Stroszek

"Stroszek" will potentially depress the hell out of you unless you happen to find Werner Herzog's brand of off-beat filmmaking amusing. I do mostly, and therefore wasn't tempted to jump off a bridge at the end of this movie, but I don't know that I'd go as far as to say it's "riotously funny," as its marketing poster suggests.

"Stroszek" tells the fictional story of a real man named Bruno Stroszek. In other words, Stroszek plays himself in this eccentric film about a man who's released from prison, meets back up with his girlfriend and elderly buddy, and takes off for the fabled lands of....Wisconsin....to pursue the American dream. Anyone who's actually been to Wisconsin can probably guess how things play out for three immigrants with about three dollars between them. What follows is a series of vignettes that place Bruno in increasingly desperate straits and ends in an ambiguous finale that involves a ski lift and dancing chickens.

Welcome to the world of Werner Herzog, folks. "Stroszek" is not as compelling as some of Herzog's best, but it does inspire a sort of morbid fascination, if only because we take comfort that our situation isn't as bad as the one our characters find themselves in. But lest you are tempted to feel too sorry for Stroszek, he, like many of Herzog's protagonists, staunchly refuses to beg for sympathy, and faces one hardship after another with the dogged determination of a man who never fully understands how humble is his lot.

Grade: A-

I discovered Werner Herzog first through his remake of Nosferatu and then through Fitzcarraldo and Aguirre: The Wrath of God. Though the brilliance of those movies is unimpeachable, Stroszek, at least for me, stands at the apex of Herzog's oeuvre.

This intensely moving and satisfying film which begins in Germany and winds up in Wisconsin is solid through and through. There's not a weak moment or weak element to be found. The acting, especially by Bruno S., is completely unaffected and without over-stylization (there is, perhaps, a reason for this - they aren't acting, simply being). The story itself deals with melodramatic elements without steering into soap opera territory and the film's ideology is not black in white. There's subtlety and complexity to the ideas put forth in this film about America, Germany, human beings, life, etc. Moreover, Stroszek avoids beating the audience's brains with its ideas; Herzog presents them in the context of the story, smoothly integrated.

And then there's the beautiful photography, particularly of the American Midwest; Herzog and his cameramen capture perfectly the cold, stark, desolate magnificence of the upper-Plains. To draw a weird comparison, the photography here is the equivalent of Husker Du's New Day Rising - crisp, harsh, and gorgeous simultaneously.

Stroszek also has a justifiably well-known ending, both surreal and completely sensible. Though any other director would be unable to top an ending such as that in Aguirre (the slumped conqueror, floating on a monkey-covered raft), Herzog does just that here.

Truly, if you have not seen any Herzog, this is a great place to start; then go see Aguirre, Fitzcarraldo, Nosferatu, Woyczek, and Invincible. The man is brilliant and I await with bated breath Grizzly Man, his new project.

This movie has been described as Herzog's take on the American Dream, and there is some overt USA bashing, but it is much more complex than that, as societies are not easily characterized. For instance, the gangster-pimps that terrorize and brutalize Bruno and Eva in Berlin are very much reflections of the Gestapo mentality and the feeling of being trapped and helpless in your own homeland. They are more fortunate than Nazi victims in the ease of their "escape" to America but unlike most of those refugees in the 30's and 40's, Bruno is unable to assimilate and contribute. He expects instant riches and does a little work for the horny hillbillies that give him a job but is still full of anger and paranoia. This is due primarily to his obvious faults, alcoholism and maybe paranoid schizophrenia, and not to the American system. All 3 of the German transplants are shown to be highly intelligent and cultured beyond the hellish railroad town they are plopped down into, and the obvious solution would have been for Bruno to seek employment as a musician, as he is very talented in that regard, but the dramatic arc of the story demands that he lose everything including Eva, and blame America and the insipid characters he is forced to deal with, and do something drastic, which he does. Eva knew that America is the same as every place: if you want a good life, you've got to work hard for it, using whatever tools & gifts you possess. But Bruno is too damaged to apply this principle, and this is the tragedy of "Stroszek" and of Bruno S.

The scene with the premature baby and the doctor is one of the greatest I've ever seen. It is just amazing, the character of that tiny infant, and shows Stroszek the fundamental power that he lacks, the tenacious nature of humanity to hold onto not only fellow human beings, but also to life itself.

