- Torquemada: Surely Rome understands that public executions discourage sin?
- Cardinal: The good Lord, you know, padre, he want us to love our neighbor, no roast him, mmm? No roast him ...
- Cardinal: The Pope also want the Inquisition to stop the use of torture. And declare an amnesty on all heretics and witches. Hmm?
- Torquemada: Rome is behind the times. His Holiness is old and lost his zeal!
- Cardinal: He is the Pope!
- Torquemada: And I am the Inquisition!
- Cardinal: His Holiness also DEMAND...order you to return to Rome with me for an audience.
- Torquemada: I've received no such demand.
- Cardinal: [chuckles] I just deliver it!
- Mendoza: [as they scour Maria's blemish-free body] What exactly are we looking for, surgeon?
- Dr. Heusos: Oh, hidden charms, poisons, a third nipple where Satan may suck. Any blemish may be a witch's mark. It could be as small as a pinprick.
- Dr. Heusos: You idiots, why did you tear out her tongue?
- Gomez: We didn't. We don't do tongues.
- Francisco: Of course not. How can they confess if they don't have tongues?
- [As Torquemada has the Cardinal bricked behind a wall]
- Cardinal: For the love of God!
- Torquemada: Yes, for the love of God.
- Torquemada: Take them to their cells.
- Maria: You swore you'd show mercy!
- Torquemada: In this place, death is mercy.
- Torquemada: Satan is ever-present among us. Every sin and deed, word or thought, no matter how long forgotten... must be truly confessed. And punished!