Wagon Wheels

Wagon Wheels is the worst western film of Randolph Scott's career. Why? It is something you never expect to see in a Scott film: It is boring. Scott is one of my western favorites ( maybe number three behind Gary Cooper and Alan Ladd). Speaking of Cooper, Wagon Wheels is a remake of Cooper's Fighting Caravans, and although the original was not Cooper's best it was far better. Lili Damita ( Felipe) was better looking and a better actress then Gail Patrick ( Nancy) and Cooper's Clint Balmet beats the Randolph Scott version. I will say that if you have not seen the original, you will probably like Wagon Wheels better then I did. I think Fighting Caravans is twice as good as Wagon Wheels and I gave Fighting Caravans 8 of 10 stars, so I give Wagon Wheels 4/10 stars.

Randolph Scott handled this Zane Grey classic with ease. Of course he had two of the best sidekicks in Raymond Hatton and Olin Howland to skillfully invigorate the plot when needed. Who better to play the leading lady than Gail Patrick as the widow with a child running from the past. A most artful character actor Monte Blue showcases his talents as the spy throwing every trick in the book in trying to stop the Wagon Wheels. I loved the music that was wonderfully interspersed throughout the film by various artists. With all this, my favorite performances were by Jan Duggan as Abby Masters and little Billy Lee as Sonny Wellington.

The print for this old western is only fair and unfortunately it does not have any sort of captioning---either closed captioning or DVD captions.

I chose to watch this film because it starred Randolph Scott--and I never turn down a chance to see another one of his westerns. Compared to the average film in the genre, Scott's always seem a bit better--much of it due to Scott's seemingly effortless acting. Even here, early in his career, his gentle yet rugged persona is intact--and quite enjoyable in this rather short B-movie. Another reason, it turned out, to see it was young Billy Lee--one of the cutest child actors I can recall--and not in a cloying and saccharine manner.

Not surprisingly considering the title, "Wagon Wheels" is about a wagon train that is heading to Oregon but must deal with the elements as well as American-Indians that are being stirred up by a jerky half-Indian (Murdock). Scott and his two very scruffy looking friends are in charge of getting these settlers to their destination.

As for the story, it's very straight-forward---without a lot of the sentiment and clichés you'd normally find in a 30s B-movie. As a result, the film does seem a tad rushed but is otherwise pretty watchable.

By the way, for historical purists out there, while the story is supposed to be set around 1850, the guns are clearly newer--with the settlers using what appear to be cartridges--which were not readily available at that time in history. Also, while popular in films, American-Indians did NOT make a habit of attacking wagon trains--in fact, it was a very, very rare occurrence.

In 1844 scout Clint Belmet and his two sidekicks guide a wagon train to the newly opened Oregon territory despite hardships and Indian attack in this Early Randolph Scott western that is pleasant viewing though it has tendency to meander.

In 1931 Paramount filmed Zane Grey's Fighting Caravans and turned it into an A picture western with Gary Cooper. It was the mentality of the studio bosses back then, why waste good stock footage. So a shorter version of this same story was done three years later with Randolph Scott playing the leading role of Clint Belmet.

Having both versions, I could compare them side by side. Same footage involving the wagon train going west and of the Indian attack climax. Just juxtapose close-ups of the current cast and you got yourself another movie on the cheap.

Since this version is only 56 minutes it was part of Paramount's B unit and played second on double bills.

Like in the first Fighting Caravans, Wagon Wheels has one young scout and two old ones leading the wagon train west. Gail Patrick gets one of her first and only leads. Usually Patrick is cast as the other woman. Maybe her best know role was as Carole Lombard's sister in My Man Godfrey.

Gary Cooper was an A list star, but Randolph Scott was on the way up and would get to not quite the top of the heap soon. He acquits himself well here.

Great stuff for the Saturday matinée crowd.