Mike Birbiglia: The Old Man and the Pool

I am not sure why but I just don't enjoy Mike Birbiglia's stand up routine. He is a bright enough guy. His stories make me smile sometime but I think he is, essentially, not that funny. This is not just this stand up special, but all of his. That is the reason I hesitated to watch this one; however, it came up on my recommended specials so I watched it. The special is filled with personal stories. I really dislike his delivery the most. Not sure why- but it gets on my nerves. If you like Mike this might be an enjoyable experience for you. I did like the venue. I think his outfit is from a clown closet.

But please bear in mind that, of course it's just my opinion and it's SO subjective, this comedy thing but... I personally strongly disliked it and I LOVE 'Birbigs', like all time faves loved :( - I think in part it's due to the, now commonplace occurrence in comedians of a certain age, trend of mortality and experiences with increasing frequency of doctors appointments, that's so off-putting - but I don't come to a stand up show to grow my anxiety and overall shpilkis ya know? I don't know, maybe something is wrong with me and I'm not appreciating and enjoying comedy as I used to but this seemed exceedingly lacking - maybe just stay home with Oona (Una?) from now on, instead of talking four years to bring us stress and lackluster -in short, this is something I'd expect from Niel Brennan, except he treats his time like a therapy session.

On November 21, 2024, I had the hilarious pleasure of witnessing him in Detroit, MI, and oh, I was utterly smitten! His live performance outshone his latest special, which left me a tad underwhelmed. The new special on Netflix just didn't tickle my funny bone as much as The New One did, and the timing seemed off, almost as if it was recorded last year. The material felt disconnected from his live act, which was a riot. I think he missed a beat by not exploring his dad's stroke and his own fatherhood more deeply, as those bits were both poignant and hilarious. Seeing him live was a treat, especially the parts about his dad and daughter - it was comedy gold. I'm a huge fan, but this latest special just didn't make me laugh as much as I hoped.

Mike Birbiglia and Neal Brennan have transcended standup. Both of their latest specials on Netflix have left me with more than just laughter. Both of these phenomenal specials left me with deep thought but without the weight of it all. It's mature comedy in the sense it's for people who've lived some life. Life is hard, and we need to laugh. We MUST laugh.

As a lifelong standup fan, I'm at the age where the one-liners aren't doing it for me anymore. I want stories. I want to relate. I want connection. And Mike Birbiglia's "The Old Man & The Pool" and Neal Brennan's "Blocks" do exactly that through immersive, humorous storytelling.

I have thoroughly enjoyed Mike Birbiglia's work for years now, but I realized watching "The New One" and then this special "The Old Man and the Pool" that he isn't a comedian. He is an exquisite storyteller and a talented comedian, for sure. But Mike has become a "humorist". His work, either written or performed live, is imbued with pathos, intelligence, poetry, and insight. A mediation on life, health, and death, his new special is genuinely funny and also moving. I identified with so many of his musings that I recognized myself in his presentation.

Mike Birbiglia is a humorist in the same breath as America's other favorite humorists. Mark Twain, Erma Bombeck, and Garrison Keillor. Watching this special was like sitting down and enjoying a good book. You finish it deeply satisfied and better for the experience.