Black Sails

I can't believe how low the score is on imdb for such a masterpiece. This show should be rated much higher.

All the actors were amazing in this show. You could really feel the passion for each individual character portrayed by each great actor.

The writing was top tier with the twists and turns in the entire story. Each and every writer involved in this series should give themselves a pat on the back, as they are all amazing and talented. You should be proud of your skills.

The camera and editing teams were amazing. You outdid yourselves in every way possible.

For the other team members such as costume, set and FX crews as well as the rest of the team, you all went above and beyond. Absolutely amazing!

This show should be above a 9 in my opinion and I personally rate this show a 10/10. I re-watch this show at least once a year, and as a writer myself, I don't think I could top such a plot with such skill involving the world of pirates.

This show is a 100% must watch! You won't regret it!

Recently I was starting to have an interest in Shows that play in different historical periods.

After HBO's Deadwood and Rome I stumbled upon this show.

It is absolutely amazing. The actors are all great, the set design and overall world is beautiful and the action scenes are intense.

I want to also focus on Captain Flint and John Silver who have both incredibly great character arcs. Another highlight was Ray Stevenson as Edward Teach.

This show grips you and you want to continue watching and it's honestly hard to stop.

If there is a nitpick I have it's with Maxwell. Not her character or anything, but her fake accent was honestly painful to listen to at times. Everytime she spoke I cringed a little. She was also involved in a love triangle and I absolutely loathe those especially this one because it felt forced and the actors didn't have the greatest of chemistry.

But that aside Black Sails is an incredible show and criminally underrated!

Black Sails is a thrilling and well-crafted series that elevates the pirate genre to new heights. Set in the golden age of piracy, this gritty and intense prequel to Treasure Island masterfully blends historical events with fictionalized accounts of legendary pirates like Captain Flint, Charles Vane, and Blackbeard.

The show excels in its character development, weaving complex and morally ambiguous arcs that keep viewers invested throughout. Toby Stephens as Captain Flint delivers a powerhouse performance, portraying a leader torn between his ideals and darker instincts. Each major character, from the fiery Eleanor Guthrie to the cunning John Silver, is layered, making their alliances and betrayals all the more impactful.

The writing is sharp, with intelligent dialogue that goes beyond the typical action-adventure fare, touching on themes of power, freedom, and loyalty. The show also doesn't shy away from exploring difficult social issues adding depth to the storytelling.

Visually, Black Sails is stunning. The high production value shines through in the meticulously detailed sets, breathtaking naval battles, and sweeping cinematography. Every sea battle is choreographed with precision, offering a visceral, edge-of-your-seat experience.

While the pace may be slow at times, especially in the earlier episodes as it sets the stage for larger conflicts, the payoffs are consistently worth the build-up. As the show progresses, the stakes only grow higher, leading to a finale that ties the narrative threads together in a satisfying and thought-provoking way.

In short, Black Sails is more than just a pirate show; it's a complex drama filled with political intrigue, intense action, and richly developed characters. It stands out as one of the best series in the adventure genre, blending history and fiction into a swashbuckling epic with real emotional weight.

Black Sails is absolutely one of the most underrated shows ever. It was so good that I binged the entire series in a week. Everything about this show is damn near perfect...the writing, acting, cinematography, production value, costumes, all of it! You can tell the effort they put into this show by the attention to detail in every scene. The acting and writing are so good that you really come to care about what happens to these characters. This is by far the best series I've ever seen about pirates and definitely a show that is for adults. I was hooked from the very first episode through to the very last. Every season is fantastic.

Black Sails is just a flat out awesome show that is so addicting that once you start watching it, you can't stop! It's the prequel to "Treasure Island." It didn't get nearly the attention that it deserved at the time and that's probably because it was on STARZ when they were just branching out into original tv shows. This was one of their first big budget tv shows and it's worth every second you put into watching it! People are finally starting to find out about it now that STARZ has become bigger and more well know with shows like Spartacus, the Power franchise, Outlander, etc and is on streaming sites like Hulu. We still got 4 amazing seasons out of it though.