User reviews

I love this series! The artwork reminds me of Scary Stories to Tell in the Dark. Not sure if that was done on purpose to hit our nostalgia hard, but it certainly did work. The Boys' humor is top notch, very comparable to their reactions in Buzzfeed Unsolved. As always, Shane is the Bee's Knees. His skepticism, especially as someone that is a believer in the paranormal, is refreshing every time. My one minor gripe is a couple of the stories aren't as engaging. Given the fact that the Boys' read these for the first time, I'm hopeful in the future whoever does do the research for this can see what works & what doesn't.

I love Shane and Ryan's chemistry. The story telling and animation is very good too. Keeps you guessing and some of the stories are real some are fake based on creepy pasta, really glad these guys are still doing stuff once they do there last season of buzzfeed supernatural.

The stories can be pretty hit or miss. There are a handful that are just...not so great, even with the commentary from these two. I prefer Too Many Spirits but I already know I'll watch every episode of this one. The animation is pretty cool as well and can be genuinely creepy. If the producers can find better stories (and /r/nosleep is full of them), then the show would easily hit an 8 or 9 in my book.