Un monde à part

Jodhi May doesn't pay attention to what's going on about her in South Africa. That is, until her father, Jeroen Krabbe, flees the country, labeled a communist traitor, her mother, Barbara Hershey, is thrown into prison, and the girls at her private school start tormenting her.

It's one of several movies about the impact of South African apartheid in the late 1980s, but this one is a bit different. Instead of being centered more on the struggle itself, Miss May, the viewpoint character, is more an unwilling witness to the fact that while it's nice to be well-to-do, not everyone can blithely accept that, especially the disenfranchised and those with a sense of justice. The performances are excellent, but even though Miss May's journey from an easy childhood to a committed adulthood is a difficult one, it hardly raises my sympathy, as it clearly is meant to.

Jodhi May deserved an Oscar for her work. All told, this is one of the finest coming-of-age stories I've ever seen filmed. And its ending is one of the saddest and most powerful ever - alongside "At Play in the Fields of the Lord."

I saw this film years ago, and some of it's scenes still haunts me. The story is set in South Africa and it's about a family which will be eventually destroyed by the problems there. The then very young Jothi May it quiet impressive in her debut and Barbara Hershey is equally good.

If this is indicative of things to come, Jodhi May will be one strong actress to reckon with. Barbara Hershey has never been better, but Jodhi May steals the show as her neglected daughter struggling with terms of identity and growth in South Africa pre-Apartheid. This one is truly a gem. I highly recommend seeing it at any opportunity. I have a copy of it I taped off the television years and years ago. I'm hoping one day it is released on DVD.

I saw this film in 1988 when it first came out. I was looking forward to seeing it on DVD but I must confess I was very disappointed. I found it excessively slow, with few dialogues, and in fact, plain boring. It should be at least 1/2 hr shorter.

True, there are moments of real poignancy in "A world apart" and Jodhi May is an excellent actress but there just doesn't seem to be much going on for most of half the film. Maybe the fact that apartheid has been defeated and that so much has happened in S. Africa since makes it less momentous.

For anyone interested in S. Africa, I recommend watching "Cry Freedom", "A white dry season" or even "The power of one" instead. These films at least seek to explain their characters involvement with the anti-apartheid movement. In "A world apart", there's no such character growth so far as the mother is concerned. Her involvement has to be taken for granted.