First appearance of Cory Rempel as Officer Ryan.
Sarah Strange appeared on the "Garage Sale Mysteries" as "Dani," the best friend and business partner of Lori Laughlin's "Jennifer Shannon," while Lochlyn Munro guest-starred on this installment as "Joel," a TV reality producer. On "Curious Caterer: Forbidden Fruit," it was Sarah who was guest starring as the manager of the fictional band The Faithfuls, while Lochlyn made regular appearances throughout the movie series as "Richard," ex-husband of baker/amateur detective "Goldie Berry" (Nikki DeLoach).