* NFL Most Valuable Player
* NFL Offensive Player of the Year
* NFL Comeback Player of the Year
* NFL Man of the Year
* 3× First-team All-Pro
* 3× Second-team All-Pro
* 9× Pro Bowl
* 5× NFL passing yards leader
* 3× NFL passing touchdowns leader
* NFL passer rating leader
* NFL 100th Anniversary All-Time Team
* PFWA All-Rookie Team
* George Halas Award
* Bert Bell Award
* Miami Dolphins Honor Roll
* Miami Dolphins No. 13 retired
* Dolphins Walk of Fame
* First-team All-American
* First-team All-East
* Pittsburgh Panthers No. 13 retired
;NFL records
* Lowest sack percentage, season: 1.0%
* Most seasons leading league, completions: 6
* Most seasons leading league, pass attempts: 5 (en)