User reviews

Not the greatest true crime documentary, but still interesting. The Family is frustrating for their shielded, close-to-best level of involvement. Friends are more concerned and knew Andrea better than her father & sisters. Family placing protecting "what's left of the family" over solving the case. The retired Detective Joe is the only hope to possibly solving the cold case with his unbiased re-examination of the evidence.

The cast of supporting characters includes a circle of quirky, gritty former drug addicts and members of a part-time amateur missing persons search group. Was Andrea the perky girl next door or a woman struggling with addiction and spiraling down the rabbit hole of shady dealers and a cartel?

TV show is so boring and drawn out. It is just them going back and forth, accusing each other and saying "I don't want to talk about it" "it's too dark to talk about" "he won't talk about". Seems like they were trying to drag it out as long as possible. Maybe they all wanted attention.

Is this real? The so-called members of this missing in America group seem to be dysfunctional and more focused on creating attention for themselves then actually wanting to help find not just Andrea but help finding anyone.. I tried to do a search on anyone they've actually found but couldn't find any numbers.. Also why are these amateur sleuths talking about doing dangerous "undercover" work especially a mother of two? Then you have a mysterious fire at the P. I.'s office that ends up burning all the notes and recordings of the missing woman.. I feel for the missing woman because in every picture they show of her she has what would be considered a smile but not a single one reaches her eyes and it looks like she's turning a frown into a smile.. They try and build this OMG we found something feeling towards the end of every episode trying to make you feel like the answer is in the next episode only to further the frustration of nothing happening..

I knew nothing about this case until I watched this. Slow and steady narrating, just wish the producers had asked the family more follow up question - and tied up loose ends. I definitely have more questions, which led me to the various social media groups dedicated to Andrea's case. Be cautious of the groups fun by the family...

What is clear is that Andrea's story desperately needed to be told. Sadly, no thanks to Andrea's family (specifically her sisters and mother), her story doesn't have an ending just yet. Many thanks to the people behind the documentary - hopeful this will put much needed pressure on the Louisville Police Department to solve this case.

A follow up episode or two is needed!

OK this show is one of those that could be told in a good 45 minute episode. However for this they chosen to pull in every body and their brother to give a comment or opinion that is takes 4 episodes. Which is why this show is a non starter from the get go! Not to mention all the social networking and their feeling and then arguments that ensue! One get the feeling that the woman ran away to away from the crowd of losers that suppose be her best friends!

There is an "interviewer" in a mask shown in the starting scenes who is clearly in the wrong job and lacks the proper skill sets to be interviewing people. Asks pointless questions and no understanding of appropriate or tactful human interaction. This continues in other scenes. Overall I found the story to not follow a logical order or leave a meaningful impression on an audience. I had to turn it off, it's just hard to watch and that's not because of the nature of the documentary. It's disappointing that we cannot get better coverage for missing persons, murders, and other major crimes, and this one just missed its chance to be impactful.

Characters seems reasonable and story-line is ok but is too drawn out into multiple episodes with too much emphasis on endless public opinions and social networking comment, which makes it feel slow and uninspiring to watch.

Very desperate attempt by a second rate corporation (but still a corporation) to get eyeballs for their precious streaming platform. Because that which will built them is a dying thing, so yeah, they put something in building up their streaming platform. True crime is a popular category, & Paramount is desperate to survive by the only route left, so someone got paid for 'producing' this 'content'. It's deceitful. So deceitful that it makes me sad for society. People think they can put out such trash because they think you're stupid. Much like the parent corporation's attempts at 'news' (you know, their jobs depend on it but it's a dying network & a dying source of news, so they have no conscience about the division they help create, so long as it gets some viewers & they continue to draw that comfy salary). Please stop dividing these kids just because you cannot stand the idea of them not letting the past taint everything they see in life.

But, no, seriously, I can't wrap my head around the producers of this getting paid by Paramount. Looking for a good crime doc? THIS AIN'T IT.

I thought this was a well done series .. I especially love retired Sergeant Joes approach he came with a game plan ...give him his own show please:) i felt like he was really getting somewhere with all his investigation. Great work!

I love how this documentary was done. I became very invested in the story and in her. After the first episode I was hooked, constantly thinking about her and couldn't wait for the next episode and the next.

You can tell that the people who put this together cared about Andrea and her story. They provided a lot of content and detailed information leading up to her disappearance and all the angles of what may have caused her disappearance to happen.

Her family (sister and father) carry a lot of guilt but the love they have for Andrea is deeply felt. Her father has an unwavering hope to find her. Her friends love and care greatly for her and have done so much to try and find answers. Andrea is an amazing person. I hope that they all find some peace and happiness in the loving memories that they carry with them of her everyday ❤