IMDb-BEWERTUNG
7,4/10
6264
IHRE BEWERTUNG
Die Geschichte von Nisha, Tochter einer pakistanisch-norwegischen Familie, die von ihren Eltern nach Pakistan entführt wird, als ihr Vater sie im Bett mit einem Mann findet.Die Geschichte von Nisha, Tochter einer pakistanisch-norwegischen Familie, die von ihren Eltern nach Pakistan entführt wird, als ihr Vater sie im Bett mit einem Mann findet.Die Geschichte von Nisha, Tochter einer pakistanisch-norwegischen Familie, die von ihren Eltern nach Pakistan entführt wird, als ihr Vater sie im Bett mit einem Mann findet.
- Auszeichnungen
- 17 Gewinne & 14 Nominierungen insgesamt
Empfohlene Bewertungen
... burst a blood vessel, up the heart rate, wind the moral compass spring to its limit; to blow-a-fuse, to frustrate and anger and despair and to hope, to hope, that the story makes a difference to anyone/someone having their basic human rights removed - no matter who or what or where they are and regardless of who's controlling them, to have hope that it can and will change and get better and to know that they are not alone.
"Hva vil folk si" follows the story of a young Norwegian-Pakistani woman Nisa and the horrors that she faces in the hands of her family in the name of culture. These are one among thousands of horror stories that happen to people of the developing world. Though the developed countries have matured culturally, the developing world is far behind and still treat grown up children like property.
Director Iram Haq gives life to her own ordeal and the horrors that she faced as a young woman. Ably supported by her lead actor Maria Mozhdah, who in a tremendous performance will steal our hearts and sympathies equally. Brilliant cinematography and editing are a plus factors to this low budgeted film. Supporting actors too have done a decent job. Sync sound is used to great effect to kindle our emotions.
It is a must watch movie for the developed world, just to understand how culturally different they are from the rest. I believe that Religious Parents in the developing world wouldn't give a hoot to the contents in Hva vil folk si but liberal parents can learn a thing or two. One should take care of their children till they are about 12, Only guide them and support them as teenagers, at 18 they should be able to decide for themselves. The children have come to live their lives in this world not ours.
Director Iram Haq gives life to her own ordeal and the horrors that she faced as a young woman. Ably supported by her lead actor Maria Mozhdah, who in a tremendous performance will steal our hearts and sympathies equally. Brilliant cinematography and editing are a plus factors to this low budgeted film. Supporting actors too have done a decent job. Sync sound is used to great effect to kindle our emotions.
It is a must watch movie for the developed world, just to understand how culturally different they are from the rest. I believe that Religious Parents in the developing world wouldn't give a hoot to the contents in Hva vil folk si but liberal parents can learn a thing or two. One should take care of their children till they are about 12, Only guide them and support them as teenagers, at 18 they should be able to decide for themselves. The children have come to live their lives in this world not ours.
Some Pakistanis would vociferously scream that the portrayal of Pakistani culture and norms is blatantly exaggerated here. Well, let me tell you. It isnt. Pakistani parents, including those who live abroad are willing to sacrifice and kill their daughters if there need be for the sake of their honour. The typical middle class man's obsession with his daughters chastity is certainly not exaggerated. The film beautifully captures the diaspora, the claustrophobia and the contradictory nature of Nisha's life. The last scene in which her fathers reflection stares at us is brilliant.
But some things are sure exaggerated. I donot know if those stem out of ignorance or a desire to appease the "white audience" with their saviour complex. I do not know if they tried to portray Islamabad or Quetta in the movie-if it was Islamabad then it was obviously very wrongly portrayed. It is a fully developed urban city with internet connection. Same with Quetta. One does not need to run to far off stores in search of internet! Also who in their right minds would make out in a street in Pakistan unless you live in Defence or something? I mean maybe the police can react the way they did in the movie but thats rare and pertaining to the special circumstance that both the people are very young and from a familiar area. I can understand this because I am a Pakistani but one might make a lot of assumptions if they arent. Moreover, everything that Nisha went through was very very traumatic. Her grief and sanity still seems pretty intact for someone who went through a lifetime of trauma. Still very willing to please her parents. Or maybe thats my peronal opinion.
All that aside, donot sit without grabbing a tissue paper because this is a highly unsettling movie.
Very good movie, all actors are very good, the performance of Maria is superb,you can feel her feelings even when she is silent..the movie shows the problem a girl faces because of two different cultures, this clash of cultures is not only a problem of pakistan but it is a reality all around the world
I wish I had the guts and courage to talk about what happens to me as a girl in Iran.
Thank you Iram Hag for this movie.
Wusstest du schon
- WissenswertesThe story idea came from the Director's real life incident. She was once kidnapped to Pakistan.
- SoundtracksTum
Written by Mansi Multani, Ishaan Divecha and Naren Chandavarkar
Performed by Mansi Multani and Ishaan Divecha
Top-Auswahl
Melde dich zum Bewerten an und greife auf die Watchlist für personalisierte Empfehlungen zu.
- How long is What Will People Say?Powered by Alexa
Details
- Erscheinungsdatum
- Herkunftsländer
- Offizielle Standorte
- Sprachen
- Auch bekannt als
- What Will People Say
- Drehorte
- Norwegen(location)
- Produktionsfirmen
- Weitere beteiligte Unternehmen bei IMDbPro anzeigen
Box Office
- Bruttoertrag in den USA und Kanada
- 44.156 $
- Eröffnungswochenende in den USA und in Kanada
- 4.024 $
- 15. Juli 2018
- Weltweiter Bruttoertrag
- 2.191.131 $
- Laufzeit1 Stunde 46 Minuten
- Seitenverhältnis
- 2.35 : 1
Zu dieser Seite beitragen
Bearbeitung vorschlagen oder fehlenden Inhalt hinzufügen