User reviews

Recognized with three Oscar nominations Darling Lili was a big flop at the time and helped seal the fate of big budget musicals and Julie Andrews's career in them. They were getting just too expensive to make with all the talent that used to be under contract to a studio now charging full market value for services. Whatever else Darling Lili is it's a full market value musical film.

Set in the era of World War I, Darling Lili's best asset is its music. Two of the three nominations were in the music field for best overall score and to Henry Mancini and Johnny Mercer for the song Whistling In The Dark. That one is an incredibly beautiful number that Julie Andrews sings perfectly. The original songs are integrated so well into the film that they fit perfectly in the era. More traditional World War I era songs are also used, no doubt all in the public domain by 1970.

Would that the score was attached to a better story. Wholesome Julie Andrews is a popular entertainer of the era, singing for the troops on the western front. She also doubles as a German spy. Her assignment which she accepts with gusto is to get involved with American air ace Rock Hudson and learn some military secrets. I think you can guess the rest.

Darling Lili lurches back and forth from cloak and dagger espionage to slapstick comedy in the extreme and it's an uncomfortable ride in the process. One of the characters is Lance Percival playing a drunken pilot in the Royal Flying Corps. I mean really, this guy should never have been in the RFC, the comedy which is good is severely out of place.

Film buffs will recognize some similarity to The Firefly and the British classic Dark Journey so if you know those films you know how this one ends. Fans of Rock Hudson and of Julie Andrews will like this and her singing is divine. The rest of Darling Lili is on a lesser plain.

After 35 years, I've seen this film again; the 136 minute version at the Anthology Film Archives in New York City's East Village. They also showed the 114 minute version which, according to their production notes, is darker in tone, since it's missing some of the comedy of the piece. Certainly some of the cutesy comedy, which Blake Edwards, the director/producer/writer, also seems to be enamored of in his Pink Panther movies, could be cut.

The film is an attempt to make a mature, romantic musical and was a big flop at the time. Edwards was married to Julie Andrews, the female star of the movie. Andrews had a great success with "Mary Poppins" a few years earlier, and a phenomenal success with "The Sound of Music." She tried repeating the success with the awful (but, perhaps, commercially successful) "Thoroughly Modern Millie," and had a stinker with "Star!", the Gertrude Lawrence story. "Star!" was an adult musical, but it didn't take, so "Darling Lili" was another try at breaking Andrews' goody-two-shoes image. She says "ass" in the movie twice and "bastard" once! The scenes I remember most from the first screening in 1970 are the striptease by Suzette (Gloria Paul) and the aerial sequences, which are pretty dazzling (except for the obvious process shots). In fact, the whole movie is quite lavish and Andrews is gowned and bejeweled beautifully. Edwards seems to have studied the films of Vincente Minnelli and is better at creating some of the Minnellian tone than George Cukor was with the dull "My Fair Lady." In fact, Minnelli was making a movie - "On A Clear Day..." - at Paramount the same time "Darling Lili" was being produced. "...Lili" went into major cost overruns, which could account for "...Clear Day..." being so lackluster in its modern scenes, since major money was being pumped into the Andrews/Edwards film.

The movie isn't terrible. In fact, it's quite charming, if a little long. But the movie-going public is fickle, and Julie Andrews musicals fell quickly out of favor. Rock Hudson is enormously likable as always, but has little to do. The production design is delightful, and it's fun to see Andrews do her striptease (which may not be in the shorter version, and I'm thinking that must have been the version I saw in 1970, because I think I would have remembered it).

Maybe the movie will come out on DVD now that they are showing two versions in NYC. The print was beautiful, by the way. It even included the overture. The audience was a poignant collection of solitary film nerds, not excluding myself!

In an odd, comic take on Mata Hari's legendary fame, Julie Andrews stars as a well-loved British entertainer who seduces military leaders and passes on their secrets to the Germans. This movie doesn't take itself too seriously, so feel free to just tap your toe and enjoy Julie's fun musical numbers. It's also a Blake Edwards movie, so you can expect to be entertained by quick comedy and superb comic timing. In a famous scene, Rock Hudson gets so mad, he barges in on Julie Andrews in the shower to continue their argument.

