ashkumar-1
Joined Jun 2008
Welcome to the new profile
We're making some updates, and some features will be temporarily unavailable while we enhance your experience. The previous version will not be accessible after 7/14. Stay tuned for the upcoming relaunch.
Badges6
To learn how to earn badges, go to the badges help page.
Reviews5
ashkumar-1's rating
I ask this question to myself, "What's the point of a war?" I got the answer from Professor Moriarty in the Game of Shadows that he wants to own the bullets & bandages. Perhaps it's always the business interest of individuals (& now nations) that orchestrate a war. Now who's got the most to lose in a war? It seems like it's always the Women and Children. So when we view that war from their eyes, we can feel the blunt of the problems the war has led to. Childish this statement be, If only the world leaders had seen issues through the eyes of kids, plenty of bloodshed in the twentieth century could have been avoided.
What's the relevance of the above paragraph with the movie, "The Boy in the Striped Pyjamas"?
We get to see the Holocaust in the eyes of a kid! Actually a German Kid, who happens to be the son of the Commander of the Auschwitz Concentration Camp. Does it matter to the German kid, whether the kid he befriends is a Jew? Does it matter if that Jewish kid is on the other side of the fence? Is it a big deal if he wants to cross the fence that separates them? As grown-ups we know the seriousness of the last question. But obviously the kid doesn't know that!
The movie is made up of moments that shows us how the world around the Kid is trying to create a perception of the Jews. The tutor, the Nazi guard, kid's father & Grandfather represent the Nazi propaganda. The Kid's Grandmother (although she appears once) represents the anti- Nazi view. I couldn't understand the stand of the Kid's mother. Probably someone who's not anti-Nazi but at the same time wants to be away from the mess. The Kid's sister is the perfect teenager who has fallen for the Nazi propaganda.
In such scenarios, I wonder is it wrong to steal food so that you can help a hungry kid? No. Our established morals have to go for a toss but does it matter? No. The biggest success of this movie is that any viewer who has seen quite a few Holocaust movies, would understand what's happening on screen. They need not show anything explicitly. That adds to the poignancy although not to a level of Roberto Benigni's Life is Beautiful.
Keeping aside all that I've said above, the movie is a must watch for the heart wrenching final few minutes. It can move even the iron hearted to tears.
Do watch it when you get time! I've tried my level best to avoid any spoilers.
Additional titbits about the movie
1. The movie was a novel adaptation of Irish writer John Boyne's The Boy in the Striped Pyjamas.
What's the relevance of the above paragraph with the movie, "The Boy in the Striped Pyjamas"?
We get to see the Holocaust in the eyes of a kid! Actually a German Kid, who happens to be the son of the Commander of the Auschwitz Concentration Camp. Does it matter to the German kid, whether the kid he befriends is a Jew? Does it matter if that Jewish kid is on the other side of the fence? Is it a big deal if he wants to cross the fence that separates them? As grown-ups we know the seriousness of the last question. But obviously the kid doesn't know that!
The movie is made up of moments that shows us how the world around the Kid is trying to create a perception of the Jews. The tutor, the Nazi guard, kid's father & Grandfather represent the Nazi propaganda. The Kid's Grandmother (although she appears once) represents the anti- Nazi view. I couldn't understand the stand of the Kid's mother. Probably someone who's not anti-Nazi but at the same time wants to be away from the mess. The Kid's sister is the perfect teenager who has fallen for the Nazi propaganda.
In such scenarios, I wonder is it wrong to steal food so that you can help a hungry kid? No. Our established morals have to go for a toss but does it matter? No. The biggest success of this movie is that any viewer who has seen quite a few Holocaust movies, would understand what's happening on screen. They need not show anything explicitly. That adds to the poignancy although not to a level of Roberto Benigni's Life is Beautiful.
Keeping aside all that I've said above, the movie is a must watch for the heart wrenching final few minutes. It can move even the iron hearted to tears.
Do watch it when you get time! I've tried my level best to avoid any spoilers.
Additional titbits about the movie
1. The movie was a novel adaptation of Irish writer John Boyne's The Boy in the Striped Pyjamas.
Its a blemish that Tamil cinema has not entertained Novel Adaptations. I'm sort of surprised that the best directors in the industry till date are not ready for Novel Adaptations. "Sila Nerangalil Sila Manidhargal" was my first tamil novel and it made me wonder "Are there people like Ganga in real life?". It was one of the best books I've ever read.
Kudos to the entire team. They have brought that feel and magic on screen too. The artists, music, dialogues are one of the best you'll ever see. I've never heard a dialogue like "You can never be a wife to someone. You can only be a concubine".
I was little sad that the climax has been changed a little. I'm not sure why. Otherwise its an amazing movie.
Kudos to the entire team. They have brought that feel and magic on screen too. The artists, music, dialogues are one of the best you'll ever see. I've never heard a dialogue like "You can never be a wife to someone. You can only be a concubine".
I was little sad that the climax has been changed a little. I'm not sure why. Otherwise its an amazing movie.
Avatar is a must watch movie not only for the making and awesome CG work but for the humanity which every man needs. We all speak of Global Warming and all the other things like apocalypse in 2012. We forget that everything is a by product of our greediness in making money virtually from everything. Same thing in the movie too.
Set in the future(2154 AD), the Sky people (we humans are referred so) create genetically engineered human-Na'vi(the aliens) hybrid called Avatars and make them live with the people of Pandorra(the fictional planet). I don't why humans are always shown in bad light in most of the English movies with certain exceptions like Independence day etc. But yes the truth is quite disturbing. Humans destroy everything that is so precious to this world. Here they need unobtainium, a rare mineral found only in pandorra.
One happy news is that the US military which is always "portrayed as the so called best and the saviors of the world " is no longer that way in this movie. They are indeed the villains. Other than that the story line will force some critics to call this movie "banal and full of clichés". Artists performance is good. Special mention to the CG team. Everything is so real.
When I walked out of the movie theatre, I couldn't resist the thought of " What the hell is happening in Copenhagen?" . We have to understand one thing, Development is good but its not that good when that development destroys things that are so unique and precious to this world.
Set in the future(2154 AD), the Sky people (we humans are referred so) create genetically engineered human-Na'vi(the aliens) hybrid called Avatars and make them live with the people of Pandorra(the fictional planet). I don't why humans are always shown in bad light in most of the English movies with certain exceptions like Independence day etc. But yes the truth is quite disturbing. Humans destroy everything that is so precious to this world. Here they need unobtainium, a rare mineral found only in pandorra.
One happy news is that the US military which is always "portrayed as the so called best and the saviors of the world " is no longer that way in this movie. They are indeed the villains. Other than that the story line will force some critics to call this movie "banal and full of clichés". Artists performance is good. Special mention to the CG team. Everything is so real.
When I walked out of the movie theatre, I couldn't resist the thought of " What the hell is happening in Copenhagen?" . We have to understand one thing, Development is good but its not that good when that development destroys things that are so unique and precious to this world.