frank56

The late Sidney Lumet's gift for realism was grossly under appreciated - this film is epic in its excellence and the major reason is his theatrical approach. His casting of the finest actors of the New York stage filled the screen with realism that was new and unexpected at the time - that so much of modern works such as television now borrow from his style is proof. Treat Williams carries this multiple hour opus effortlessly as well as the late great Jerry Orbach and others who all present fully realized, unforgettable takes in real life people whose stories are told here. This classic is among my most prized in my vast film collection and it's an honor to see such excellent craftsmanship. Forget naysayers and just experience this phenomenal cinema work.

I'm overjoyed that this excellent film is finally available on DVD. Robby Benson gives a performance that may finally receive the proper recognition. This is a story about friendship, true heart and life -- just see it and enjoy the richly developed performances and storytelling that unfold like a beautiful flower -- simply great.

I've seen so many negative comments about this film, and I have none...I thought the acting, subject matter and direction was straightforward and thought provoking. The film's matter-of-fact tone about the possibility of determining orientation force the viewer to deal with the issues presented here, making the discussion intense. Performances all good here, and we're reminded of the acting power of both Brendan Fraser and Jennifer Beals, who thoroughly impressed me here, not to mention the film's biggest surprise, Garry Marshall, who turns in a really solid performance as their father. Seek this out and enjoy an intelligent, well done film.