In one of my favorite scenes, Julie has been tasked with delaying Rock at her house. She puts on a large act of seduction, but in order to stretch things out, she insists on getting literally swept off her feet. Rock struggles to pick her up and carry her through the rooms, since she continues to kiss him and pretends to be so engrossed in her task she doesn't know he's having trouble. It's pretty funny, as is much of the movie. The very best scene, though, is hands down the striptease. Julie gets jealous of Rock's other paramour Gloria Paul. Gloria's a stripper, and Julie watches a risqué dance, then recreates it onstage in her next performance! You won't be able to believe it until you see it: Julie Andrews bumping, grinding, and taking her dress off. I thought it was fantastic, and it almost earned her a Hot Toasty Rag nomination; but there were lots of heavy, dramatic performances that year and she didn't make it on the list.

You'll get to hear lots of fun songs that put you back in the wartime mood, and Henry Mancini's Oscar- and Rag-nominated "Whistling in the Dark" opens the film. And with two pretty people in the leads, and lots of smooching, you're in for an enjoyable, funny evening.

Blake Edwards' "Darling Lili" is not a great film, but it is better than most people give it credit for. One of the most maligned productions in history (the aerial sequences took 2 years to film, the budget swelled to 3 times the original budget, various cuts of the film only add to the muddle), my final analysis is this: an underrated film whose reputation should soar once it's more widely seen.

This film exists in three versions: the original roadshow version (190 minutes)which Edwards disowned, the general release version (136 minutes)and Edwards' personal director's cut (113 minutes).

Tones shift between versions. The roadshow version had more talky sequences and was a numbing bore. The general release version deleted these sequences and was an improvement, but was still missing something. Edwards' cut was a great improvement. It is more serious in tone than the previous cuts, but the story concucted by Edwards and William Peter Blatty benefits from that approach. Julie Andrews is simply great as Lili, the singer/spy and her singing is at an all time high. Rock Hudson is excellent as her American pilot lover. Only after his inclination was exposed, did people take him seriously as an actor. But he was great all along. The songs by Henry Mancini and Johnny Mercer are strong as is the cinematography (by Russell Harlan, in Panavision)

Sadly, "Darling Lili" is not available on tape or DVD. But luckily for us, AMC shows this very often.

Roadshow version: 1/2* General Release: ** 1/2 Director's Cut: ***1/2

Darling Lili may have been a major flop at the time, but to me it is not a bad film. Not great, uneven is a good way to describe it, but it is much better than its reputation. It is overlong, the comedy/slapstick scenes at times feel out of place and compared to the other themes that make up the film at odds with the rest of the film, the film can get muddled, the film can drag and Rock Hudson while likable is rather stiff- compared to his usual performances- and doesn't have the strongest of chemistrys with Julie Andrews(though not without its moments). Julie Andrews though is great though, her acting and presence are charming and she as ever sings like an angel. Lance Percival shines also in possibly his best film role and one of his best performances. The film looks gorgeous, the highlights being the marvellously shot aerial dogfight sequences and the visuals that accompany the song Whistling Away the Dark. The music is distinctive Henry Mancini, it fits the film adeptly and is a very memorable score and one you can re-visit more than once. Much has been said about the hauntingly beautiful Whistling Away the Dark, how Andrews sings it(like an angel and with so much nuance and emotion) and how it's staged and for good reason, simply put it's a beautiful song that is beautifully sung and beautifully staged. The script and the story aren't great but they're not disastrous either. The script is intelligent with some snappy moments, it didn't feel that talky, and the story at least has some entertainment value despite moments being muddled and the spy thriller, drama and musical themes being far more convincing than the comedy and romance ones. Overall, uneven but Darling Lili a decent film and is much better than it's made out to be, though it's somewhat easy to see why it was a flop. 6/10 Bethany Cox

Colorful musical that is deficient in the script department, exactly why Julie is a spy is never really apparent and it really hurts the film. That being said the production design is beautiful as are some of Julie's costumes, it all seems overproduced and under-directed though. While the design is good a problem the film suffers from, and it was one many 60's musicals share, is that nothing looks lived in or used so it feels false from the beginning. Rock has been better elsewhere although that also is probably the fault of the script. What makes this worth sitting through is Julie and her voice which is exquisite and put to use on some lovely songs. "Whistling Away the Dark" in particular is haunting and beautifully staged if only the rest of the film was up to its brilliance this would have been something indeed.

