Tod durch Erhängen

This is a very good movie. There are moments of brilliance, funny and emotional moments and for sure, this made me think a lot.

It started as a dark comedy but as it progressed, it became something else. Something like an absurd, Kafkaesque satire/psychological drama. Definitely, it was unpredictable and it took a lot of risks. I admire director's boldness. I love overambitious movies, even why they failed, because at least, the creators dared to present something different and visionary. DEATH BY HANGING didn't fail but it became at times, disjointed and unfocused. I am not gonna lie, i didn't understand everything i watched, it was too confusing at some point.

But still, the pros outweigh the cons by a lot. It was a brilliant movie. And innovative. This is pure art, pure Cinema.

The film begins with a documentary style look at a Japanese execution chamber. An unseen narrator explains that the vast majority of people still support the death penalty before the image shifts across a prison to the death camber itself. This chamber looks old fashioned, quaint even, both from the interior and exterior. As the building seems so archaic it's almost hard to imagine that people are actually brought there to die. One doesn't have to imagine, however, since the execution ritual is quickly and efficiently carried out as soon as the viewer is acquainted with the setting. Everything goes smoothly in this case except for one thing: the guilty man is certainly hanged but he continues to live.

After a brief recuperation, R, the condemned man, awakens with a strong case of amnesia. The confused officials quickly reveal themselves as fools without the ability to react critically. They are determined to execute this man again but they won't feel right about it until he remembers who he is and why this is happening to him. The rest of the film consists of various people helping R regain the memories of who he is and how he got into this situation. The actions of the various people are often comically absurd as they attempt reenactments of various parts of R's life including his childhood in a slum reserved for "inferior" Koreans and the murders he has been convicted of. It's often a funny film but the subject matter is too serious for it to be seen as anything but the blackest of comedies.

This is very much a social issues film for ardent leftist director Nagisa Oshima and several issues are dealt with including capital punishment (of course), nationalism, racism, violence against women, and the postwar lives of war criminals. There is never any doubt which side Oshima is on for any of these issues: the film is unsubtle if not downright didactic. Still, Oshima's prodigious talent as a film-maker greatly increase the effectiveness of this film and many of these issues are still quite relevant all over the world today. This film is not quite as masterful as 1969's less obvious Boy but it's still a worthy of the attention of people interested in Japanese culture and/or Nagisa Oshima.

Pretty fantastic dark comedy/satire about the death penalty, the justice system, and relations between Japan and Korea post World War 2.

What starts as a quirky and amusing (yet still quite dark) film about what to do with a sentenced to death prisoner who apparently can't be killed gradually becomes more surreal, psychological, and more dramatic.

The progression is done well, and while there are scenes in the second half that can be overwhelming or confusing, at a point I certainly stopped taking things literally and tried to focus on the ideas and themes presented. (Arguably, with the initial premise of a man surviving being hanged, I should have stopped taking things literally almost straight away).

It has an accessible first half that does give way to a more disturbing and confounding second half, but it's a journey well worth taking if the premise sounds interesting to you.

This is one of the most complex and troubling films that I have seen lately. I know unfortunately too little about Nagisa Oshima, beyond his being the director of the famous Empire of Senses. Here he gives an amazingly strong film about the fate of one man identified by a one letter name (as in Kafka's Process) facing death by hanging but refusing to die, and losing his memory in the process. The whole bureaucratic system around works to get his memory back in order to make him pay for his crimes. They will re-enact his crimes starting to look crazier and bringing to surface their own demons and prejudices, plunging the hero redeemed innocent by amnesia and themselves in a complex world that mixes ceremony and nightmare. The film is a strong shout of protest against the death penalty, militarism and any repressive system that crashes human dignity.

Oshima is a director who usually leaves you in no doubt about what he thinks, but he goes all out here. This film is a strong polemic against the death penalty as practiced in Japan. The condemned man fails to die, and those in the death chamber panic and wonder what to do. After about five minutes of narration (by Oshima himself), the characters gear into action, using Oshima's chosen method : black farce. This is a very funny film, and all the more so because it confronts some very edgy stuff and often crosses the line to outrage. Oshima, as he often does, attacks Japan's sacred cows head on. As well as the death penalty, he deals with prejudice against Koreans, rape, politics, respect for authority and much more.

The acting is excellent, particularly the Korean who plays the condemned man. His calm poise provides an excellent balance to the mania of the officials around him, as they try to make him remember who he is and what he's done.

Strong stuff, warmly recommended.