Job timeout risk: ee/spec/features/merge_request/user_edits_approval_rules_mr_spec.rb ran much longer than expected
Everyone can contribute. Help move this issue forward while earning points, leveling up and collecting rewards.
Why was this issue created?
ee/spec/features/merge_request/user_edits_approval_rules_mr_spec.rb was reported to have:
- exceeded Knapsack's expected runtime by at least 50%, and
- been identified as a notable pipeline bottleneck and a job timeout risk
Suggested steps for investigation
- To reproduce in CI by running test files in the same order, you can follow the steps listed here.
- Identify if a specific test case is stalling the run time. Hint: You can search the job's log for
Starting example group ee/spec/features/merge_request/user_edits_approval_rules_mr_spec.rband view the elapsed time after each test case in the proceeding lines starting with[RSpecRunTime]. - If the test file is large, consider refactoring it into multiple files to allow better test parallelization across runners.
- If the run time cannot be fixed in time, consider quarantine the spec(s) to restore performance.
Run time details
- Reported from pipeline 2562790 created at
2024-03-21T10:08:12Z
| Field | Value |
|---|---|
| Job URL | rspec-ee-system-pg14-single-db-11-14 |
| Job total RSpec suite run time | expected: 27 minutes 26.77 seconds, actual: 80 minutes 44.91 seconds
|
| Spec file run time | expected: 35.1 seconds, actual: 12 minutes 41.9 seconds
|
| Spec file weight |
15.73% of total suite run time |
- Reported from pipeline 2564875 created at
2024-03-21T19:46:39Z
| Field | Value |
|---|---|
| Job URL | rspec-ee-system-pg14-single-db-ci-connection-7-14 |
| Job total RSpec suite run time | expected: 27 minutes 31.45 seconds, actual: 83 minutes 25.68 seconds
|
| Spec file run time | expected: 35.14 seconds, actual: 13 minutes 4.66 seconds
|
| Spec file weight |
15.68% of total suite run time |
- Reported from pipeline 2721159 created at
2024-05-01T21:05:05Z
| Field | Value |
|---|---|
| Job URL | rspec-ee-system-pg14-single-db-8-14 |
| Job total RSpec suite run time | expected: 23 minutes 49.68 seconds, actual: 80 minutes 38.86 seconds
|
| Spec file run time | expected: 28.57 seconds, actual: 13 minutes 44.47 seconds
|
| Spec file weight |
17.04% of total suite run time |
- Reported from pipeline 2770852 created at
2024-05-14T15:11:34Z
| Field | Value |
|---|---|
| Job URL | rspec-ee-system-pg14-single-db-ci-connection-7-14 |
| Job total RSpec suite run time | expected: 25 minutes 4.79 seconds, actual: 80 minutes 34.03 seconds
|
| Spec file run time | expected: 31.25 seconds, actual: 14 minutes 39.94 seconds
|
| Spec file weight |
18.2% of total suite run time |
- Reported from pipeline 2778128 created at
2024-05-16T01:15:48Z
| Field | Value |
|---|---|
| Job URL | rspec-ee-system-pg16-opensearch1-13-14 |
| Job total RSpec suite run time | expected: 25 minutes 19.92 seconds, actual: 79 minutes 58.9 seconds
|
| Spec file run time | expected: 33.35 seconds, actual: 13 minutes 53.52 seconds
|
| Spec file weight |
17.37% of total suite run time |
- Reported from pipeline 2914894 created at
2024-06-22T05:10:39Z
| Field | Value |
|---|---|
| Job URL | rspec-ee-system-pg14-12-14 |
| Job total RSpec suite run time | expected: 26 minutes 42.97 seconds, actual: 70 minutes 0.12 second
|