The coin-operated live animals in the end represent not only cruelty and lack of compassion, but the obsessiveness of the American pursuit of entertainment. I personally felt more compassion for these creatures as victims of a system than I did for Bruno, who was pretty much doomed before he came to America.

Fascinating, unique look at the American dream follows three German social misfits (Bruno S., Eva Mattes, Clemens Scheitz) as they travel to Railroad Flats, Wisconsin to seek a better life. Strange comic moments mesh together well with some extremely sad and moving moments. Superbly performed by everybody, although the cast is mostly non-actors. The documentary style shooting works well with the story. One of Herzog's best.

Bruno is a street performer released from prison in Berlin. In a local pub, he befriends a down-on-her-luck prostitute named Eva, who moves in with him. Her pimps harass and assault them both regularly, forcing their way into Bruno's apartment at one point and trashing the place. After Bruno's elderly friend Herr Scheitz announces his plans to move to Wisconsin, Bruno and Eva decide to accompany him to try and start again in America. However, it turns out their prospects may not be much better stateside, as we see in Werner Herzog's brilliant comic-drama 'Stroszek.'

A powerful, deeply moving film, 'Stroszek' is unique and unforgettable. It is a tender portrait of life on the margins of society that is most affecting. Herzog's characters are profoundly realistic creations and his story is full of poignancy. A movie about shattered dreams and dashed hopes, its themes are universal and its images captivating. At times, the precisely honed film feels improvisational or off-the-cuff; which is a credit to the unaffected nature of Herzog's writing and direction. Though there is a lot of humor in 'Stroszek,' it is ultimately a harrowing drama that speaks volumes about the human condition within our callous world.

'Stroszek' reunites Herzog with cinematographer Thomas Mauch, one of his more frequent collaborators. Mauch's naturalistic approach gives the film a documentary-like feel, which bolsters the faux-authenticity of Herzog's narrative. His juxtaposition of the constricting alleyways and streets of Berlin with the wide-open spaces of Wisconsin is arresting and effective. In the role of cinematographer, Herzog regularly uses Mauch, Jörg Schmidt-Reitwein or Peter Zeitlinger. The work of the latter two generally feature more stylizations and elaborate lighting, and possess a dream like atmosphere. For a human-centered drama like 'Stroszek,' the realism of Mauch's approach is most appropriate, as the haunting beauty of the resulting visuals prove.

The film boasts an atmospheric soundtrack, featuring songs by the likes of Sonny Terry and Chet Atkins. David Lynch has often stated that a successful film is comprised of "sound and image moving together through time," positing that, in scenes, visuals and sounds must complement each other; as they do masterfully throughout 'Stroszek'. Terry's 'Old Lost John' is utilized particularly well in one scene at the end of the film that sticks in the mind long after the credits have rolled (as it evidently did in Herzog's; he would re-use the song decades later to similar effect in 'Bad Lieutenant: Port of Call New Orleans').

Herzog has said that he doesn't like to "confront" his films alone during the editing stage, and until 1984, Beate Mainka-Jellinghaus assisted him during that process on all his cinematic endeavors. Their work for 'Stroszek' is flawless, and the film has a steady pace that never lets up. Additionally, the set design is muted, though highly detailed. Locations look long lived in, and the grittiness of their appearance adds to the overall narrative impact.

'Stroszek' stars Bruno S as the titular character. Partially inspired by himself, Bruno gives a tour-de-force performance of boundless depth, vulnerability and emotional perspicuity. He is someone you warm to immediately, and has your sympathies throughout. As does Eva Mattes- the only real professional actor involved- co-starring as Eva the prostitute. Her ease of performance and range leaves an indelible impression on the viewer, and you feel she really cares for Bruno. Also worthy of note is Clemens Scheitz's terrific turn as the elderly, comic Herr Scheitz and a troupe of performing chickens; who do most memorable work (despite the intense stupidity of their gaze).

A masterful and understated tragicomedy, 'Stroszek' is vintage Herzog. Boasting an insightful screenplay full of humor and drama in equal measure, the story is heartfelt and speaks of universal human truths. Seamlessly edited and shot with a distinct visual style, the film is timeless and terrific. Strongly acted and featuring an emotive soundtrack full of catchy tunes, this tale of broken dreams is one you'll find hard to forget.