User reviews

Credibility is the factor often found lacking in Indian cinema. They're prone to casting outspoken, billionaire actresses as shy village damsels and silver spoon urban elites as repressed youth from the peripheries. Not in this one, thankfully. Great detail is given even to the child actor that plays the protagonist's younger self (matching their looks). The story itself is simple & heartfelt, probably why it wouldn't find many takers in a nation that drools over scenes where vehicles fly when 53 year old actors punch them while saving their 22 year old love interests. This disillusionment is the theme for the film as well, where "door k dhol suhaavne" is explored masterfully. The urban life seems a bit rushed/undeveloped but by then, the story has left a favorable imprint on you. Good to see the bellboy from The Grand Budapest Hotel in a supporting role here! P. S: More content of this ilk, Netflix!

It's a masterpiece of a kind keeping the innocence if the characters intact throughout the movie where they journey through different stages of life from a small kid growing up perspective.it has real grasp on the 70s India and American culture hype in the country.

The mother, father, children bond is heartwarming and at the same time saddening.

A short story, but it has good actors and a good setting.

He is super handsome and credible... Suraj Sharma, the Life of Pie fame carries off the movie singlehandedly and although story is well developed at places but feels rushed in at few and a drift from the protagonist's quest surfaces at times ... the movie starts with Indira Gandhi's Emergency address and followed by various events such as Indira Gandhi's assassination, Challenger crash and also Bollywood posters, movie songs and dialogues from 1980s that evoke the film's time period in an unobtrusive way...A sad story actually .. noticeable background score... a decent watch ..

What a beautiful film, full of meanings and analogies, the initial phase, with the readings of the letters a journey apart, deliciously passionate, a real drama, this week, a Brazilian woman died in the desert trying to cross it to enter the US, "O American dream", sad, real, beautiful photography, the quality films that Bollywood knows how to produce and that we love...

The surprise to me is that it hasn't been seen more - or reviewed more - since its Sundance launch in 2015. It's quite a good film that becomes engaging in a way that builds steadily.

In contrast to another reviewer here, I want to suggest that the plot is unpredictable, at least at the level of specifics and so I don't want to even give an alert and talk about spoilers.

I recommend watching it - it's a quality film with a theme that digs deep - into what I would call the role of a fantasy in not just one person's life but reverberating, like falling dominoes, into surrounding lives ... more specifically, how something of a fluke (a wedding present) can stimulate a fantasy that over time impacts every member of a family across generations due to fallout from that one instigating worshipful fantasy, in varying ways that determine the life trajectory of others rather than the original fantasizer.

Not even a single dialogue where I can see Suraj's lip movement.