Blake Edwards tried very hard to change Julie Andrews image in this film. He tried to make her sexy not realizing she already was. I think they were both still a bit irked that Julie had not been chosen to film her Broadway success of Camelot and was passed over as not being sexy enough. Unfortunately, they chose this vehicle to try and assuage this belief. It gets to the point where it is almost funny seeing Rock Hudson, who we all know now was gay, kissing Julie every 2 minutes throughout this movie. It seems now that they were not only trying to make you believe that Julie was a femme fatale but that Rock was straight. Sadly, they have absolutely no chemistry together and the unending kissing scenes start grossing one out. The other error they made with this picture was not knowing what kind of movie they were making. It is almost three separate movies. There is the drama of Julie as the German spy trying to get military secrets from Rock. There is an air war movie with lots of footage of WWI vintage planes swooping about and there is the stupid attempts at humor that Blake Edwards seems to think he has to insert in every one of his pictures whether it is appropriate or not, In this case, it was not. The only truly redeeming qualities in this film are looking at the always lovely Dame Julie and hearing her sing in that crystal clear bell-like soprano. Of course if you love her, you may overlook the weaknesses of this film just because of her. You can always tell yourself, afterward, that it was a hell of a lot better than sitting through STAR!

I suppose I like this film as well as any I know; it is not perfect, but under the title "The Americanization of Lily" this charming and memorable semi-musical satire might I suggest have been appreciated more, and still loved by those who recognized its special Blake Edwards'-produced spirit of gentleness, clever humor and solid narrative. The improbably but delightful story-line follows Lili Smith, a fringe-type spy for the Germans in a much simpler and less black-and-white war; Lili Schmidt passing as Smith is helping her Uncle who is patriotic too, for Germany but neither cruel nor political, merely opportunistic. Lili's target is William Larrabee, a charismatic U.S. squadron leader who can supply her valuable information. The plot thickens comes when Lili falls in love with Larrabee, has her eyes opened to the consequences of her playing spy, and sees the effects of combat on wounded men at a hospital and realizes what it might mean to his men whom she has met and likes. She gets jealous of a rival for Larrabee's affections, then realizes she can no longer do what she has been doing and gives up the spy business. The logical end of the film comes when after the terrible WWI has ended, as she sings the theme song of the film, "Wishing" in a darkened theater, one by one the members of Larrabee's squadron appear, including her lover himself, indicating they have forgiven her and their former opponents; and even Uncle Kurt enthusiastically joins in the singing of "It's a Long To Tipperraree", to indicate all is well with the world again. This is an audacious and sometime brilliant story idea, written by director Blake Edwards and William Peter Blatty of "John Goldfarb" fame; and it is a delightful narrative. Larrabee's squadron, including an inebriate who keeps crashing and other lovable types populate this lively film; and the feel of this stylish and glowing film is almost epic, both in its scope and realization. Credit must go to Jack Bear and Donald Brooks for their costume creations, Reg Allen and Jack Stevens for sets, Fernando Carrere for another beautiful production design, Henry Mancini for his sensitive and appropriate musical score, and to Russell Harlan for his shining cinematography. In the beautiful footage, the principal actors are Julie Andrews as Lili, Rock Hudson as Larrabee, Keremy Kemp outstanding as Lili's Uncle Kurt, Michael Witney, Lance Percival as the inebriate pilot, gorgeous Gloria Paul as Lili's stripteasing rival, and many other fine actors in smaller parts. It is hard to say enough nice things about the pace, or the cleverness of the just-this-side-of broad comedy; this element is introduced by Edwards to leaven the horrors of actual warfare, to example the almost comic-opera approach with which men made war back in a more innocent-minded era of human civilization.. This comedy also helps prepare the way for Lili's conversion from uncritical acceptance of a duty to the German state to acceptance of the reality of what she is doing and potentially what she may be causing. This is a rare "sense-of-life" film about Lili's "Americanization", her assertion of herself in the real world and then among others before tragedy can happen. It is haunting, I find, and beautiful in many ways. I consider it to be Blake Edwards'masterpiece of directing; and under the title "The Americanization of Lili" I believe with hardly any changes it might have been recognized as the polished sapphire of a film it is by every standard I know.

