The Gray Man

A solid thriller about Albert Fish (a very fine performance by Patrick Bauchau), the real life serial killer of children in 1930's America. Fish seemed a harmless old man, but in 1934 he was arrested as the murderer of several missing children he somehow duped their families into leaving him with (using an assumed name throughout). Part character study and part detective procedural, The Gray Man wisely avoids graphic horror and sensationalism (Fish's murders, for instance, are never shown on camera), and while it is rather conventional, it is nevertheless quite chilling nonetheless and it shows a director with a very keen sense of storytelling.

This is a very well made biography of the 1920-30's serial killer Albert Fish. I thought the set designers did a fabulous job with the period rooming houses, abandoned farms, and even the detectives police station. This is not a glossy MGM or Warner Brothers expensive film production about a fictionalized serial killer. Instead the director, Scott L. Flynn, developed the story line to provide us his film's audience with what it must have been like to live in the 1920-30's with a deranged child molester and serial killer on the loose.

The film maintains a historical value to it by outlining the known crimes and murders committed by Albert Fish without glorifying his crimes with any sexual deviancy nor with much violence and/or excessive blood letting since Albert Fish was known to be a cannibal.

It is easy to focus on the cat and mouse game between the serial killer Albert Fish (Patrick Bauchau) and the lead Detective Will King (Jack Conley) as Albert Fish seems to be unaware that he is being investigated by lead Detective Will King.

As stated earlier this is not a costly production as with (1991) The Silence of the Lambs, or (2007) Zodiac, but what the film The Gray Man does deliver is a first rate biography of the 1920-30's pedophile and serial killer Albert Fish.

I give the film a well deserved 7 out of 10 IMDb rating.

I'm not sure what angle they were going for here, sometimes film noir, sometimes doco style but never thriller or horror movie. The fil plays it too nice for that.

The film never really makes you feel as creepy as the character should make you feel.

The actor (forgot his name) who plays the detective was the stand out actor for me.

Its ok but lacks drama :)

Albert Fish was one of the most monstrous of human monsters. While this movie shows him being prepared for electrocution, after he was convicted of kidnapping and cannibalizing a little girl, he taunted his captors that he was also responsible for nearly l00 other unsolved murders. This movie is so devoid of shock, horror, tension, grimness that it could be shown on the Disney Channel with just a few minor cuts. It's like the movie makers were determined to make a "serious" "artful" movie that would not upset anyone. Everything in this film is clean, glossy, sunny and the actor who portrays Albert Fish is so handsome and charming that it's like he walked in from a soap opera. The horrendous life of Albert Fish and the horrors he perpetrated deserves a shocking, bloody, horrific treatment. Nothing in this tame, pallid production suggests any of these qualities.

Although there's solid performances from the main cast, particularly Patrick Bacau who plays the notorious Albert Fish, this film seems to lack something - thus it's left like its title, grey. What could and should have been an excellent film becomes, because of bad direction, a lack of character development (the detective in particular is poorly developed), plus a poor script, an unsatisfying B movie which is at times tedious and plodding.

Regarding the subject matter, there's too much skipping over of important facts, and the characters are mainly one dimensional clichés. The lack of intimacy in the direction and cinematography - which is perhaps intentional - doesn't work. As a viewer, I'm left not drawn in enough to the characters to really know them, and at times, this left me bored. No time is taken to explore motives of anyone. The film is OK - but that's about it.