| Spec file run time | expected: 29.38 seconds, actual: 12 minutes 50.4 seconds
|
| Spec file weight |
18.34% of total suite run time |
- Reported from pipeline 2945567 created at
2024-06-28T15:53:21Z
| Field | Value |
|---|---|
| Job URL | rspec-ee-system-pg14-single-db-4-14 |
| Job total RSpec suite run time | expected: 26 minutes 21.08 seconds, actual: 81 minutes 32.68 seconds
|
| Spec file run time | expected: 29.37 seconds, actual: 12 minutes 39.74 seconds
|
| Spec file weight |
15.53% of total suite run time |
- Reported from pipeline 2951567 created at
2024-07-01T13:22:18Z
| Field | Value |
|---|---|
| Job URL | rspec-ee-system-pg14-6-14 |
| Job total RSpec suite run time | expected: 25 minutes 23.59 seconds, actual: 70 minutes 49.11 seconds
|
| Spec file run time | expected: 28.62 seconds, actual: 12 minutes 42.91 seconds
|
| Spec file weight |
17.95% of total suite run time |
- Reported from pipeline 2996543 created at
2024-07-12T07:54:32Z
| Field | Value |
|---|---|
| Job URL | rspec-ee-system-pg14-14-14 |
| Job total RSpec suite run time | expected: 25 minutes 45.28 seconds, actual: 80 minutes 24.94 seconds
|
| Spec file run time | expected: 33.94 seconds, actual: 13 minutes 46.23 seconds
|
| Spec file weight |
17.12% of total suite run time |
- Reported from pipeline 3087310 created at
2024-08-07T18:37:32Z
| Field | Value |
|---|---|
| Job URL | rspec-ee-system-pg14-8-16 |
| Job total RSpec suite run time | expected: 24 minutes 42.25 seconds, actual: 78 minutes 33.86 seconds
|
| Spec file run time | expected: 33.21 seconds, actual: 12 minutes 36.29 seconds
|
| Spec file weight |
16.04% of total suite run time |
- Reported from pipeline 3087357 created at
2024-08-07T18:48:57Z
| Field | Value |
|---|---|
| Job URL | rspec-ee-system-pg14-single-db-ci-connection-8-16 |
| Job total RSpec suite run time | expected: 24 minutes 42.25 seconds, actual: 81 minutes 3.9 seconds
|
| Spec file run time | expected: 33.21 seconds, actual: 12 minutes 44.32 seconds
|
| Spec file weight |
15.71% of total suite run time |
- Reported from pipeline 3203807 created at
2024-09-12T07:18:01Z
| Field | Value |
|---|---|
| Job URL | rspec-ee-system-pg14-9-16 |
| Job total RSpec suite run time | expected: 25 minutes 41.34 seconds, actual: 77 minutes 50.1 seconds
|
| Spec file run time | expected: 33.19 seconds, actual: 12 minutes 34.27 seconds
|
| Spec file weight |
16.15% of total suite run time |
- Reported from pipeline 3231198 created at
2024-09-20T09:31:32Z
| Field | Value |
|---|---|
| Job URL | rspec-ee-system-pg14-8-16 |
| Job total RSpec suite run time | expected: 25 minutes 12.95 seconds, actual: 80 minutes 16.98 seconds
|
| Spec file run time | expected: 33.56 seconds, actual: 12 minutes 59.29 seconds
|
| Spec file weight |
16.18% of total suite run time |
- Reported from pipeline 3374171 created at
2024-10-29T09:19:21Z
| Field | Value |
|---|---|
| Job URL | rspec-ee-system-pg14-7-16 |
| Job total RSpec suite run time | expected: 23 minutes 45.72 seconds, actual: 81 minutes 0.41 second
|
| Spec file run time | expected: 28.46 seconds, actual: 12 minutes 47.89 seconds
|
| Spec file weight |
15.8% of total suite run time |
- Reported from pipeline 3468273 created at
2024-11-19T08:59:16Z
| Field | Value |
|---|---|
| Job URL | rspec-ee-system-pg14-13-16 |
