Elise120

I really really wanted to love this movie. After all, the story is compelling and hits so close to home for me (my uncle was a defector of Hitler's SS and was executed for being a traitor). I'm also a fan of August Diehl who's a terrific actor. However, this film was too long, tedious and excessively melodramatic with Malick's typical self-indulgent style. His camerawork consists of wide angle shots, odd extreme closeups and annoyingly choppy jump-cuts which gave me a headache.

Probably one of the worst films I've ever seen. And I'm the type who tries to find some redeeming qualities in almost everything. This movie has none! Filled with plot holes and just plain bad screenwriting. I don't understand the 70% it has on Rotten Tomatoes.

Blackpool (released as Viva Blackpool in the US) is absolutely the best mini-series I've ever seen. It was unique, well written, directed and acted. Although both David Tennant and David Morrissey are wonderful actors, I felt that David Morrissey really stood out in his role of Ripley Holden. If anyone's seen any of his other work, they would see what an incredible actor he is!! And outrageously attractive as well. The musical numbers are well done. What a brilliant idea to have the actors sing along with the original artists, sort of like Karaoke. I was also impressed with new actor Tommy Morrisson, who played Danny Holden. I expect to see him in other films..he's very talented. Sarah Parrish is lovely and talented as always, and I'm looking forward to seeing David Tennant as Dr. Who. In conclusion, I highly recommend this series. I only wish that BBC would release the DVD for Region 1 soon, as my home VHS recording is getting worn from repeated viewings.