Mandy Garland wurde taub geboren und ist darum auch stumm. Ihre Eltern glauben, dass sie sprechen lernen kann, sind sich aber nicht einig, wo und bei wem sie das lernen kann.Mandy Garland wurde taub geboren und ist darum auch stumm. Ihre Eltern glauben, dass sie sprechen lernen kann, sind sich aber nicht einig, wo und bei wem sie das lernen kann.Mandy Garland wurde taub geboren und ist darum auch stumm. Ihre Eltern glauben, dass sie sprechen lernen kann, sind sich aber nicht einig, wo und bei wem sie das lernen kann.
- Regie
- Drehbuch
- Hauptbesetzung
- Nominiert für 6 BAFTA Awards
- 1 Gewinn & 7 Nominierungen insgesamt
Empfohlene Bewertungen
This film also has archetypal characters to a degree, but focuses on children and disability in a unique way. It has strong women and incredible directing of actors. So much of the film hinges on displaying realisations and moral questioning, wordless reactions. It hinges on people changing and evolving. The film has a real sense of humanity and vulnerability.
It has a delicate visual flair, a use of space and lighting. Two round lights bouncing off a pair of glasses. A child running through a large, wide empty hallway filmed with a short focal length. A wisp of smoke trailing over a face through a dissolve.
Phyllis Calvert deserved more recognition for her acting and didn't have the career she deserved. Mandy Miller's subtle, vulnerable performance for a child actress is a rare feat. Jack Hawkins is stunning as ever. It pains me that Alexander Mackendrick's directing didn't flourish. Mandy and The Lady Killers showed he could have been an interesting voice in modernist, New Wave cinema in the 60s. Unfortunately, his career was in turmoil by the late 50s. At the very least, we can cherish what he made at the summit of his craft.
When Mandy's parents find out she is deaf, they have differing ideas on what to do next. Mother, Christine, wants to send Mandy to a special school for deaf children so she can learn to read and write - and perhaps speak - and be as much like other children as possible. But her father, Harry, is somewhat ashamed of his daughter and would rather keep Mandy hidden away at his parents' house with only a governess to teach her the finger alphabet. After seeing how she reacts with other children, Christine realises that for Mandy's sake she must get her to the school, and leaves Harry. Watching Mandy's progress in the school provides some fascinating insight into ways of teaching and, contrary to Harry's thoughts, she does progress, with help from headmaster Searle. A second storyline is developed here as people increasingly believe that Christine is having an affair with Searle, when in fact they are both only interested in the good of the child.
A real "four tissue" movie, 10/10.
If you have the opportunity to watch this movie, watch it! I give it a big 10 out of 10.
Wusstest du schon
- WissenswertesAlexander Mackendrick deliberately chose not to cast a real deaf-mute in the title role as he felt that they subconsciously always wanted to make it appear as if they understood what was being said to them, even when they didn't.
- PatzerWhen Harry Garland, Mandy's father, precipitously leaves the flat where Mandy and Christine are staying, he departs empty handed. In the next scene, coming out of the taxi, he has the bag he had brought into the flat.
- Zitate
Christine Garland: [heated argument] Don't you see? Because she isn't used to them that this sort of thing happens. She must learn to live with other children.
Harry Garland: We've had this out over fifty times. We've all tried to explain it.
Christine Garland: All? You mean you and your family. Your father who's so lazy he wouldn't lift a finger to help and your mother who uses Mandy as something to gush about and sentimentalise over like a, like a spinster with a lap dog.
Harry Garland: CHRIS.
Christine Garland: And YOU are ashamed of Mandy... wanting to keep her out of sight. YOU and your kindness, you don't care a wrap about her.
Harry Garland: Shut-up!
Christine Garland: All you care about is yourself, you'd rather she remain dumb!
- VerbindungenFeatured in Film Profile: Michael Balcon (1961)
Top-Auswahl
- How long is Crash of Silence?Powered by Alexa
Details
- Erscheinungsdatum
- Herkunftsland
- Sprache
- Auch bekannt als
- Crash of Silence
- Drehorte
- Produktionsfirmen
- Weitere beteiligte Unternehmen bei IMDbPro anzeigen
- Laufzeit
- 1 Std. 33 Min.(93 min)
- Farbe
- Seitenverhältnis
- 1.33 : 1