| Job total RSpec suite run time | expected: 22 minutes 52.88 seconds, actual: 82 minutes 1.61 seconds
|
| Spec file run time | expected: 33.3 seconds, actual: 12 minutes 39.75 seconds
|
| Spec file weight |
15.44% of total suite run time |
- Reported from pipeline 3497919 created at
2024-11-25T23:21:23Z
| Field | Value |
|---|---|
| Job URL | rspec-ee-system-pg14-single-db-ci-connection-11-16 |
| Job total RSpec suite run time | expected: 24 minutes 9.15 seconds, actual: 80 minutes 42.37 seconds
|
| Spec file run time | expected: 32.76 seconds, actual: 12 minutes 49.49 seconds
|
| Spec file weight |
15.89% of total suite run time |
- Reported from pipeline 3565671 created at
2024-12-11T07:25:23Z
| Field | Value |
|---|---|
| Job URL | rspec-ee-system-pg14-7-16 |
| Job total RSpec suite run time | expected: 23 minutes 17.22 seconds, actual: 80 minutes 52.39 seconds
|
| Spec file run time | expected: 29.86 seconds, actual: 13 minutes 53.48 seconds
|
| Spec file weight |
17.18% of total suite run time |
- Reported from pipeline 3618977 created at
2024-12-27T20:58:24Z
| Field | Value |
|---|---|
| Job URL | rspec-ee-system-pg14-es8-12-16 |
| Job total RSpec suite run time | expected: 23 minutes 58.62 seconds, actual: 71 minutes 21.09 seconds
|
| Spec file run time | expected: 31.26 seconds, actual: 12 minutes 46.13 seconds
|
| Spec file weight |
17.9% of total suite run time |
- Reported from pipeline 3682116 created at
2025-01-15T18:08:09Z
| Field | Value |
|---|---|
| Job URL | rspec-ee-system-pg14-13-16 |
| Job total RSpec suite run time | expected: 24 minutes 42.43 seconds, actual: 80 minutes 35.05 seconds
|
| Spec file run time | expected: 31.06 seconds, actual: 12 minutes 49.15 seconds
|
| Spec file weight |
15.91% of total suite run time |
- Reported from pipeline 3721317 created at
2025-01-24T22:00:31Z
| Field | Value |
|---|---|
| Job URL | rspec-ee-system-pg14-9-16 |
| Job total RSpec suite run time | expected: 26 minutes 0.78 second, actual: 79 minutes 51.72 seconds
|
| Spec file run time | expected: 36.61 seconds, actual: 12 minutes 40.5 seconds
|
| Spec file weight |
15.87% of total suite run time |
- Reported from pipeline 3733516 created at
2025-01-28T17:49:23Z
| Field | Value |
|---|---|
| Job URL | rspec-ee-system-pg14-7-16 |
| Job total RSpec suite run time | expected: 25 minutes 9.95 seconds, actual: 70 minutes 27.96 seconds
|
| Spec file run time | expected: 30.16 seconds, actual: 12 minutes 42.99 seconds
|
| Spec file weight |
18.05% of total suite run time |
- Reported from pipeline 3759367 created at
2025-02-03T16:31:54Z
| Field | Value |
|---|---|
| Job URL | rspec-ee-system-pg14-single-db-15-16 |
| Job total RSpec suite run time | expected: 24 minutes 54.38 seconds, actual: 81 minutes 27.39 seconds
|
| Spec file run time | expected: 32.18 seconds, actual: 12 minutes 48.5 seconds
|
| Spec file weight |
15.72% of total suite run time |
- Reported from pipeline 3841998 created at
2025-02-24T08:49:33Z
| Field | Value |
|---|---|
| Job URL | rspec-ee-system-pg14-7-16 |
| Job total RSpec suite run time | expected: 24 minutes 59.86 seconds, actual: 80 minutes 3.71 seconds
|
| Spec file run time | expected: 28.88 seconds, actual: 12 minutes 43.73 seconds
|
| Spec file weight |
15.9% of total suite run time |
- Reported from pipeline 3932304 created at
2025-03-18T00:18:31Z
| Field | Value |
|---|---|