By 1970 Blake Edwards was in a creative crisis that would last until 1975 when he turned again to Inspector Closeau in "The Return of the Pink Panther". He was able to still make a couple of good films before he died (including one I am very fond of, "That's Life! "). His leading lady Julie Andrews and composer Henry Mancini would still have to wait until 1982 for "Victor/Victoria" to have a great success, and by then the superstar status of Rock Hudson (with a haircut too snobbish for his standardized screen persona) was non-existent. Shot in 1968 when students and workers were protesting everywhere around the globe (riots affected production, and it was moved from Paris to Brussels), the events unfortunately did not hint Edwards that the world was changing fast. By 1970, when it was released, nobody could care less for a spy comedy set during I World War, while the rubbing lips routine passing for kissing was not convincing in the days of "free love". Worse is that there was no chemistry between the two leading actors, and they were not even convincing: Andrews as a Mata-Hari type spy called Lili Schmidt, and Hudson as a don Juan and star pilot who fights Von Richtofen in the skies. Hudson even seems tired and bored, specially when he tells her that she is the most sensual and exciting woman he has ever met (with all respect to Miss Andrews, one cannot help but think of Gina Lollobrigida, Paula Prentiss, Claudia Cardinale, Leslie Caron, Cyd Charisse, Angie Dickinson, and other very attractive ladies who were paired with Hudson). It is a very sad affair because it seems everybody tried hard, but Edwards and his co-scriptwriter William Peter Blatty mixed too many elements, from slapstick to aerial battles and all kinds of film homages: Edward's own "The Pink Panther" (with two Clouseau's clones), Wise's "The Sound of Music" (an aerial shot of Andrews running through a field, a group of children chanting in the countryside... not even "Do-Re-Mi", but a forgettable song), or Donner's "What's New, Pussycat?" (the final sequence at the Château Chantel hotel), among others. As for Mancini, he tried the same strategy of another 1970 film he scored, Vittorio de Sica's "I girasoli", for which he overused his main theme: here Mancini took the beautiful song "Whistling Away the Dark" (which also sounds very good with French lyrics) as the leitmotiv, and it is insistently heard throughout, while the other songs he penned with Johnny Mercer are weak. Perhaps if all of them (Mancini, Mercer, Blatty and Edwards) had concocted a typical Edwardian sophisticated comedy, it would have worked. It did not, but at least eleven years later the whole mess inspired Edwards' very funny "S.O.B."

Yes, I am a romantic of sorts who likes musicals and comedy and this fit the bill! Julie Andrews gives a mesmerizing performance at the beginning and end of this film with the "Whistling in the Dark" production number. The sedate-to-outrageous number that she performs in the middle of the story when she believes that Rock Hudson has been seeing a dancing/call girl is eye-popping and will certainly make you giggle.

I only wish that this film could be found in video or DVD as I would surely purchase it in a heartbeat for my home library!

Rarely we saw in cinema industry a blend of three opposite genres as in Darling Lili, as far I remember I never watch such combo, musical, comedy and spy thriller, actually all them together do not mixed very well, worst exposing the heavenly persona Mary Poppins into Mata Hari alike, it somehow scratch Julie Andrews who doesn't fit well as villain, prompted refuse by audience, that displeased such weird offering.

In other hand the wiser Black Edwards the aim of safeguarding her wife hired the kisser chin Rock Hudson, therefore Julie Andrews will be safe in whole picture of the harmless already aged star, oddly enough in a shower sequence Hudson says "I think you actually is a virgin woman", well if it were up of Rock Hudson certainly she would remain so, another blatant discrepancy is concerning the battle on the front of conflict, they wrongly used gardened clean landscape instead the hell of deep and dirty trenches as we always used to see.

On the intent to relief the low tension the screenplay provides two Pink Pantherish comic characters as the moronic couple Jacques Marin and André Maranne is the highlight of the picture, without forget the blazing performance by Gloria Paul as Crepe Suzette.

Thanks for reading.

Resume:

First watch: 2024 / How many: 1 / Source: DVD / Rating: 6.

Set in Northern France during the first World War, Lili Smith (Julie Andrews) is a popular English performer who entertains the Allied forces and entertains diplomats and generals. Unbeknownst to her Allied admirers, Lili is in fact a German Spy who under direction from her handler and uncle Colonel Kurt Ron Ruger (Jeremy Kemp) gathers information from conversations with often inebriated Allied pilots and commanders to feed to German forces. Lili is assigned to work on Major William Larrabee (Rock Hudson), an ace pilot and leader of Eagle Squadron, but as Lili seduces him she finds herself developing feelings that are genuine. However matters are complicated when Duvalle and liggett (Jacques Marin and Andre Maranne respectively), two agents from French Army Intelligence tell Lili they believe Larabee may be the spy they are looking for along with burlesque performer Crepe Suzette (Gloria Paul) whom Lili comes to believe is having an affair with Larabee.

