Powerful and bloody.
This is not strictly-speaking an adaption of Erich Maria Remarque's classic. A few minor incidents from the novel are included, but Remarque's biggest contribution to this film is the title. Given the ending of the film (as opposed to the book) the title is somewhat misleading, but it's such a classic that the film-makers' decision is quite understandable.
This is a brutal and uncompromising study of the realities of war. The fact the the war depicted took place more than a hundred years ago doesn't make it any less relevant. It could be shown in Ukraine today, and soldiers on both sides would understand.
Nor is the film's anti-war message terribly new. It is, however, a message that needs to be repeated over and over again, until (maybe) enough people take it seriously.
The battle scenes are appallingly visceral - possibly the best of their type since the opening of Saving Private Ryan.
The history of any war is written by the winners, but that doesn't stop them being a tragedy for the poor grunts on the losing side as well.
This is a brutal and uncompromising study of the realities of war. The fact the the war depicted took place more than a hundred years ago doesn't make it any less relevant. It could be shown in Ukraine today, and soldiers on both sides would understand.
Nor is the film's anti-war message terribly new. It is, however, a message that needs to be repeated over and over again, until (maybe) enough people take it seriously.
The battle scenes are appallingly visceral - possibly the best of their type since the opening of Saving Private Ryan.
The history of any war is written by the winners, but that doesn't stop them being a tragedy for the poor grunts on the losing side as well.
- Lomax343
- Oct 19, 2022