csaltun
Joined Feb 2009
Welcome to the new profile
We're still working on updating some profile features. To see the badges, ratings breakdowns, and polls for this profile, please go to the previous version.
Reviews8
csaltun's rating
Cem Yilmaz has a great reputation in Turkey. But seems he forgets that great reputation creates great expectations. I think this is the biggest problem Yilmaz faces now.
I have seen Ali Baba and the Seven Dwarfs and I can say that it didn't surprised me at all. I do not mean that its a typical "full of fun" CY movie, unfortunately the opposite way round.
First of all, the story itself is so poor, nothing interesting with screenplay. Its like CY had some jokes in his mind and created a story only to put those jokes in it.
Another problem with characters. I did not understand what some characters really do in the movie, why do they exist, what would be the lose if those characters do not exist etc etc.
Looks like CY found a formula for his movies somethings like:
Find some jokes + Create a simple script (No need to be smart but should contain everything your audiences expect) + Choose correct actors & actresses (The ones who already tested and liked by fans) + Put CY name on it = Collect your money
Simple but unfortunately there are some elements are missing in the formula. Such as, story, creating a character, plot, intelligence of viewers (The worst thing about this movie is that CY does not care about his fan's intelligence. He thinks that everybody is ready to eat whatever CY cooks. Of course, its so wrong.)
CY makes films one after another. Don't know if because he has many things to tell or want to earn as much as possible or ... just don't know. What I know is that CY may go really down if keeps following the same strategy. This would be a shame for a genius, so I hope he wakes up to himself immediately.
As a last word about the movie, its just a simple comedy. If I knew that before then Id not pay for it but wait until its on TV.
I have seen Ali Baba and the Seven Dwarfs and I can say that it didn't surprised me at all. I do not mean that its a typical "full of fun" CY movie, unfortunately the opposite way round.
First of all, the story itself is so poor, nothing interesting with screenplay. Its like CY had some jokes in his mind and created a story only to put those jokes in it.
Another problem with characters. I did not understand what some characters really do in the movie, why do they exist, what would be the lose if those characters do not exist etc etc.
Looks like CY found a formula for his movies somethings like:
Find some jokes + Create a simple script (No need to be smart but should contain everything your audiences expect) + Choose correct actors & actresses (The ones who already tested and liked by fans) + Put CY name on it = Collect your money
Simple but unfortunately there are some elements are missing in the formula. Such as, story, creating a character, plot, intelligence of viewers (The worst thing about this movie is that CY does not care about his fan's intelligence. He thinks that everybody is ready to eat whatever CY cooks. Of course, its so wrong.)
CY makes films one after another. Don't know if because he has many things to tell or want to earn as much as possible or ... just don't know. What I know is that CY may go really down if keeps following the same strategy. This would be a shame for a genius, so I hope he wakes up to himself immediately.
As a last word about the movie, its just a simple comedy. If I knew that before then Id not pay for it but wait until its on TV.
I just watched movie after waiting for months. As I am a Behzat Ç. series fan, I need to say that the movie is not good as I expected.
Its just a longer version of what we see on TV, so even I can not call this as a movie.
Similar to its TV version, the weakest point is the screenplay. They just wrote a simple screenplay and decked it out with acting, slang etc.
Besides its negative points, the performance of Erdal Beşikçioğlu is noticeable again. Honestly I am not happy with the movie and looking for new season on TV to decide to follow or quit watching it.
Its just a longer version of what we see on TV, so even I can not call this as a movie.
Similar to its TV version, the weakest point is the screenplay. They just wrote a simple screenplay and decked it out with acting, slang etc.
Besides its negative points, the performance of Erdal Beşikçioğlu is noticeable again. Honestly I am not happy with the movie and looking for new season on TV to decide to follow or quit watching it.
I stopped watching Mr. Night's movies I think after watching either Signs or Village. Actually it does not matter because all his movies are the same as they use the success of 6th Sense which was the only OK movie of him.
If I have nothing else to do and have a Shyamalan movie then I would sit on my chair and stay there by doing nothing for 2 hours but not watch another Shyamalan trash.
I will definitely not watch the Airbender just because of the director.
Oh my god, I remember the girl in the water.. I need to forget it immediately....
If I have nothing else to do and have a Shyamalan movie then I would sit on my chair and stay there by doing nothing for 2 hours but not watch another Shyamalan trash.
I will definitely not watch the Airbender just because of the director.
Oh my god, I remember the girl in the water.. I need to forget it immediately....