The final film in a four picture deal between director Black Edwards and studio Paramount Pictures, Darling Lili is loosely inspired by the real life story of exotic dancer Mata Hari who was convicted and executed by firing squad for being a German spy during World War I. Produced over the course of three years, the budget was originally intended as a large but not unexpected $11 million but production problems led to the budget ballooning to an unwieldly $25 million making it one of the most expensive films of the time. Further issues happened in post-production due to creative differences between Paramount and Edwards with the studio taking control of the film and leaving Edwards out of the editing process. The movie didn't do well upon initial release, and along with other failures/underperformers like Happiest Millionaire, Hello Dolly!, and Paint Your Wagon along with demographic changes and changing cultural mores lead to the abandonment of such old fashioned musical epics like Darling Lili in favor of musicals that were more traditional stage show adaptations or more edge like Rocky Horror Picture Show or Grease. Darling Lili did receive some praise for it's score by Henry Mancini as well as the song "Whistling Away the Dark" which were nominated at the Academy Awards for Best Original Score and Best Original Song respectively, and the costuming was also nominated for an Academy Award. However beneath the gloss, and the troubled production history serving as the basis for Blake Edward's satirical film S. O. B. Which spoofed the incompetence and excess he experienced making the film, Darling Lili is underwhelming as a romance, a spy film, and a comedy.

Julie Andrews tries to play against type as a German spy whose alias is a stage performer, but aside from one scene where Andrews does a burlesque striptease act most of the movie sees Andrews not really stretched all that far from her delivery in films like Mary Poppins or Sound of Music. There's an attempt to give her more grit and punch to her performance but the script by William Peter Blatty and Blake Edwards doesn't give the character of Lili Smith enough depth for Andrews to sink her teeth into this role and put a different spin on it. Rock Hudson is also rather underwhelming as our male lead who certainly looks the part of our dashing rogue male counterpart, but he never has all that much chemistry with Andrews and the movie pretty much admits this with all of their relationship building scenes done in montages where we can't hear them speaking and the final kiss is shot from the back of Rock Hudson's head which shows that Edwards' knows there's no chemistry between Hudson and Andrews so he focuses on the more impactful actor by default.

The movie also runs at a turgid pace. To my knowledge there are three versions of this movie: a 190 minute roadshow version that to the best of my knowledge has not been released, a 136 minute general release version, and a 107 minute director's cut that Blake Edwards supervised in 1991. For the purposes of this review a watched both the general release and director's cut and if you are going to experience this movie the director's cut is the way to go since it gets rid of many of the dead spots and floundering scenes that were in the general release version. Now it's still a movie with two lead actors whose chemistry is equivalent to a wet matchbox so there's no "saving" this movie, but there is at least a more "digestible" version of it if you're morbidly curious. I can't even imagine what the 190 minute version runs like because even at half the length its still a bit of a sit. I will say Henry Mancini's score and "Whisper Away the Dark" or quite good per the standards of Mancini and it is certainly a lavish production with beautifully designed period appropriate costumes and stage direction. But despite the novelty of seeing Julie Andrews in a more risqué role, it alone isn't enough to elevate a very standard formula musical especially in comparison to scenes in Guys and Dolls or Gentlemen Prefer Blondes that preceded this film by 10 or 15 years and had far more sexual energy to some of their scenes.

Darling Lili is a lot of money with only surface level detail to show for it. Julie Andrews feels uncertain as to how she should approach this Mata Hari inspired character, and the chemistry between Andrews and Rock Hudson is virtually non-existent. The movie is too slow and uninvolving even with Blake Edward's greatly shortened director's cut, and it doesn't work as a comedy, romance, or spy film as a result. Darling Lili like many musicals of the time had the ambition but it was lost among the excess and bloat of a tumultuous production cycle.

It was 1970. Julie Andrews had hit her highs onscreen, and her star was starting to fade, at least in the public's eye. "Lili" represented another opportunity for Julie to change her image, coming right after the megamusical "STAR!" which didn't deserve the drubbing *it* received either.

Audiences didn't seem to care for this WWI musical drama. In fact, they were staying away in droves from ANY musical--drama or not.

The shame of it all is that this film, with its many classic moments, was stigmatized by the press who were gunning for Our Fair Julie and her new beau, writer/director/producer Blake Edwards.

