Improve Workspaces example configuration and debugging guidance
Problem to solve
The current Workspaces example devfile
config causes some issues for users:
- The example
devfile
uses an image that lacks development tools, such as Yarn, causingpostStart
commands to fail with "not found" errors. - Users struggle to understand why
postStart
commands fail because:- Logs show "Finished running" even when commands fail.
- Log locations are not clearly documented.
- No guidance on how to debug
postStart
issues.
- The
postStart
logs indicate completion without indicating success/failure status
Further details
Use cases and scenarios:
- Developers setting up Workspaces for frontend projects requiring Node.js/yarn.
- Teams configuring
devfiles
for projects with specific tooling requirements. - Users debugging failed
postStart
commands.
Current user journey problems:
- User follows example configuration from docs.
-
postStart
commands fail silently (yarn not found). - User assumes everything worked because logs show "Finished running".
- User discovers the issue only when trying to access the application.
- User needs to hunt through multiple log files to find actual error messages.
Proposal
-
Update example configuration:
- Use a more complete base image that includes common development tools or provide clear guidance on installing dependencies in
postStart
.
- Use a more complete base image that includes common development tools or provide clear guidance on installing dependencies in
-
Improve debugging docs:
- Add clear section on "Debugging
postStart
Commands" - Document log file locations. For example,
/projects/workspace-logs/poststart-stdout.log
andpoststart-stderr.log
- Explain how to access logs through VS Code File menu.
- Add troubleshooting topics.
- Add clear section on "Debugging
-
Enhance logging clarity:
- Document that "Finished running" doesn't mean "completed successfully".
- Add note about checking logs for errors.
Additional content to consider:
-
Create comprehensive guide sections:
- "Choosing the right base image" guide.
- "Setting up custom images" tutorial.
- "Common
postStart
patterns" examples.
-
Add practical examples:
- Frontend project setup (Node.js/yarn/npm)
- Backend project setup (Python/Ruby/etc.)
- Multi-language project configurations
Other links/references
- Related epic for broader Workspaces adoption: Enable Workspaces Dogfooding for non-GDK Engine... (&17034)
- Original Slack discussion thread
Edited by 🤖 GitLab Bot 🤖