Hypothetical

How good each episode of a show like this is will always be heavily dependent on the guests that week. Unfortunately that's a problem here, when you have to Google half of the them just to see who they are. And it quickly becomes clear that they aren't better known because they just aren't funny or entertaining. However, there are some good moments, and James Acaster is really the biggest reason to watch it.

Seems like the guys on the show are having a nice time but really not enjoying it. Contrived, enineered and the opposite of what's it's meant to be.. competition between 2 teams? Sadly, not for me.

A pleasantly unpretentious Dave comedy vehicle where different comedians were asked hypothetical questions - Acaster and Widdicome are a fine hosting pair and there's a warm natural energy to it all with the kind of breathlessly joyful improv not seen since the days of Whose Line. It can vary depending on the guests but you can tell Widdicome and co have a lark putting the thing together and I always hold a particular personal affection for it because it's one of the few TV things I've ever seen recorded live which was a hoot.

While James and Josh are funny on other panel shows (would I lie to you, QI etc) Hypothetical just isn't funny and neither of them can raise this show to those levels. At an hour long it's actually painful waiting for a genuinely funny moment to happen. Gave it a go but have given up now, it's mediocre at best. The Dave channel really needs to try a lot harder to find a replacement for Taskmaster.

I love James acaster and really like Josh Widdicombe, when he's not pushing an agenda on The Last Leg. The fact they're close mates adds to the show also.

The premise for the show isnsolid, but the quality really does depend on the guests and whether you like them or not.

So don't expect to like every episode but it's worth watching.

Although I will say that it seems to be the same current crop of "Dave" comedians doing the rounds so if you're not a fan of Taskmaster, Ultimate Worrier, Judge Romesh, Dave Gorman's new one (i forget the name) and those types of shows, this probably isn't for you.

Fingaz MC.