Eric Mabius credited as playing...
Oliver O'Toole
- Shane McInerney: Is there something you want to tell me Oliver?
- Oliver O'Toole: [Walks over to his office fridge but it's empty] We're out. And I'm not prepared to discuss this YooHoo free.
- Shane McInerney: I wasn't going to tell you this but I have Angie the barista keep a couple of emergency YooHoos for you behind the bar at the Mailbox Grille.
- Oliver O'Toole: Miss McInerney you never cease to surprise me and I hope to some day return the favor.
- Shane McInerney: You made that Valentine.
- Oliver O'Toole: All by myself. The heart was a little...
- Shane McInerney: No it's perfect. I haven't gotten a homemade Valentine since Joe Cook made me one in the second grade. He ran up to me on the playground shoved it in my hand then punched me in the shoulder.
- Oliver O'Toole: Well then this must have been something of a let down.
- Shane McInerney: [laughs] No. Not at all. I just wish... Why didn't you just say 'hey Shane did you get my invitation?'
- Oliver O'Toole: Well um, a gentleman never makes assumptions about a woman's affairs.
- Shane McInerney: But I didn't have any affairs. I got a massage, a pizza and took a very long jog that happened to take me past a gentleman's window as he sat by candlelight reading a book with music and a glass of wine... I know, I know it was a childish thing to do.
- Oliver O'Toole: Or perhaps we're just finally old enough to know that sometimes matters of the heart can hurt more than...
- Shane McInerney: Than a punch in the shoulder?
- Oliver O'Toole: Precisely.
- Shane McInerney: I'm sorry Oliver.
- Oliver O'Toole: I'm sorry too... Shane.