Carmela, eine langsam in die Jahre kommende Lehrerin, hat eine besondere Schwäche für Schüler aus zerrütteten Familien, gerät dadurch aber mit dem Schulleiter in Konflikt. Der 12 Jahre alte ... Alles lesenCarmela, eine langsam in die Jahre kommende Lehrerin, hat eine besondere Schwäche für Schüler aus zerrütteten Familien, gerät dadurch aber mit dem Schulleiter in Konflikt. Der 12 Jahre alte Chala und Yeni, in die er verknallt ist, sind beide arm und haben ernsthafte Probleme zu H... Alles lesenCarmela, eine langsam in die Jahre kommende Lehrerin, hat eine besondere Schwäche für Schüler aus zerrütteten Familien, gerät dadurch aber mit dem Schulleiter in Konflikt. Der 12 Jahre alte Chala und Yeni, in die er verknallt ist, sind beide arm und haben ernsthafte Probleme zu Hause.
- Regie
- Drehbuch
- Hauptbesetzung
- Auszeichnungen
- 21 Gewinne & 12 Nominierungen insgesamt
- Mercedes
- (as Idalmis García)
- Mirta
- (as Anniet Forte)
Empfohlene Bewertungen
It baffles the mind how someone living 15-20 hours away by plane could craft a screenplay that feels like a snapshot of one's own childhood.
The world's state between 1930 and 2000 ought to be examined by sociologists. For though we speak different tongues, dwell in different lands and continents, and follow different faiths, we have grieved for the same things and rejoiced over the same. And yet, we have been hurt in identical ways.
My love for the cinema and literature of Portuguese- and Spanish-speaking nations is no coincidence. Conducta only deepens this affection and, as always, remains sorely underrated.
This is no teacher-student film in the vein of Hollywood's tiresome "White savior teaches humanity to immigrants" nonsense.
Cuba, Havana... Turkey, Istanbul...
The true protagonist of this tale is Saintly Teacher Carmela, a woman who decides for herself, filled with love and compassion. She teaches her students to be individuals like herself. She teaches them the most essential lesson of all: to be themselves, to resist, to fight - no matter who stands before them. By the film's end, you'll see that only two people truly walk their own path: Teacher Carmela and her student Chala. And perhaps also Chala's sweetheart Yeni and her proud father.
The moment when Yeni covertly gifts White Fang by Jack London to guide Chala away from dogfights and toward maturity filled me with delight. For those who know me are aware of my deep admiration for Jack London. That act, much like the priest giving Jean Valjean the candlesticks, was a gesture of profound nobility.
These four stand apart, for the rest are either pawns of the street's lawlessness or puppets of the state's rigid, loveless ideological rule.
Yeni's father's words linger in one's mind: "The worst masters rise from the ranks of servants."
This is a shining example of tender discipline between a teacher and a child, a crowning achievement for Cuban cinema. The acting is splendid, the continuity flawless. The camera roams Havana's streets with an almost poetic precision. Armando Valdés Freire, portraying Chala, delivers a remarkable performance for one so young. Likewise, Amaly Junco, playing the lovely Yeni, shines with equal brilliance. But most of all, I was captivated by Teacher Carmela. For it is evident she is one of those children who never truly grow up. Actress Alina Rodríguez understood this perfectly, and in the opening and closing scenes, her mischievous grin in response to Chala's call, without even turning her gaze, encapsulates the film in its entirety.
While editing the film's IMDb page, I noticed that Armando Valdés Freire, born in 2000, had not appeared in any other films. A profound loss for the world of cinema.
Also, the energy of the young lead actors was amazing. So strong. Boy/girl stuff far beyond the limited scope of typical films. These are tough people for ones so young. Totally impressive, let alone both so physically attractive for their ages, especially in the faces. So expressive!
Incredible work considering the subject matter.
So, we see it. What are we going to do about it? How do we return sovereignty to countries, and exchange such cultural diversities?
Thx, SLAFF, for presenting such an incredible film!
But the film is good not because it deals with the situation as a whole, or the education system, but because it focuses on a small group of people. It shows a teacher, an aged woman, responsible for helping her pupils cross the hell of their childhood.
The most troublesome boy in her current class in Chalah, whose mother is an addict and his father may or may not be a fight dog trainer for whom he works.
The most important thing-the story never becomes the old unbearable shtick about a teacher taming and saving students.
The child actor Armando Valdes Freire is simply amazing. He portrays a boy who is tough, street-smart, and reckless, and who deeply cares about his negligent mother. He feels that the teacher, Carmela, is the one person on whom he can count, and he's devoted to her. He also likes an immigrant girl who's in danger of being exiled with her father any minute.
Alina Rodríguez, who does Carmela, never misses. Her acting is so precise, she seems to be the teacher herself. She goes through her own hardship so she's aware life is rough, but she is willing to be that little Dutch boy who puts his finger in the hole in the wall to prevent the ocean from washing over the city.
Clearly, as it is not a soap opera, some things remain open, and nothing reaches an ideal solution. However, the film convinces that there is hope where one special person can open the way for others.
Aging teacher Carmela has an extra place in her heart for the kids coming from broken families and difficult family relations. 11 year old Chala is a troublemaker, and earn the money to keep his mother running on drugs and alcohol by training special pigeons and dogs for illegal dog fights.He is infatuating with class mate Yeni, which hasn't got the proper right to attend school, because her father is work-less and outside of his county. Carmela gets in trouble by her support for these two pupils, and the young headmaster wants her dismissed. It's also a love story, and a story about a teachers' importance.
This film is simply amazingly well made. Perfect photography, amazing acting in a perfect script. This could simply not be made better in any way! Young Chala is played so amazingly well by Armando Valdez Freire that it's almost unbelievable. The others are equaling the play. Such amazing instruction. So natural, so real, and upright charming.
The film in some way resembles Walter Salles amazing "Central do Brazil" (1998) and also to some extent "Dead Poets Society" (1989), but is even better.
I saw this film with English subtitles on the premiere night at the Films from the South Festival in Oslo in a packed theater giving standing ovations after screening.
Treat yourself to see this. In fact, go head over heels to see it. But remember to bring some napkins to stop the tears. What a gem! What a film!
What to criticize on such a film? Hm... I surrender!!!
Wusstest du schon
- WissenswertesOfficial submission of Cuba to the best foreign language film category of the 87th Academy Awards 2015.
- Zitate
Carmela: Every year, I have a Chala in my class. None of them has ever been stronger than me, because, at heart, they are all children. There are four things you need to bring up a child: a home, a school, rigor and affection. But outside that door, there's the street, and a teacher needs to know what's waiting for them out there. In the past, life was clearer, and I knew what I was preparing my students for. Now, the only thing clear to me is what not to prepare them for.
Top-Auswahl
Details
Box Office
- Weltweiter Bruttoertrag
- 147.731 $
- Laufzeit
- 1 Std. 48 Min.(108 min)
- Farbe
- Seitenverhältnis
- 2.35 : 1