I'd like to start by saying the American Panel of Judges consists of RuPaul (who is in no way fit to be a judge on such a TV show). Not only is he extremely unprofessional, he sings (however not professionally in a sense where he releases music. He's more focused on entertainment like his Drag Race Show) and doesn't actually have the skill to properly critique acts on the show. He is great in entertainment and that's where he should remain. The way he reacted when Dimash asked to leave the competition was completely unprofessional and disrespectful (not to mention extremely dramatic and unnecessary as well). Not only did it show him off as a terrible judge, but also as a terrible human being. Dimash clearly said the reason why he was leaving the competition was because he personally felt it was unfair for him to be competing with 2 young children and be judged equally where he had many more years of practice and his vocals are much more mature than theirs. He was also made unaware that children would be participating in the competition, otherwise he would've never joined. I love Drew Barrymore as an actress, and even though she sings, it doesn't mean she has the musical ear to critique people's singing. Just because someone can sing, doesn't mean they are all fit to be judges. Not every singer has a musical ear in a sense they can identify a real artist. Faith Hill, never heard of her until the show so I cannot give my opinion on her in terms of music. The overall reaction from the panel was completely disappointing and only showed me, as a viewer, that they are extremely shallow. If they were frustrated about losing such a talent like Dimash, they could've expressed that frustration without having to insult the guy and basically tell him to suck it up it's a competition. There are morals and ethics and whatever one believes, he/she shouldn't be compelled to go against their beliefs. He felt it was unfair to compete against children, so as judges and MATURE adults, they should've communicated their frustrations better and not attack the artist. As for the whole concept where combined the American judges get 50 points and the rest of the world get 50 is unfair and biased (especially since the show is called The WORLD"S Best). Each judge should have an equal vote whether it be yes or no, or a rating of 0-50. Overall, I wouldn't recommend this show to anyone nor would I be looking forward for another season. There are much better shows out there that are talent based and entertaining at the same time like all the (Country) Idols, Talents and The Voice shows.
