AVALIAÇÃO DA IMDb
6,4/10
2,7 mil
SUA AVALIAÇÃO
Este documentário mergulha nos mistérios em torno dos Neandertais e no que seus registros fósseis nos revelam sobre suas vidas e desaparecimento.Este documentário mergulha nos mistérios em torno dos Neandertais e no que seus registros fósseis nos revelam sobre suas vidas e desaparecimento.Este documentário mergulha nos mistérios em torno dos Neandertais e no que seus registros fósseis nos revelam sobre suas vidas e desaparecimento.
- Prêmios
- 3 vitórias no total
Emma Pomeroy
- Self - Palaeoanthropologist, University of Cambridge
- (as Dr. Emma Pomeroy)
Graeme Barker
- Self - Shanidar Cave Project Director, University of Cambridge
- (as Professor Graeme Barker)
Davorka Radovcic
- Self - Krapina Collection Curator, Croatian Natural History Museum
- (as Davorka Radovčić)
Chris Hunt
- Self - Geoarchaeologist, Liverpool John Moores University
- (as Professor Chris Hunt)
Lucía López-Polín
- Self - Conservator, Shanidar Cave Project
- (as Dr. Lucía López-Polín)
Amanda Henry
- Self - Associate Professor, Leiden University
- (as Dr. Amanda Henry)
Sophie Verheyden
- Self - Geologist, Royal Belgian institute of Natural Sciences
- (as Dr. Sophie Verheyden)
Jacques Jaubert
- Self - Archaeologist, University of Bordeaux
- (as Professor Jacques Jaubert)
Clive Finlayson
- Self - Director, Gibraltar National Museum
- (as Dr. Clive Finlayson)
Geraldine Finlayson
- Self - Chief Executive Officer, Gibraltar National Museum
- (as Professor Geraldine Finlayson)
Ralph Solecki
- Self - Archaeologist
- (cenas de arquivo)
- (as Professor Ralph Solecki)
Patrick Stewart
- Self - Narrator
- (narração)
- (as Sir Patrick Stewart)
Avaliações em destaque
"Secrets of A Neanderthal" presents itself as an intriguing exploration into the lives of our ancient relatives, the Neanderthals. However, while the documentary offers fascinating insights, it falls short in its tendency to present assumptions as facts.
Throughout the film, viewers are bombarded with speculative assertions about Neanderthal behavior, culture, and interactions. While these hypotheses are certainly thought-provoking, the documentary often fails to distinguish between established evidence and mere conjecture.
One of the most glaring issues is the danger of presenting theories as concrete truths, especially when discussing events that occurred over 50,000 years ago. The limitations of archaeological evidence and the inherent biases in interpretation should caution against such definitive claims. Yet, "Secrets of A Neanderthal" seems to disregard this, leading to a potentially misleading and overconfident portrayal of the Neanderthals and their world.
Viewers would be wise to approach the film with a critical eye, recognizing that many of its assertions are, in fact, speculative in nature.
Throughout the film, viewers are bombarded with speculative assertions about Neanderthal behavior, culture, and interactions. While these hypotheses are certainly thought-provoking, the documentary often fails to distinguish between established evidence and mere conjecture.
One of the most glaring issues is the danger of presenting theories as concrete truths, especially when discussing events that occurred over 50,000 years ago. The limitations of archaeological evidence and the inherent biases in interpretation should caution against such definitive claims. Yet, "Secrets of A Neanderthal" seems to disregard this, leading to a potentially misleading and overconfident portrayal of the Neanderthals and their world.
Viewers would be wise to approach the film with a critical eye, recognizing that many of its assertions are, in fact, speculative in nature.
Patrick Stewart is the narrator of this light "documentary", and the posh received pronunciation accent starts to drone quickly. British accents have oversaturated the documentary landscape. I can't abide listening to them for several hours anymore.
I've read that the Scottish accent is the most desirable in terms of call centres, and that is due to its pleasing lilt.
Anyway, aside from the tedious voiceover, there's really nothing much here, and it seems to be a hair and makeup exhibit more than an educational journey into an interesting topic.
And now I shall keep writing until the required character limit is met. Thanks for reading.
I've read that the Scottish accent is the most desirable in terms of call centres, and that is due to its pleasing lilt.
Anyway, aside from the tedious voiceover, there's really nothing much here, and it seems to be a hair and makeup exhibit more than an educational journey into an interesting topic.
