AVALIAÇÃO DA IMDb
6,7/10
23 mil
SUA AVALIAÇÃO
Um garotinho brilhante é atormentado por dois grandes valentões idiotas.Um garotinho brilhante é atormentado por dois grandes valentões idiotas.Um garotinho brilhante é atormentado por dois grandes valentões idiotas.
- Prêmios
- 1 indicação no total
- Direção
- Roteiristas
- Elenco e equipe completos
- Produção, bilheteria e muito mais no IMDbPro
Avaliações em destaque
The Swan.
A small brilliant boy is tormented by two large idiotic bullies.
First of all, I almost forgot it was a short movie until it finished !
I was fully involved in this magical story and the way it was presented that I'd call it lazy for not capturing what's happening and instead telling what's happening through beautiful frames.
It may look lazy but I know it must be even harder to make such as a thing, especially nowadays when you simply can make it normal, Wes Anderson is beyond that.
The production design was stunning as always and I enjoyed every minute of it, I need more of these colorful narratives by Wes.
A small brilliant boy is tormented by two large idiotic bullies.
First of all, I almost forgot it was a short movie until it finished !
I was fully involved in this magical story and the way it was presented that I'd call it lazy for not capturing what's happening and instead telling what's happening through beautiful frames.
It may look lazy but I know it must be even harder to make such as a thing, especially nowadays when you simply can make it normal, Wes Anderson is beyond that.
The production design was stunning as always and I enjoyed every minute of it, I need more of these colorful narratives by Wes.
A young boy relentlessly bullied by two older boys finally finds the strength to escape his tormentors. The pair of cruel older boys, who enjoy shooting songbirds in the hedgerow and ultimately kill the titular bird while it's nurturing its young are so repulsive that they drift into caricature (as perhaps was the intent, as they are figments of the narrator's memories). Like Anderson's other recent Dahl interpretations, 'The Swan' is a stagy, borderline surreal, meta-production that puts style far ahead of content. The cast is great, as is the intricate imagery, so I enjoyed the short despite the disagreeable and mean-spirited cruelty that permeates the story.
'The Swan (2023)' is perhaps the most stripped-back of Wes Anderson's four Roald Dahl shorts, with only one real major character and a more relaxed approach to the intricate stage-like design that each entry in this pseudo series makes distinct use of. It really feels like Rupert Friend is reading you a story - occasionally altering his pitch, timbre and accent to do the voices of the various characters - and, in its own way, feels strangely intimate. The story itself, although presented with a certain level of twee whimsy, is incredibly bleak and culminates with an ending that hits you like a truck. It's a case of tell more than show, but the aesthetic is specifically designed to accommodate this and it actually makes some moments feel potentially more potent than they would have in more traditional fare. It's a compelling effort overall that moves at a solid pace and has a tangible emotional impact that sneaks up on you but leaves you speechless as the credits roll.
The Swan is heartbreaking but ultimately powerful stuff, a story of never backing down or letting monstrous people win. It's uneasy viewing and definitely the darkest of the Wes Anderson Roald Dahl shorts in the most rewarding way possible.
Rupert Friend essentially carries this, narrating everything with almost no support until Fiennes' closing words that adds real power to it. Until then Friend is phenomenal, narrating at a fast speed with a real pain to his voice as he describes what is clearly a very painful memory.
Wes Anderson's direction works so well here, the whimsical world created contrasts so effectively against the dark nature and it's generally just so stunning. This fully artificial world that acts like a play is endlessly watchable and each short has been so unique.
Rupert Friend essentially carries this, narrating everything with almost no support until Fiennes' closing words that adds real power to it. Until then Friend is phenomenal, narrating at a fast speed with a real pain to his voice as he describes what is clearly a very painful memory.
Wes Anderson's direction works so well here, the whimsical world created contrasts so effectively against the dark nature and it's generally just so stunning. This fully artificial world that acts like a play is endlessly watchable and each short has been so unique.
