O Homem que Não Se Calou

As a Bosnian, A Man Who Couldn't Remain Silent struck me on a profoundly personal level. The film captures emotions so raw and real that they stay with you long after the credits roll. The cinematography is intimate yet powerful, with every frame carefully composed to reflect the weight of the story. The sound design, subtle but deeply immersive, adds another layer to the experience-every silence, every echo feels intentional and haunting.

What truly touched me was the authenticity of the emotions. The film doesn't just tell a story; it makes you feel it. The pain, the resilience, the unspoken words-it's all there, beautifully portrayed through nuanced performances and a gripping atmosphere. Unfortunately, the English translation loses many of the local anecdotes that give the film its depth and authenticity, which is a shame because these details are what make it so uniquely powerful.

I'm amazed at how a short film can leave such a lasting impression. In just a brief runtime, it delivers an emotional punch stronger than many full-length features. A must-watch for those who appreciate cinema that speaks from the heart.

Road to the Oscars 2025: This is nominated for one Oscar best short film.

This one I didn´t know much about going in and it was a short that send me down a rabbit hole to understand it fully. Not that it is hard to understand, but it depicts a historical time and war I simply did not know much about. It is always nice to be challenged and asked to know more, but this is a short where you need to know a little bit about the Balkan war to really let it hit. It is still impactful and relevant to think about in today's international climate, but as a history drama on its own it needs a little context.

A train is stopped looking for anyone believing in the wrong god. A man is hiding with no papers to show.

I really liked the cinematography here. It is in this old claustrophobic train and it definitely works as intended, only adding to the tension in the short. No where to hide or run to.

Ad mentioned, you need to know your history a little bit to make the short really land. It is not holding your hand, assuming you know why these men are doing the atrocities they are. After reading a bit about the Balkan wars, it is sad to see countries hunting down each other like this. And also as mentioned it is something that rings out even if you understand the context or not as ethnic hunts still persist to this day. It is always nice having a short shining a light on something you don´t really know much about, making you learn more.

This is a rather plotless shorty though. Not much happens and it is primarily waiting for the confrontation, but with a rather good use of tension.

This was a good short and one shining a light on a part of history that is interesting to read about. It might have needed a bit more in terms of its plot though.

Oscar predictions: I think this is the weakest of the 3 shorts I have watched in the category. Doesn't make it bad, but weaker compared to I´m not a robot(2023) or A lien(2023). It is also not really pushing an academy agenda.

A movie you watch with a lump in your throat. From the beginning, there is an underlying ominous tone, all because of the events that happened as the curtain falls on this perfectly executed short.

In today's day and age, there was no need for the director to show you the atrocities, the executions, the blood and gore - it's all a quick google search away. This horrific crime against humanity, and many more committed by the same perpetrator, are yours to learn about, spread the knowledge, and do whatever is in your power not to let them happen again.

The film also, as the director states, sends a broader, universal message about true heroes and helping fellow man, standing up to an oppressor when it matters most.

Intense story about war time and legitimation of abuse and reaction about rights of the other , ignoring the risks.

A train, an army presumed check , a young man without ID papers and the simple story of survive of other .

The atmosphere is the main trait and, for older viewers, the remind of episodes presented by media, at the first part of 1990 decade, from Yugoslavian space.

The portrait of Dragan, proposed by Goran Bogdan , is one of basic essential virtues of film. The interest of militaries is to identify Muslims - this explains the familiar question in Serbian culture, about the saint patron of family. But the heart is the sacrifice of captain for save the young man . And the brutality of military, like his lie .

In short, intense story for profound remind of a version of evil never dead.

This is quite a tensely shot short drama that depicts a scene on a train that has been stopped on it's journey through Bosnia by a paramilitary gang seeking Muslims. They are polite enough to the "brother" passengers whose papers they inspect, but "Milan" (Silvio Mumelas) in one carriage has no papers and is terrified. His fellow travellers offer him some comfort and one, the retired captain "Tomo" (Dragan Micanovic) sticks his neck out when they try to remove the man from their compartment. When the train eventually moves on, fellow passenger and family man "Dragan" (Goran Bogdan) wonders if he, too, ought to have done more. The Balkan conflict of the early 1990s has been largely forgotten by us now, so this is quite a poignant reminder of the cruelties of ethnic cleansing enforced during a brutal war that saw the rule of law abandoned and the rule of a vengeful few capitalise on the fears of the general population to impose their will.