But "Lili" really *is* worth seeking out. Julie sings beautifully, especially the haunting "Whistling Away the Dark," a lovely Henri Mancini tune that opens and closes the film. Her performance is nuanced and quite affecting--just watch her as a fat tear silently slides down her cheek after a tumultuous argument with Major Larabee.

Edwards has staged some stunning flight sequences, but the suffer somewhat, in 1990s sensibilities, from the blue-screen process shots needed to get Rock "into" midair. Edwards also can't seem to help himself from sliding into formulaic comedy bits (he apparently thinks a bumbling Frenchman with an umbrella on a roof in a rainstorm is hilarious--it shows up in film after film of his).

The reason to watch "Lili" is for its interesting spin on the Mata Hari legend and the performance of Miss Andrews, who certainly didn't deserve the brickbats that came her way following its release.

After the success of "Mary Poppins" and "The Sound of Music" did Hollywood ever worry about what they might do with the hottest property on the planet? Did anyone ever doubt that Julie Andrews could act or that she was more than just a voice, even if that voice seemed limited in its range? The 'big' Hollywood musical did seem to be on the way out, (even "Camelot" went with Vanessa Redgrave and not Julie, who was the stage Guinevere), but Miss Andrews was still holding her own in such non-musicals as "Hawaii" and "Torn Curtain" and she would prove a splendid Gertrude Lawrence in "Star" and for a time she would continue in roles that allowed her a certain dramatic or comedy license while also giving her the chance to sing.

In 1970, cast in "Darling Lili" she had the role of a music hall entertainer who also happened to be a German spy during the years of World War One. It was a frivolous epic, part romantic comedy, (though never a particularly funny one), and part spirited action flic with some splendid aerial sequences as well as being a mildly engaging spy yarn with perhaps the least likely German spy in all of movies. Of course, if Julie is to change her allegiance it's going to take the right man to do it and I suppose who better than Rock Hudson, still flaunting his hunk status almost 20 years after first baring his chest on screen. Unfortunately for Rock, (not looking very happy here), Jeremy Kemp is there to steal his every scene. The director was Blake Edwards and if it isn't one of his finest films let's just say it has its moments.

Definitely in line with Blake Edwards's career, the same comic style (in my opinion childish), but also a great visual style, thanks to the almost obsessive attention to framing, lighting, and costumes.

During World War I, in Paris, the famous stage singer Lili Smith (Julie Andrews) is actually a German spy. When her superior and lover, Colonel Kurt von Ruger (Jeremy Kemp), gives her the mission to steal the secrets of Air Force Major William Larrabee (Rock Hudson), her womanizing threatens to overwhelm her spying.

Blake Edwards's direction maintains his high standards of clarity and perfection; the screenplay is a bit too superficial, with a few minor contradictions or illogicalities; the actors, Julie Andrews aside, are decidedly out of place, at times even over the top.

Recommended for lovers of bel canto and Julie Andrews's performances. Not recommended for those who don't like slapstick.

Years ago, when DARLING LILI played on TV, it was always the pan and scan version, which I hated and decided to wait and see the film in its proper widescreen format. So when I saw an inexpensive DVD of this Julie Andrews/Blake Edwards opus, I decided to purchase and watch it once and for all.

Boy, what a terrible film. It's so bad and on so many levels that I really do not know where to start in describing where and when it goes so horribly wrong. Looking at it now, it's obvious to any fans of movies that Blake Edwards created this star vehicle for his wife simply because so many other directors had struck gold with Andrews in musicals (MARY POPPINS, SOUND OF MUSIC, THOROUGHLY MODERN MILLIE, etc) but also because Andrews was snubbed from starring in projects made famous on stage by Julie herself (CAMELOT, MY FAIR LADY, etc) because Hollywood thought she wasn't sexy or glamorous enough. So Blake created this stillborn effort, to showcase his wife in a bizarre concoction of spy story/war movie/romance/slapstick comedy/musical. DARLING LILI suffers from multiple personalities, never knowing who or what it is. Some specific scenes are good or effective but as a whole, it just doesn't work at all to a point of it being very embarrassing.

