[go: up one dir, main page]

Skip to content

Unresolved status of discussions is implied visually

Problem to solve

When I am moving from one unresolved discussion to the next, my position on the page is changing significantly and I might be scrolled up or down. And once I arrive at the next unresolved discussion, it is not visually distinct compared to notes (comments without a thread and therefore don't have a resolved/unresolved status).

When I am moving through many unresolved discussions on a larger merge request with 5, 10 or 20 unresolved discussions, there is not a clear sense of progress as I move through the review - it is simply next.

Further details

Proposal

  1. Add clearer visual designation of unresolved discussion threads.
  2. Add navigation options for unresolved discussions that provide more connection with the current page position.
Proposal 1 Proposal 2
2020-08-20T14.56.30 2020-08-20T14.59.31