I loved the idea of this mod. And I think the voice actors were great and sounded pretty good for not being the originals.

My issue is with the puzzles.

I finished both Portal games by myself. I think I used a walkthrough for the first one towards the ending because I was getting lost in the backrooms and just did not know where to go. But that was just one point, and it wasn't a puzzle so much as trying to find the right direction.

There's no direction here. I can't solve the puzzles because I don't even know where I'm trying to get to.

The first real puzzle I got to, I spotted a button after lots of looking around, developed a strategy to get to the button, executed my strategy ... and then the button did nothing because the rest of the wall it was attached to had rotted away. I stood there, looking around for some alternate goal I had missed, and saw ... nothing.

I could see other things to put portals on, but nothing that indicated a way out. Everything else was back the way I came. Without a clear goal, there's no puzzle to solve, so I'm out. I'm not a "throw random crap around until something happens because I'm bored" kind of person. I'm a "I need to accomplish this task, so I should experiment with things that look like they will move me forward on accomplishing this task" kind of person. This set up isn't working for me.

everything about this mod is wonderful, especially the price.... except cave's voice. it seems there wasn't any effort to find a suitable actor or even try to sound more like johnsmanne. I got pretty excited going into the relaxation chamber hoping that it was going to age up his voice. nope.

classic mod