John le Carré: Der Taubentunnel

Getting inside the head of a spy is undoubtedly challenging; getting inside the head of a novelist who was once a spy who now writes about that enigmatic profession is nearly impossible. And that's one of the hurdles that hampers this profile of former MI5 and MI6 operative David Cornwell, better known to the world by his pen name, John le Carré (1931-2020). Based on the author's memoir of the same name, the latest from documentarian Errol Morris puts the best-selling espionage novelist under the microscope, seeking to discover who le Carré is, what factors impacted his life and writings, and how his novels mirror those influences in terms of content and themes. Through discussions of books like "The Spy Who Came in from the Cold," "Tinker, Tailor, Soldier, Spy," "Smiley's People," "A Perfect Spy" and "The Looking Glass War," backed by clips of film and television adaptations of these works, le Carré and Morris ruminate on the writer's objectives in bringing them to life, some of them personal in nature and some of them expressions of his feelings about the murky underworld he left behind and brought to life on the printed page. Much of what the author consequently discusses comes across as dark, cryptic, and characterized by rampant intrigue and betrayal, not unlike the life he left behind (as well as the dismal upbringing he underwent at the knee of his untrustworthy father, a professional swindler adept at plying his craft). The insights, to say the least, are rather depressing and disquieting. But that unsettling material is further compounded by a string of often-perplexing observations about le Carré's existential outlooks and literary intentions, some of which seemingly amount to little more than oh so much navel gazing and intellectual masturbation, overstated attempts at encapsulating his perspectives on human nature and human relations as reflected through his works. I can imagine that there's probably a market for a film like this among Anglophiles captivated by the writer's works, the spy novel genre in general and PBS/BBC television dramas, but it really didn't do much for me, especially since this offering pales in comparison to many of Morris's other better productions. Thankfully, the picture's merciful 1:32:00 runtime proved to be its saving grace (even though the picture admittedly improves once it gets past an overly long, excessively detailed prologue). Ironically, le Carré notes in the film that he sees his novels as an antidote to the James Bond books and movies, but, from where I stand, I'll take 007 over this any day.

As "The Pigeon Tunnel" (2023 release; 93 min) opens, Le Carre and the film's director Errol Morris are discussing the making of this film (supposedly the last interview LeCarre ever gave). LeCarre (real name: David Cornwell) then reflects on his upbringing, which he admits was anything but easy. At this point we are 10 minutes into the documentary...

Couple of comments: this is the latest documentary from Oscar-winning director Errol Morris ("The Fog of War"). Here he reassesses Cornwell/Le Carre's life and times. And how does Morris exactly do that? For the most part he simply lets the interviewee do the talking. It's almost as if we get a glimpse of what Le Carre is such an accomplished writer. The movie is at its best when Le Carre explains how his own real life experiences as a spy for the British secret service influenced the novels he wrote. Morris uses film clips to illustrate various points. At a certain point, it blurs the lines of what is real and what is fiction. I found is rather fascinating. THe movie also benefits tremendously from the delightful original score by Philip Glass and Paul Leonard Morgan, who has scored several earlier Morris documentaries.

"The Pigeon Tunnel" premiered at the Telluride Film Festival in early September, earning immediate critical acclaim. There is good reason why this movie is currently rate 95% Certified Fresh on Rotten Tomatoes. The movie just started streaming on Apple TV. If you are a fan of John Le Carre or of Errol Morris' earlier documentaries, I'd readily suggest you check this out, and draw your own conclusion.

Fascinating, insightful, and informative. I could say more, but the "actor" says it better. However ... talking heads (with the occasional interjection from the writer/director Errol Morris in this case) often use other author's words, and this can leave the viewer feeling as if the question asked has not been answered, and sometimes avoided. Here, whilst the subject replies honestly, he also admits to a possible distortion by the hand of time, youth, and literary escapology and invention. I thoroughly enjoyed his affable demeanour, his candour and the insight it gave into the parallels between the books and his life. Any and every fan of John Le Carre's work should watch this tv film/documentary.

Did you know that "The Spy Who Came in from the Cold" by a certain David Cromwell (aka John Le Carré) sold between 12-15 million physical copies? That's before Richard Burton took on the mantle of "Lemeas" from that novel and long before Sir Alec Guinness took on the part of the forensic super-spy "George Smiley" in "Tinker Tailor Soldier Spy" and that gives us quite an indication as the phenomenal success of this writer who basically bares his soul here in a one-to-one with Errol Morris. Spurred on only sparingly by the director, we are left with what is an succinct and informative retrospective on the life of a man who might not have seemed obviously destined for literary greatness. We start with his childhood where he was largely brought up by his con-man father (after his mother got fed up of the crooks and the mistresses and fled when he was five) and follows his education through Oxford, his recruitment into and ultimately boredom of the the British Intelligence community before turning his hand to bringing all of this experience to life in over twenty published novels. This isn't a treatise on how to write a thriller. It's an enjoyably structured lesson on how a little bit of experience, an understanding of human nature and a vidid imagination can create works of fiction that enthral and captivate. He delivers this with candour, humour, a tiny bit of self-deprecation but most notably - truthfulness. You need to have your thinking cap on, too. He uses language eruditely and in a considered fashion that I could listen to all day. You won't learn much about how to write a spy story, but you will learn something of this fascinating and engaging human being. It's an Apple TV production so might get only a limited cinema release (though the BBC seem to have supplied quite a bit of archive, so perhaps they secured a tx as a quid pro quo?) and it's most definitely worth a watch if you are remotely interested in the genre, in writing - or in just listening to an interesting man.

Director Errol Morris has made some pretty great documentaries in his career like "The Thin Blue Line, A Brief History of Time, and Fog of War" as Morris provides some interesting insightful documentaries and stories. With this one focusing on the career and life of John le Carré, Morris takes an interesting look of Carré's personality, career and the outlooks of the Cold War era and for the most part, it was solid.

John le Carré being the main subject provides some good and interesting conversations and discussions about his ideas and career with some pretty interesting dramatic reenactment moments to demonstrate the setting and environment. Throughout, the production was solid with the camerawork being good although nothing too special about it's presentation and colors. The conversations between Morris and Carré are strong as if there was good chemistry between the two of them.

However, the engagement wasn't the strongest as since topics about spy career isn't my most favorite genre of literature, there were some pacing moments that did feel a little sloppy that made certain subjects feel uninteresting to discuss about. There were certain discussion moments that I wished they had focused a little on more. The soundtrack does end up getting obnoxious as the soundtrack distracts certain moments.

Overall, it's an interesting documentary but it's not my favorite from Morris.