Die Erbschaft der Tante Clara

"You don't know anything about dogs" - "I'm very fond of dogs".

That little exchange demonstrates the culture-gap between Henry (Ronald Shiner) and Clara (Margaret Rutherford), as he tries to shield her from the murky world of the greyhound stadium.

The odd couple have come together after the death of Clara's rich, unscrupulous uncle, who has bequeathed her everything, as the only relative who has never shown any interest in his fortune - until now, when she wants to know how it was earned. A high-minded spinster who seeks to put the world to rights, she recruits the old man's butler, Henry, to help her investigate what he already knows are a lot of dodgy businesses. That greyhound-stable for one. A pub that waters the beer. A crooked fairground stall. A seedy brothel. And an accountant who pockets the maintenance due to an illegitimate daughter.

Her generous forgiveness of the wicked may not be very believable, but it provides for much comedy of contrast - his flash-harry crudeness, her exaggerated gentility. Watch for the statutory walk-on role for her strange, desperately-shy real-life husband, and a small part for the unknown Sid James, entirely in character as an on-course bookie. The uncle is played by Edwardian relic A.E. Matthews, still in good resonant voice at 85. Don't be distracted by the scriptwriter's name Kenneth Horne - it wasn't the radio comedy star, but a different one, much the same age.

"Aunt Clara" was probably a vehicle for Margaret Rutherford to display her unique subtle, disarming type of humor. I say probably because the picture was hijacked by Ronald Shiner, a vaudeville-type given to bombast and overacting. The styles of the principals are at great variance and on several occasions Miss Rutherford was simply overwhelmed by Mr. Shiner, whose persona has the same effect as, say, Carmen Miranda - an arresting presence that you can't take your eyes off whenever he is on screen. And he is in nearly every scene.

Don't get me wrong. He was funny enough and carried his part well enough, but I put the DVD in to watch Miss Rutherford, who was hard-pressed to compete with the over-the-top style of Mr. Shiner. I savored as I could the moments when she delivered her fey, understated brand of comedy in a part made for her talents as a naive spinster who inherits a fortune from a disreputable nephew. You have to listen for her, but you just watch him.

All in all, it was an enjoyable movie which could have been better but for the complaints mentioned above. It could have been rated a 7 but I settled for 6. Quick note to UK contributors; your ratings for films made in the UK are often misleading. Some even-handedness is needed, as abnormally high ratings hinder rather than help.

Margaret Rutherford had few opportunities for leads except for the Jane Marple films. But when she got a role like the one in Aunt Clara she ran away with it.

This is happy and whimsical tale of a woman who is left a small fortune and a lot interesting holdings from her uncle A.E, Matthews. Matthews had some interesting interests that a pious old soul like Rutherford would normally not be dealing with. Like thoroughbred race horses, greyhound dogs, and a bordello where the working girls are getting a bit long in the tooth..

Rutherford may seem a bit dotty, but she has a lot of innate wisdom and things work out for the best though a bit roundaboutly.

This is a fine role for Margaret Rutherfprd and a must for her fans.

I would agree with 2 of the previous reviewers who have highlighted a major problem with this film,Ronnie Shiner.The director seems content to let him bulldoze everyone else out of the way,overacting wildly.Alas it isn't that funny.Furthermore the main premise of the film is done to death by the end.Margaret Rutherford is likely to be so shocked by the investments of her late relative,A.E.Matthews,that she has to be shielded from them.However in each case she is worldly wise to know what is going on.This might be funny once or twice,but when constantly repeated it actually becomes a bit of a bore.There are a lot of well known character actors appearing in this film but unfortunately they are let down by a script which lacks humour and which ends up rather maudlin.Shiner was a big star in the 1950s but ill health curtailed his career.When you watch his films today you can only wonder why audiences found him so funny.I do remember going to watch him in Operation Bullshine and walking out half way through!

This was Margaret Rutherford's favourite film and it's not difficult to see why as she is given full reign to her comic abilities. She is charming throughout and works well particularly in scenes with Ronald Shiner. She plays 'Clara' a middle - aged spinster who is left the task to clean up the acts of several members of her family who are engaged in rather unsavoury practices when her elderly uncle dies. As an angel of mercy, she visits each of her relatives in turn showing them the errors of their ways with hilarious results. Her last visit takes her to Fay Compton who employs a rather dilapidated brothel which includes a group of dishevelled ladies who work there. This scene is particularly moving and full of pathos. Unfortunately this film is rarely shown on British television - a great loss.