Mind you, the version on the DVD is the "director's cut", or in this case, "let's salvage whatever we can" from this notorious box office flop. In releasing the DVD, Edwards cut 19 scenes (19!!!!!!!!) from the original bloated theatrical version into this more streamlined and yet remarkably ineffective version. The film moves along with no idea of what it is. We are 25 minutes into it and we still don't know what's going on or why we're watching what's going. What kind of spy is Lili? How powerful is she? Was she ever responsible for someone's death? Instead we watch a thoroughly bored looking Rock Hudson trying to woo a thoroughly bored looking Julie Andrews. Things aren't helped much with the inexplicable reason why the two fall in love. Why does Julie fall for Hudson? Why him and not other men she got involved with? There should have been one of her ex hanging around, trying to win her back or trying to decipher her secret. This would have given us some much needed contrast to the muddled action. It would also have given us some impetuous to the sluggish proceedings. There's no catalyst in this story.

One only has to look at the cut scenes to clearly see that Edwards and the writer just came up with ideas inspired by Andrews' (and Edwards') previous successes. The best (or worst) example is the scene when Andrews and Hudson follow a group of children who sing in the middle of a forest. Edwards channeling SOUND OF MUSIC. It's no wonder he removed it from the DVD. Back in 1970, that scene might have worked on a certain level but today, that moment reeks of desperation. There are other plot elements directly inspired by Andrews/Edwards other films. The endless scenes of dogfights is inspired by the much better MODERN MILLIE. The musical moment "I'll give you three guesses" was created just to make fun of Julie's MARY POPPINS persona, which is turned "raunchy" with Julie doing a striptease in the act. The ending, bird's eye view of Julie running towards Hudson's plane, is another "wink" at SOUND OF MUSIC.

The whole thing is confusing. Julie plays a singer, born from a German father and British mother, who lives in England but sings her (English) songs in Paris. You never know exactly where the story takes place. Some moments are just badly edited. Like when Julie and her "uncle" are on horseback. They talk and talk and then Julie suddenly sprints off in mid-sentence. I'm like "what happened here?"

The comedy bits are unfunny and cringe-worthy. Every scene with the French police are pathetic. Where's Peter Sellers when you really need him. The action is badly thought-up. When Julie and her "uncle" are on their way to Germany on that train, Hudson's squadron and the German squadron reach the train (in daytime) at the same time even thought the train has been moving for hours and they left the night before. The French/German border is not that far. Anyway, that's one slow moving train there. The 'climax' is an entirely poorly executed moment.

The musical moments. The beginning is the best part of the entire film (and the reason I gave this film 3 stars) but its effect is diminished considerably because it's repeated at the end. Speaking of redundant, did we really need to see a can-can dance, Crepe Suzette stripping scene and Julie stripping too? The "Girl in no man's land" is OK even if it's bleeding obvious, but that moment just doesn't make any sense whatsoever because Lili sings it to a group of injured soldiers at a French hospital, making me wonder: how many soldiers there were injured indirectly by the result of her spying?

The whole project is listless and without energy. The romance is 100% unbelievable. Rock Hudson is way too old and tired looking (check out the museum scene). Julie looks dazed, like she's on Valium. But what really kills this ill-conceived project is Julie playing a German spy. Edwards desperately wanted to dispel the Mary Poppins syndrome afflicting his wife and believed that playing a traitor was a good career decision. As much as I like Julie, she's no Greta Garbo, who pulled it off so beautifully in MATA HARI. Funny enough, even if Julie plays a German spy, she still comes across as cloying and cute.

How bad is DARLING LILI? Even after 37 years since its release, Blake Edwards felt he still needed to work on it for its DVD release.

Julie Andrews plays a German spy who falls in love with an American pilot Rock Hudson, while on an assignment for Germany.

The songs are beautiful. The two are well-paired. Julie demonstrates a more temperamental side in this film than the nice girl she normally plays.

A half-German, half-English girl who sings beautiful and entertains the troops in WW I, Julie sings some endearing Mancini songs.

I loved the film. Some will say it's a "chick-flick," but so what. It's wonderful.

Supporting characters are somewhat stereotyped. It may not be up to Rock's performance in Pillow Talk, Magnificent Obsession, or Giant.

Blake Edwards shot the film in Ireland and authentic WW I -type planes were used in the film. Scenery for England and France is absolutely gorgeous.

As many would be aware there's 3 versions of this film. A (Can you believe it?) 3 hour+ original roadshow version which was last seen around the traps eons ago, the theatrical version of 136 minutes edited by Paramount and a 107 minute director's cut, which I haven't seen. I'm reviewing the the most commonly seen, theatrical cut, which Paramount wanted to distribute primarily as a musical to cash in on Julie Andrews's general popularity. In my opinion they should have stuck with director Blake Edwards's idea of eschewing most of the music and comedy sub-plots and concentrated on producing a darker war time romance, perhaps best imagined as a predecessor to something like 2016's very passable Robert Zemeckis directed Allies.

