The 'ball on a string' demonstration is a common tool used in physics education to illustrate the concept of conservation of angular momentum. However, various confounding factors can cause significant deviations from the idealized case, particularly under extreme conditions or when using low-stiffness pivots or high coefficients of friction. These factors include air resistance, contact friction at the pivot point, the mass of the ball and string, the angle of the string due to gravity, and the wobbling of the pivot point due to the centrifugal forces acting on it. In this work, we critically review by means of accurate simulations the adequateness of the 'ball on a string' demonstration in view of these confounding factors and provide recommendations for instructors on how to maximize the educational value of the demonstration while minimizing potential confusion for students. Our analysis suggests that a stiff pivot and avoiding extreme conditions are key to obtaining results that are in good agreement with the idealized case. We also caution instructors against using the demonstration without at least mentioning the confounding factors, as this may lead to a questionable understanding of the underlying physics principles.
Education
Education
International journals dedicated to maintaining and improving the standard of taught physics at all levels, from schools through to universities.
Sign up and opt in to receive the latest research, journal and ebook news in physics education.
Featured journals
Explore research and reviews
On the ball on a string demonstration of angular momentum conservation
Affordable methods for surface tension and contact angle measurements
Physics language and language use in physics—What do we know and how AI might enhance language-related research and instruction
How understanding large language models can inform the use of ChatGPT in physics education
Eponyms in physics: useful tools and cultural heritage
How often does unguided peer interaction lead to correct response consensus? An example from conceptual survey of electricity and magnetism
What topics of peer interactions correlate with student performance in physics courses?
Latest from us
Physics Education at home: DIY activities for home learning
With many schools and colleges around the globe currently shut due to the ongoing COVID-19 pandemic, here are some articles from the vast Physics Education archive, to help provide some inspiration for teachers and students alike. These peer reviewed articles tend to be aimed at older school students but may be suitable for 14-16 year olds and in a few cases even younger students. Articles have been chosen that do not require specialist materials and so can be carried out at home. Read the full collection here.