| Job URL | rspec-ee-system-pg16-single-db-ci-connection-12-16 |
| Job total RSpec suite run time | expected: 24 minutes 14.33 seconds, actual: 81 minutes 13.47 seconds
|
| Spec file run time | expected: 30.45 seconds, actual: 12 minutes 47.06 seconds
|
| Spec file weight |
15.74% of total suite run time |
- Reported from pipeline 4001879 created at
2025-04-03T18:09:39Z
| Field | Value |
|---|---|
| Job URL | rspec-ee-system-pg16-11-16 |
| Job total RSpec suite run time | expected: 24 minutes 34.71 seconds, actual: 79 minutes 54.59 seconds
|
| Spec file run time | expected: 33.1 seconds, actual: 12 minutes 42.32 seconds
|
| Spec file weight |
15.9% of total suite run time |
- Reported from pipeline 4095249 created at
2025-04-29T15:09:09Z
| Field | Value |
|---|---|
| Job URL | rspec-ee-system-pg16-10-16 |
| Job total RSpec suite run time | expected: 24 minutes 5.06 seconds, actual: 79 minutes 48.26 seconds
|
| Spec file run time | expected: 30.21 seconds, actual: 13 minutes 0.55 second
|
| Spec file weight |
16.3% of total suite run time |
- Reported from pipeline 4346788 created at
2025-07-08T09:27:11Z
| Field | Value |
|---|---|
| Job URL | rspec-ee-system-pg16-8-16 |
| Job total RSpec suite run time | expected: 24 minutes 3.85 seconds, actual: 72 minutes 26.29 seconds
|
| Spec file run time | expected: 32.1 seconds, actual: 12 minutes 48.85 seconds
|
| Spec file weight |
17.69% of total suite run time |
- Reported from pipeline 4486358 created at
2025-08-14T08:36:34Z
| Field | Value |
|---|---|
| Job URL | rspec-ee-system-pg16-3-16 |
| Job total RSpec suite run time | expected: 26 minutes 21.43 seconds, actual: 79 minutes 42.28 seconds
|
| Spec file run time | expected: 32.88 seconds, actual: 12 minutes 46.42 seconds
|
| Spec file weight |
16.03% of total suite run time |
- Reported from pipeline 4486311 created at
2025-08-14T08:24:04Z
| Field | Value |
|---|---|
| Job URL | rspec-ee-system-pg16-3-16 |
| Job total RSpec suite run time | expected: 26 minutes 21.43 seconds, actual: 79 minutes 56.49 seconds
|
| Spec file run time | expected: 32.88 seconds, actual: 12 minutes 42.04 seconds
|
| Spec file weight |
15.89% of total suite run time |
- Reported from pipeline 4499494 created at
2025-08-18T13:24:33Z
| Field | Value |
|---|---|
| Job URL | rspec-ee-system-pg16-12-16 |
| Job total RSpec suite run time | expected: 25 minutes 1.26 seconds, actual: 80 minutes 59.67 seconds
|
| Spec file run time | expected: 36.0 seconds, actual: 12 minutes 44.22 seconds
|
| Spec file weight |
15.73% of total suite run time |
- Reported from pipeline 4642079 created at
2025-09-23T15:47:12Z
| Field | Value |
|---|---|
| Job URL | rspec-ee-system-pg16-8-16 |
| Job total RSpec suite run time | expected: 27 minutes 53.67 seconds, actual: 82 minutes 31.13 seconds
|
| Spec file run time | expected: 36.05 seconds, actual: 12 minutes 37.98 seconds
|
| Spec file weight |
15.31% of total suite run time |
- Reported from pipeline 4649433 created at
2025-09-25T01:42:37Z
| Field | Value |
|---|---|
| Job URL | rspec-ee-system-pg16-es8-4-16 |
| Job total RSpec suite run time | expected: 28 minutes 38.34 seconds, actual: 73 minutes 24.01 seconds
|
| Spec file run time | expected: 35.73 seconds, actual: 12 minutes 47.32 seconds
|
| Spec file weight |
17.42% of total suite run time |
Edited by KNAPSACK_REPORT_ISSUES_PROJECT_TOKEN