Der neue Sheriff

I have always been surprised to see that ambitionless film director Louis King gave the best of his films by the end of his career. Not masterpieces, but greater films than the bulk of what he made in the thirties, forties: I mean grade Z westerns, or crime series - Bulldog Drummond, Charlie Chan; I though make exception with this small crime flicks for Paramount Pictures starring Lloyd Nolan, J Caroll Naish and produced in the late thirties. So this one, produced by the prestigious Twentieth Century Fox - Louis King"s also prestigious brother Henry's company - is a surprise. Louis King could have worked for Allied Artists or Republic Pictures. Excellent little western, the kind that Universal Studios could have made too. Splendid location settings. However, 20 Th Century Fox gave us similar B westerns in the fifties, several directed by Harmon Jones. And a strange and unusual showdown. Cameron Mitchell in a surprisingly good villain performance.

If you're thinking that you might have seen Powder River before you would be right. If you saw Frontier Marshal or My Darling Clementine and noted in Powder River's credits that it's derived from a book by Stuart Lake than you'll know the source. Rory Calhoun plays a Wyatt Earp like marshal who has quit law enforcement for prospecting.

But when his partner Frank Ferguson is bushwhacked and robbed of the gold they've panned, Calhoun takes on the marshal's job. He also makes the acquaintance of a pair of outlaw brothers Carl Betz and John Dehner. And a terminally ill and alcoholic doctor Cameron Mitchell who is lightning fast with a six gun.

There's also a bit of Destry Rides Again added to the mix with French speaking saloon owner Corinne Calvet. The good girl from back east who wants to bring Mitchell home to save his life is former Roy Rogers leading lady Penny Edwards.

The best part of Powder River is a nice action gunfight in a foiled stagecoach robbery with Calhoun and Mitchell joining forces. The guys and the stagecoach are on a river ferry with the outlaws firing on them from shore and the ferry cut loose is heading for the rapids. All nicely staged.

If you've seen My Darling Clementine or Frontier Marshal you know how this one comes out. Calhoun made several good westerns in the Fifties and Sixties. But it's Mitchell who has the best role, the Doc Holiday part is always the best one every time this story is retold.

Louis King means squat to me as a director: the only other film of his that I saw was DANGEROUS MISSION! And I cannot remember it in any detail though I rated it 7/10.

Rory Calhoun rules the roost here: he blends Wyatt Earp and Destry, though at the start he is a humble, no nonsense gold digger who knows who killed his mining sidekick, wants to avenge that death, takes on the role of sheriff, and never wears a gun - very much like Jimmy Stewart in DESTRY RIDES AGAIN.

In turn, Cameron Mitchell plays Mitch Hardin, an ultra quick gun hand who, like Doc Holliday, boozes far more than good health requires. As if that were not disruptive enough, he also coughs and suffers from severe headaches that disable him every so often, at times right in the middle of a shootout. I found myself laughing at his plight, but Hardin - the name of a real and famous killer among gunfighters in the Old West - is loyal to Calhoun, even if their relationship does not get off to a wholesome start, as both have their eye on the same female. In the end, poor handsome Calhoun gets no girl but Hardin - who saves his girlfriend's life by removing a bullet from her chest, so he is a qualified but often inebriated medical doctor - sounds ever more like Doc Holliday.

Good cinematography, fair screenplay. Generally good fun. 7/10.

I'm not really a fan of Rory Calhoun, but I enjoyed his character in this picture. It tells a story with a bit more depth and a few surprises, while still providing action, romance and some terrific western scenery. While Calhoun's character, Chino Bull, is still country-suave and in control, he doesn't convey the snide quality that was an undercurrent in his later television work. The story line carries some standard western baggage, but at the same time it veers away with unexpected plot developments that were a bit more sophisticated than the type of that era, presaging the so-called "adult westerns" that became the standard in the 1950s and '60s. The female characters, unfortunately, are given the usual supportive roles. Still, it's an interesting story against some beautiful backgrounds.

More than Lose Remake of "My Darling Clementine" (1940) the John Ford Classic.

Rory Calhoun Vehicle with a Smattering of Gun-Play with a "Powder River" Ferry-Boat Scene a Highlight.

Good Cast with Cameron Mitchell as the Doomed Doctor and Corinne Calvet as "Frenchy" a Fiesty Saloon-Owner-Gal making an Impression.

Never Reaching Heights of its Own, the Movie is Watchable for the Cast, Technicolor, and Proven Story.

Rory Calhoun is a bit More Animated than Usual.

The First-Half is the Better Half.

But Still Maintains Enough Interest to Carry yet Another 1950's Western to its Predicable Feel-Good Exit for Post-War Western Fans who were Legion.