Alexander der Große: Wie er ein Gott wurde
Originaltitel: Alexander: The Making of a God
IMDb-BEWERTUNG
5,6/10
13.318
IHRE BEWERTUNG
Alexander war König des antiken mazedonischen Reiches und gilt als einer der größten und erfolgreichsten Feldherren der Geschichte.Alexander war König des antiken mazedonischen Reiches und gilt als einer der größten und erfolgreichsten Feldherren der Geschichte.Alexander war König des antiken mazedonischen Reiches und gilt als einer der größten und erfolgreichsten Feldherren der Geschichte.
Folgen durchsuchen
Zusammenfassung
Reviewers say 'Alexander the Great: Hero or Conqueror' offers an engaging narrative with impressive visuals and strong performances, particularly in portraying Alexander and Darius. However, it faces criticism for historical inaccuracies, poor acting, and its hybrid format. Some viewers value its entertainment and artistic liberties, while others find it misleading and shallow. The depiction of Alexander's personal life sparks debate, making it an ambitious yet flawed series.
Empfohlene Bewertungen
Yet again, Netflix makes the same mistakes, making everything feel like a joke.
This feels like a cheap soap opera instead of a documentary. The inaccuracy of the historical events are insane, the acting is very sad and forced. Nothing is explained about Alexander's life, they only induced fake drama which makes no sense at all.
This is a shame, Alexander has always been one of my favourite rulers from the past and I was hoping for some new information or at least a good interpretation of the ones all of us know.
This is another Netflix fail, do not waste your time if you are a history nerd, all you will end up on with is being sad and frustrated.
This feels like a cheap soap opera instead of a documentary. The inaccuracy of the historical events are insane, the acting is very sad and forced. Nothing is explained about Alexander's life, they only induced fake drama which makes no sense at all.
This is a shame, Alexander has always been one of my favourite rulers from the past and I was hoping for some new information or at least a good interpretation of the ones all of us know.
This is another Netflix fail, do not waste your time if you are a history nerd, all you will end up on with is being sad and frustrated.
Maybe the creators didn't want to remake the Farrell Alexander. Or maybe there wasn't enough info that would be palatable to the Netflix audience that gets bored in the age of TikTok. Nita particularly good look at Alexander's life. The series starts with Al in exile at age 20. It leaves out his education with Aristotle and the taming of his famous horse. These two stories are part of the legend. Why they were left out is beyond me. Another reviewer noted the flaws in the armor worn by the troops. I can't speak to that but the horses were too large and the tack was off. I get really annoyed by that detail. Narrators pop in and out to provide sciencey exposition that stops the motion of the story. I'd suggest reading The Persian Boy instead of watching this series. And let's quit making the Persians the Evil Empire. It was a long lived and culturally diverse area that existed as part of the Silk Road. A series on Persia would be fascinating.
I'm impressed at least by the fact that Netflix is paying more attention to audiences who are interested in history.
Having said that, I think the hardcore history audience will also demand a lot from the Netflix series.
They're such nerds that they've read everything and expect Netflix to present it to the public just like the books.
It's a docudrama with very strong drama, but it could be worse.
There are a lot of inaccuracies it is true. But giving this documentary 1/10 because you think "Alexander was Greek not Macedonian" reveals how stupid you are despite knowing more about Alexander than the producers.
Having said that, I think the hardcore history audience will also demand a lot from the Netflix series.
They're such nerds that they've read everything and expect Netflix to present it to the public just like the books.
It's a docudrama with very strong drama, but it could be worse.
There are a lot of inaccuracies it is true. But giving this documentary 1/10 because you think "Alexander was Greek not Macedonian" reveals how stupid you are despite knowing more about Alexander than the producers.
Not a spoiler, highly inaccurate series. I agree with anither review saying that the 300 movie was more accurate than this 😂. So many missed moments, missed battles, inaccurate events oh so many. It felt like watching something like "ancient aliens", like this is a hypothesis of a couple of PhDs. The disappointing part also is that one of the historians is from St Andrews University. It had such high standards.. Clearly not anymore. Although, that historian was the most serious and studious than the rest of them! One is in love with Alexander and is telling a story that he has in his mind and the other is almost like making fun of him. What an odd series. Only reason I put 4 stars, is for the drama series, not the historians nor the highly inaccurate story.
I'll keep this short. Hollywood still can't make anything remotely accurate about Alexander the Great. It makes me sick. When I was a kid we had that Oliver Stone mess with Colin Farrell and honestly I didn't think it could get worse. I was wrong.
This Netflix garbage is intentionally inaccurate. I don't understand it. I've studied Alexander and ancient Macedon for years and when I tell you they are intentionally changing or misleading very well known historical details, please know I'm not kidding. All for entertainment purposes I guess but here's the problem - the truth is so much more interesting!
Just skip it. There are YouTube documentaries that are far far far better than whatever this garbage is.
I suppose it's better than that Jada Pinkett Smith "Cleopatra was Black" nonsense.
This Netflix garbage is intentionally inaccurate. I don't understand it. I've studied Alexander and ancient Macedon for years and when I tell you they are intentionally changing or misleading very well known historical details, please know I'm not kidding. All for entertainment purposes I guess but here's the problem - the truth is so much more interesting!
Just skip it. There are YouTube documentaries that are far far far better than whatever this garbage is.
I suppose it's better than that Jada Pinkett Smith "Cleopatra was Black" nonsense.
Wusstest du schon
- WissenswertesThis is no clear historical evidence that Alexander and Stateira, Darius' wife, had a sexual relationship. In the series, historian Lloyd Llewellyn-Jones cites Plutarch as saying that Stateira died in childbirth and suggests that the child could not have been Darius', given how long she has been separated from him. Yet Plutarch had also written that Alexander showed no interest in Stateira. Plutarch also said that Darius heard the news about his wife's death from an escaped eunuch, who'd been captured along with the women. The eunuch had defended Alexander, suggesting that "[Darius] should even admire Alexander for having shown greater self-restraint in dealing with Persian women than valor against Persian men."
Top-Auswahl
Melde dich zum Bewerten an und greife auf die Watchlist für personalisierte Empfehlungen zu.
Details
- Erscheinungsdatum
- Herkunftsland
- Offizieller Standort
- Sprache
- Auch bekannt als
- Alexander: The Making of a God
- Drehorte
- Produktionsfirmen
- Weitere beteiligte Unternehmen bei IMDbPro anzeigen
- Laufzeit
- 45 Min.
- Farbe
- Sound-Mix
- Seitenverhältnis
- 16:9 HD
Zu dieser Seite beitragen
Bearbeitung vorschlagen oder fehlenden Inhalt hinzufügen