Christmas on 5th Avenue

7.3 stars.

The story begins with a woman named Eva who helps people improve their lives. She takes on a challenge to spruce up a very rich author's Manhattan apartment for the holidays. She discovers there is more depth to this man than at first, and he's not the scrooge that he appears to be. The rest of the story is about how she helps Lucas find happiness, and he fills the hole she's had in her hopelessly romantic heart. The theme is about finding happiness with the people in our lives no matter who they seem to be or what station they currently hold. We bring our genuine self to the table and that's how true love is revealed to us.

The film has a lot of slow moments and takes its time delivering the goods. I stuck with it in the hopes that I'd be blessed by something and I wasn't disappointed, however you must be patient with 'Christmas on 5th Avenue' because the gems don't show up until the last 30 minutes.

Eva (Kathryn Davis) runs a concierge business. She is given an assignment by a favorite client to decorate her son's NYC condo for Christmas to pick up his spirits, his wife died 3 years ago on Christmas day. Eva was going to stay at the condo since the son, Lucas (Oliver Renaud), was in Vermont and wouldn't be in NYC until Christmas, however, unbeknownst to the mother, Lucas had already returned to the NYC condo. Since Eva has no place to go, Lucas agrees to let her stay in the guest room. Eva is a Pollyanna type of person with a sunny and optimistic disposition, while Lucas is a pessimistic, recluse, a cold hearted writer, two opposites living in the same place. The plot takes us on a journey of how the two very different personalities impact each other.

Kathryn Davis is one of my favorite Hallmark female actors, she plays the role of Eva with a sparkling positive personality PERFECTLY! Some have criticized Oliver Renaud's performance saying he was too cold and stiff. However, that is EXACTLY how the character of Lucas was written in the script, at the beginning we see a depressed recluse, and the viewer watches Luca's character change and his feelings for Eva grow. I think Oliver did an excellent job portraying Lucas's transformation. The only complaint I had was toward the end of the movie when Lucas starts to reveal his feelings for Eva, and all of a sudden she does a 360 change in her personality and seems to blame her lack of understanding and experiencing what true love really is on Lucas! She also seems to suddenly forget all the nice things he's done for her. It was like they switched personalities, and was an awkward moment in the script. (perhaps it was Hallmark's set formula of incorporating their usual "conflict" which didnt work in this case since it was too much out of character for Eva.) But overall, this was an enjoyable romantic Christmas movie.

This movie is carried by Kathryn Davis as Eva. "Eva loves life, darling, and she's not afraid to live it." And it's fund to watch her live it. Why she sets her sights on Lucas baffles me, but the world definitely needs people like her. There is an exchange where Lucas accuses Eva of "doing it for money" and she responds that she has to eat and pay the rent and he doubles down on the accusation. By that point in the movie, it's clear money isn't what motivates her, and Lucas should be able to see that.

Olivier Renaud, as Lucas, is a cold fish in this movie. He never really shakes that even as Eva supposedly reforms him. There really isn't chemistry between the leads. And Lucas' response to all Eva does makes no sense. Whatever response he makes seems to be mostly internal. While Davis carries the move, Renaud holds it back.

Still, it's indicative how appealing Eva's personality is such that the movie is still enjoyable.

The story premise is a slight twist on the trope where a cabin is double booked for two strangers. In this case, it's Lucas' condo.

This is a perfectly okay, not special, Christmas movie. Storyline is what you'd expect. As a film it's fine to have on in the background while wrapping presents. New York looks great, though I would have liked some more shots of Christmas in the most beautiful city in the world (rather than focusing on one not-very-festively-decorated apartment). We Brits often watch US Christmas films for the stunning scenery and backdrops, so this one disappoints a bit on that level.

There are some decent cameos and supporting actors. I have to comment on the two stars, as most of the reviewers liked Kathryn Davis as Eva, but found Olivier Renaud, as Lucas, cold and unexpressive. I think perhaps a lot of reviewers are American? To this typical British viewer, Lucas seems a normal, thoughtful, emotionally-balanced if reserved sort of chap - and as a bonus, he looks great in a t-shirt! Eva is great looking, but too often chirpy and demanding to the point of annoying, excessively smily, and she seems to get more over-emotional and needy as the movie goes on. I just wanted her to calm down a bit. This seems to be a common kind of performance by female actors in US Christmas films, so maybe Americans find it 'normal', but for Brits it's pretty exhausting, and it's a relief to have a character like Lucas who seems more realistic. (Did I mention he also looks great in a t-shirt?) Would have been nice if, in return for Eva livening Lucas up and making him smile more, he maybe showed her the value of understatement and that you don't always have to over-share and over-express every emotion. It wasn't really a two-way development between them, which is a shame.

Overall, then: an okay Xmas film with two good-looking leads, one of whom you'll probably find a bit annoying (maybe depending on where you hail from). Fine for wrapping presents to.

Eva runs a concierge business and is very busy during Christmas. When one of her most important customers offers her her son's penthouse to live in while he is in Vermont in exchange for decorating and filling his freezer with home-cooked food, she jumps at the chance. But surprise surprise, the grieving reclusive best-selling author shows up unexpectedly. Romance and reclamation insue.

I'm in the minority in thinking Olivier Renaud's performance as Lucas was right on the money. He was supposed to be a cold fish, harsh, and stiff. Eva was so perky and sunny that it made a nice contrast and upped the chemistry between them. When he finally did warm up, it made it all the more affecting.