And now I shall keep writing until the required character limit is met. Thanks for reading.
Some of the comments from reviewers are strange in that the reviewers seem disappointed there are assumptions. Of course there are. That's archaeology. I am a post graduate archaeologist and making assumptions is part of the process of interpretation. The modern evidence is showing Solecki's assumptions were partly incorrect and I have no doubt that in 50 years the science will have advanced so that new interpretations and assumptions are made. However, this wonderful documentary is a fantastic introduction to the world of the Neanderthals and what we currently know about them. For instance, it's only in the last 20 years we have established they ate plants. Kudos to the international team that have made these wonderful discoveries and long might they prosper.
This is exactly what you can expect from a documentary on Neanderthals. I see too many reviews saying it should be more precise and less speculative because "science is not speculative." Do you know how hard it is to even determine the sex of old skeletons, let alone anything else? Archaeologists, in most cases, can't say anything with 100% certainty. Of course, it's speculative. Until you know something with complete assurance, you don't truly know.
With all this said, I'm very satisfied with this documentary. I heard about it from someone who called it a "series," and I was excited to watch something longer than this, but nonetheless, it's totally worth watching. The scenery is absolutely amazing.
With all this said, I'm very satisfied with this documentary. I heard about it from someone who called it a "series," and I was excited to watch something longer than this, but nonetheless, it's totally worth watching. The scenery is absolutely amazing.
Netflix's "Secrets of the Neanderthals" isn't exactly breaking new ground in documentary filmmaking. The familiar troupe of talking heads and sweeping nature shots is present. Yet, there's a certain charm to this BBC Studios production, fueled by a genuine fascination with our extinct cousins.
The documentary hinges on a recent excavation at Shanidar Cave in the Kurdistan Region of Iraq. We follow a team of archaeologists, led by the enthusiastic Professor Graeme Barker, as they unearth a remarkably well-preserved Neanderthal skeleton - the first of its kind in the region for over 25 years. This discovery forms the narrative spine, allowing the exploration of Neanderthal life through the lens of this individual.
What elevates "Secrets of the Neanderthals" is its focus on debunking outdated stereotypes. Neanderthals are no longer depicted as knuckle-dragging brutes. The film effectively highlights their complex tool use, elaborate burial rituals, and potential capacity for symbolic thought. This revised image is bolstered by impressive CGI reconstructions that breathe life into these ancient humans.
However, the documentary falters slightly in its pacing. The Shanidar Cave excavation, while significant, can feel drawn-out at times. Additionally, some scientific explanations could have benefited from a touch more simplification for a broader audience.
Overall, "Secrets of the Neanderthals" is a solid and informative documentary. It serves as a timely reminder that our understanding of human prehistory is constantly evolving. While not a groundbreaking masterpiece, it's an engaging watch for anyone curious about our enigmatic ancestors.
The documentary hinges on a recent excavation at Shanidar Cave in the Kurdistan Region of Iraq. We follow a team of archaeologists, led by the enthusiastic Professor Graeme Barker, as they unearth a remarkably well-preserved Neanderthal skeleton - the first of its kind in the region for over 25 years. This discovery forms the narrative spine, allowing the exploration of Neanderthal life through the lens of this individual.
What elevates "Secrets of the Neanderthals" is its focus on debunking outdated stereotypes. Neanderthals are no longer depicted as knuckle-dragging brutes. The film effectively highlights their complex tool use, elaborate burial rituals, and potential capacity for symbolic thought. This revised image is bolstered by impressive CGI reconstructions that breathe life into these ancient humans.
However, the documentary falters slightly in its pacing. The Shanidar Cave excavation, while significant, can feel drawn-out at times. Additionally, some scientific explanations could have benefited from a touch more simplification for a broader audience.
Overall, "Secrets of the Neanderthals" is a solid and informative documentary. It serves as a timely reminder that our understanding of human prehistory is constantly evolving. While not a groundbreaking masterpiece, it's an engaging watch for anyone curious about our enigmatic ancestors.
Principais escolhas
Faça login para avaliar e ver a lista de recomendações personalizadas
Detalhes
- Data de lançamento
- País de origem
- Idiomas
- Também conhecido como
- Secrets of the Neanderthals
- Empresa de produção
- Consulte mais créditos da empresa na IMDbPro
- Tempo de duração
- 1 h 20 min(80 min)
- Cor
Contribua para esta página
Sugerir uma alteração ou adicionar conteúdo ausente