I have to be honest. The roadshow version must have been dire. I just couldn't imagine Darling Lili going on for almost another hour. As it is, it is way too padded out. The Rock/Julie courtship seems to go on interminably any way, before he finally sweeps her off her feet and carries her passionately towards the bedroom. Much of the singing footage doesn't really stand out much either and the comic stuff is strictly third rate material which was likely out-takes from Edwards's Pink Panther movies. In other words, mainly visual gags we've all seen before.

Having said that Darling Lili still has quite a bit going for it and is not quite the disaster, the early critics would have had you believe. It's wonderful to look at and has amazing visuals and glorious cinematography from Russel Harlan. This includes the fine aerial combat content with Rock Hudson's Major William Larrabee, a top American pilot flying with the British Royal Flying Corps and running into encounters with The Red Baron among others. The costuming and the selected locations (mainly Ireland and Belgium) can only be described as splendid. Rock and Julie do make a great pair and have a fun sexy chemistry, though as mentioned earlier, the preliminaries were endless and repetitive. We'd already got the message that they were very fond of each other, at least 30 minutes earlier.

I need to do myself a favour now and try and see the Edwards director's cut at some stage in the future. It sounds like it's going to make an interesting contrast with this version.

David Bryce's comments nearby are exceptionally well written and informative as almost say everything I feel about DARLING LILI. This massive musical is so peculiar and over blown, over produced and must have caused ruptures at Paramount in 1970. It cost 22 million dollars! That is simply irresponsible. DARLING LILI must have been greenlit from a board meeting that said "hey we got that Pink Panther guy and that Sound Of Music gal... lets get this too" and handed over a blank cheque. The result is a hybrid of GIGI, ZEPPELIN, HALF A SIXPENCE, some MGM 40s song and dance numbers of a style (daisies and boaters!) so hopelessly old fashioned as to be like musical porridge, and MATA HARI dramatics. The production is colossal, lush, breathtaking to view, but the rest: the ridiculous romance, Julie looking befuddled, Hudson already dead, the mistimed comedy, and the astoundingly boring songs deaden this spectacular film into being irritating. LILI is like a twee 1940s mega musical with some vulgar bits to spice it up. STAR! released the year before sadly crashed and now is being finally appreciated for the excellent film is genuinely is... and Andrews looks sublime, mature, especially in the last half hour......but LILI is POPPINS and DOLLY frilly and I believe really killed off the mega musical binge of the 60s..... and made Andrews look like Poppins again... which I believe was not Edwards intention. Paramount must have collectively fainted when they saw this: and with another $20 million festering in CATCH 22, and $12 million in ON A CLEAR DAY and $25 million in PAINT YOUR WAGON....they had a financial abyss of CLEOPATRA proportions with $77 million tied into 4 films with very uncertain futures. Maybe they should have asked seer Daisy Gamble from ON A CLEAR DAY ......LILI was very popular on immediate first release in Australia and ran in 70mm cinemas for months but it failed once out in the subs and the sticks and only ever surfaced after that on one night stands with ON A CLEAR DAY as a Sunday night double. Thank god Paramount had their simple $1million (yes, ONE MILLION DOLLAR) film LOVE STORY and that $4 million dollar gangster pic THE GODFATHER also ready to recover all the $77 million in just the next two years....for just $5m.... incredible!

Julie Andrews and Rock Hudson were great in this movie / musical. The opening song by Ms. Andrews, "Whistling Away the Dark," will always be in the back roads of my mind. The plot line during World War I, is great and suspenseful one. If you are a romantic, you will love this movie. This is a movie that I always enjoy to see again and again.

An obvious vanity press for Julie in her first movie with Blake. Let's see. Where do we begin. She is a traitor during a world war; she redeems that by falling in love; her friends (who are presumably patriots because they are German citizens) are expendable and must die; and she winds up as a heroine. OK. The scenes with the drunken pilot and the buffoons who work for French intelligence can't even be described, and we won't even mention Rock's romantic scenes with a female. (By the way, when they visit a museum, look at his gaze - I reran it on video and it's priceless). Is it a farce or is it a romantic classic or is it a war movie? I don't know and you won't either.