Wes Anderson's "The Swan," a part of an impressive short film collection inspired by Roald Dahl's stories on Netflix presents viewers with a vivid adaptation of Dahl's tale resonating with Anderson's signature stylistic flair. Featuring a stellar cast including Asa Jennings as the young Peter Watson and Rupert Friend portraying the adult Peter the 17-minute narrative plunges into the unsettling account of young Peter's encounter with two bullies.
Throughout the film, Anderson's masterful touch is evident, blending live-action with animation seamlessly, giving life to Dahl's rich storytelling. Embracing a strong visual design, the film possesses Anderson's penchant for symmetry and direct camera engagement. Though the plot unfolds through narration, suggesting more of the cruelty than explicitly showcasing it, the experience felt immersive. Such is the potency of the narrative that at moments, it seems like a reading session of Dahl's story rather than a motion picture.
However, the film might not resonate with everyone, especially those unfamiliar or less appreciative of Anderson's unique style, which over the years has been refined and might come across as predictable to some. Nevertheless, for fans of Anderson and Dahl, "The Swan" stands as a testament to storytelling excellence, artfully presented and layered with nuanced details awaiting rediscovery upon subsequent viewings.
Beyond "The Swan," Anderson's other Dahl adaptations, notably "The Wonderful Story of Henry Sugar" and "Ratcatcher," further cements his prowess in translating Dahl's universe onto the screen.
In essence, "The Swan" is a captivating piece, masterfully bridging Anderson's cinematic artistry with Dahl's narrative brilliance.
Throughout the film, Anderson's masterful touch is evident, blending live-action with animation seamlessly, giving life to Dahl's rich storytelling. Embracing a strong visual design, the film possesses Anderson's penchant for symmetry and direct camera engagement. Though the plot unfolds through narration, suggesting more of the cruelty than explicitly showcasing it, the experience felt immersive. Such is the potency of the narrative that at moments, it seems like a reading session of Dahl's story rather than a motion picture.
However, the film might not resonate with everyone, especially those unfamiliar or less appreciative of Anderson's unique style, which over the years has been refined and might come across as predictable to some. Nevertheless, for fans of Anderson and Dahl, "The Swan" stands as a testament to storytelling excellence, artfully presented and layered with nuanced details awaiting rediscovery upon subsequent viewings.
Beyond "The Swan," Anderson's other Dahl adaptations, notably "The Wonderful Story of Henry Sugar" and "Ratcatcher," further cements his prowess in translating Dahl's universe onto the screen.
In essence, "The Swan" is a captivating piece, masterfully bridging Anderson's cinematic artistry with Dahl's narrative brilliance.
Você sabia?
- CuriosidadesOne of four Netflix shorts directed by Wes Anderson and based on stories by Roald Dahl, all released over four days in the same week: September 27-30, 2023.
- Part 1, A Incrível História de Henry Sugar (2023) - September 27
- Part 2, this film - September 28
- Part 3, O Caçador de Ratos (2023) - September 29
- Part 4, Veneno (2023) - September 30
- Citações
Roald Dahl: Some people, when they have taken too much and have been driven beyond the point of endurance, simply crumble and collapse and give up. Others however, though they are not many, who will for some reason always be unconquerable. You meet them in time of war and also in time of peace. They have an indomitable spirit. And nothing, neither pain, nor torture, nor threat of death will cause them to give up. Little Peter Watson was one of these.
- ConexõesEdited into The Wonderful Story of Henry Sugar and Three More (2024)
Principais escolhas
Faça login para avaliar e ver a lista de recomendações personalizadas
Detalhes
- Data de lançamento
- País de origem
- Central de atendimento oficial
- Idioma
- Também conhecido como
- Лебідь
- Locações de filme
- Empresas de produção
- Consulte mais créditos da empresa na IMDbPro
- Tempo de duração
- 17 min
- Cor
- Proporção
- 1.66 : 1
- 16 : 9
Contribua para esta página
Sugerir uma alteração ou adicionar conteúdo ausente