El Ardor - Der Krieger aus dem Regenwald

While it is not obvious in the beginning inside the jungle on Misiones near triple frontier with a jaguar roaming nearby, it is increasingly clear as this Argentine-Brazilian movie on land conflict advances, particularly in its second half, that it is a Western. Not only due the script, with powerful and violent gangsters robbing a rural estate from a humble hardworking family, a mysterious stranger engaging himself in protecting it against them, defensive shooting strategy, rape and duel. Also in edition, cinematography and even costumes (although the story is not in XIXth century in the United States, but in contemporary or recent past in verdant and watery Northeastern Argentina), the film explores many traits of the genre, with large face close-ups, shotguns, neckwear and wide-brimmed hats. The movie is technically well made, with extraordinary actors such as Chico Diaz, Alice Braga and Gael García Bernal.

The movie didn't work for me. It felt too artificial... forced. Almost like I could tell 'this is a movie' constantly. And it is not supposed to be like that, it has a kind of magical aura you are supposed to feel, and sometimes it works, mainly with sounds and the jungle images. But it doesn't work on how they managed ellipsis... for time to pass by they show you a dark sky with a full moon. Also it didn't work in acting direction, I think. The actors are good, but the tone is completely flat. It may have been a good idea, but it becomes somehow artificial while the movie advances. And the idea of man becoming one with nature felt also forced. The 'tiger'analogy with the main character. It has a great message and I think it was a strong bet. I'm glad they tried. Maybe Herzog's movies would have been a good starting point to think the mise en scene for this subject.

Kai (Gael García Bernal) is a mysterious shaman who emerges from the Rio Paraná to help a poor farmer and his daughter (Alice Braga), who are threatened by a band of cold-blooded mercenaries hired to force them to sell their land... I need to review it at a more opportune time to reassess it...

It looked great, but it was just good, it doesn't involve you as I imagined, it lacks a charisma, something more to feel really attracted to the events... indigenous population and small producers... Total darkness doesn't help much either... I need to review it at a more opportune time to reassess it...

As my title says, it could have been better. I was looking for a western and I had the impression that this was a western, not! I do appreciate the subtitles but there was not enough dialogue to carry the story and flesh out the plot. I am a devoted fan of westerns, independent westerns, and westerns set in other counties and this may have been called a "modern" western but it does not rise to that either. I recognized Alice Braga since she is one of the stars of Queen Of The South. I can see a great effort was made and the production values were good but I can't say more than that. Better luck next time.

Set in the Argentinean rain forest this is part western and part eco tale. It stars one of my favourite actors Gael García Bernal, as Kai, and he also co produced it. We have a poor subsistence farming family who are targeted by nasty thugs working for a land grab company – we are never sure what their ultimate aim is.

Kai ends up going to rescue the abducted daughter of one of the farmers but in so doing puts himself on a collision course with the evil ones.

Now this has a few clichés in it and has borrowed heavily from other films in the western genre. The action is limited, but when it happens it is well done. The cinematography is lovely – but hard to go wrong when you have the bounty of a rain forest at your feet– probably. The performances are all above average too but where it falls down is the thin story line. It is good versus bad with next to no ambiguity at all and almost no back story – this makes it hard to put everything into context.

That said I still enjoyed the watch – but would not want to see again, so a rental option here methinks. Original title is 'El Ardor' and filmed in Spanish with good to average sub titles and a run time of 96m minutes; this is one for those that like the sides nice and firmly drawn and appreciate some good old fashioned retribution.