given only a "two star" rating by our local newspaper, I decided to watch this recent addition to the TCM collection anyway and I'm glad I did. Although the story does not always flow smoothly and there are flaws in the narrative, The Red Lily is a beautifully told, emotionally driven, story with excellent acting by the three leads -- Enid Bennett; Ramon Novarro,who in this picture again shows what a fine actor he was; and, Wallace Beery providing some comic relief in what is until the very end essentially a tragic tale.

It is Bennett who makes this movie work. She is outstanding in her portrayal of a girl who is transformed from a naive peasant to a harsh and bitter "lady of the streets." This transformation is convincingly done, partly through her physical change, but more importantly through Bennett's skill as an actress. As another commenter has noted, her resemblance to Lillian Gish in physical appearance (except in profile), mannerisms, and acting style is uncanny. That alone is praise enough for any actress.

The direction by Fred Niblo, who was Bennett's husband, is nearly flawless with Niblo using innovative shots, creative lighting, and tinting to reinforce his story. The new musical score is superb and truly enhances the movie.

The Red lily is definitely worth watching even if you are not a fan of the Golden Age of Silents.

Forget that this is a "B" movie. Forget that it is in many ways outdated. Instead give writer-director Ida Lupino much deserved credit for addressing a subject which at the time (1950) was taboo in Hollywood. To my knowledge, this was the first film to address the subject of rape and the emotional and mental effects that that crime has upon its victims.

Although much of the cast's acting is pedestrian at best, Mala Powers, who at the time was eighteen or nineteen, gives an excellent performance throughout as the traumatized young woman, Ann, who tries to run away from her "shame." Based on her work in this film, I'm surprised that she did not have a more successful acting career. Tod Andrews, too, has some fine moments as the minister who reaches out to help her.

Ms Lupino, obviously working on a limited budget, was still able to create some memorable scenes such as the pursuit through the streets and alleys leading to the rape, and the police lineup following it. And, she created a bittersweet ending which left me wondering if Ann really could ever have a normal life again.

This film is a little known entry from the early days of "talkies" that deserves better recognition. Not a masterpiece by any means, it is still a forerunner of the screwball comedies of the later 30s and 40s and, as such, is pleasant and delightful in its own way.

The cast is very good. It is hard to believe that Loretta Young, playing an heiress who wants to create a family scandal, was only sixteen or seventeen when this movie was made. She has a charm and sensuality that belies her years. Douglas Fairbanks, Jr., who was nearly as young, does a nice job as a bumbling wannabe gigolo who falls in love with Loretta. Also, as noted by other reviewers, Louise Fazenda, as Young's aunt, and Daphne Pollard, as the "helpful" maid, give very funny performances.

The next time that this movie is on TCM, try to catch it or tape it. There are a lot worse ways to spend an hour or so.