Her Deadly Eyes is an ambitious horror film that ultimately falls flat due to poor storytelling, weak character development, and baffling production choices. From the script to the set design, everything feels disjointed, as if the director and producer had no clear vision of what they wanted the film to be.
The screenplay is particularly weak, feeling more like an amateur novel adaptation than a structured film script. Characters speak unnaturally, and the dialogue fails to fit their personalities or motivations. A major flaw is the film's inability to differentiate between a plot twist and a plotline-it introduces ideas but stretches them into empty, meaningless sequences that add nothing to the overall story.
One of the biggest immersion-breaking moments comes from the poorly thought-out set and props. The supposed "rich villain" of the village carries a Kuromi phone case and a rundown phone, an odd detail that makes his character feel inconsistent. Meanwhile, a secluded room meant for captives inexplicably has a clock-why would kidnappers need their victims to keep track of time?
Then there are the glaring logic gaps. A girl who has never seen before suddenly understands what blood looks like after receiving an eye transplant. The same character, after undergoing surgery, is left with a grotesque hole in her face, raising questions about the medical logic behind the scene. Instead of serving as chilling horror elements, these details make the film feel unintentionally comedic.
The scares are equally ineffective, lacking tension or purpose. The film jumps between disconnected ghost sequences and an unrelated subplot about an affair, making it feel more like a disorganized compilation of horror moments rather than a cohesive narrative. The affair subplot itself is bizarre-the man cheats on his wife with someone older than her, which adds another layer of confusion rather than intrigue.
Overall, Her Deadly Eyes is a frustrating watch, filled with missed opportunities and baffling creative choices. Instead of delivering a chilling horror experience, it becomes an incoherent mess that leaves viewers questioning what they just watched.
