Combat Girls

A film about right wing racism in Germany and a groan is predictable. While following the narrative of such stories, the cast and the style of the film offer a new perspective.

The film is presented in a semi-documentary style, with scenes and transitions which are more like a documentary. The near realism - or TV like visual style - makes the building of the story interesting and unpredictable.

The present is mixed with the back story of the lead character which allows for insight without her telling us because she can't.

The cast have seemingly inhabited the roles and the script and together with the camera work, which puts the audience in the center of things, adds to the directness of the film.

The story of racist violence is counterpointed with violence at other levels between the German characters and their families. In this grim environment a brief reconciliation emerges but is quickly shattered. The ending is almost poetic in an ugly place.

A very fine achievement.

I heard someone say that the movie can be educational? The truth is that I would not watch this movie for educational purposes and not even with children under 18 years of age.

The morality is clear and that is why the movie does not emphasize on certain things. I didn't like this approach at all!, it is too black and white, and too much violence.

It's not just racism, it's the way of treating it, racism with violence, the worst there is. This is a hateful group of young people lost in life, whose brain has been spinned and they have no way out, the only thing that makes sense to them is violence, and on top of that they look for it, violence, and provoke it, it is the only way to feel power for them. But what do they care? They have weapons and explode at the slightest, everyone fears them, and rightly so. It would scare me too, a lot! Even the parents and grandfather scare me!

What I found even more racist and frustrating is treating a young man from Pakistan like a real idiot, for seeking help from the person who hates him and has tried to kill him.

The acting is good and realistic and this is the most positive thing I can add. Even the music seemed terrible to my taste.

The movie will not resolve everything or not in a satisfying kind of way. At the contrary, it lacks a sense of justice in one way or another, big time!

As I say, I still can't believe I've seen the entire movie. If you can stand it this story has the ability to drag you in by the very rough and emotional violent ride.

During the first few minutes I sat with my heart racing wanting to kill them all! Judge for yourself.

I'm certain this is going to be Germany's nominee for the Oscars.

The auteur, David Wnendt, seems to have collected a lot of true stories and pieced them together into a fast-paced, very violent, often harrowing and quite unpredictable plot.

Most of you don't know the East German neo-nazi scene. You'll ask yourself if this is really how these people live and talk. Believe me, it is. This movie is so close to reality it often feels like a documentary. I expected to sit in the cinema nitpicking, counting mistakes. I found just one. (A license plate with an "88" in it. The German license plate office doesn't allow that.) All the actors are unknowns and few of them get to shine. All the adults in this story are wooden and almost all the teenagers are idiots. Their main job is to convey total ignorance about the extent of their ignorance. They do that well. Jella Haase is very good.

But Alina Levshin is the one who's superstar material. This is her movie, and it will be remembered as her breakthrough. Two of the movie's most memorable scenes are long uncut closeups of her face, not speaking, and they're some of the best acting I've seen, ever.

Do see it. Just don't expect to sleep easily the night after.

The topic of right wing extremists in Germany is a very hot one. The movie tries to stay as real as possible with its depiction of the characters it portrays and the world they are living in. It's not an easy watch and it especially isn't easy to play. Main actress does a fabulous job here.

The morality is clear and that is why the movie does not emphasize on certain things. You'll either like this approach or you'll think it's takes the matter too lightly. Whatever the case don't expect your usual mainstream approach. The movie will not resolve everything or not in a satisfying kind of way. The acting alone is worth watching it of course.

Very good by all means. Done marvelously in the technical and artistic way. And did I say very touching? The movie has dark and very heavy structure. It looks so authentic that involves you easily and then make you upset. It gives a smart portrait of the local neo-nazi movement in one German town but also all the social background that causes the phenomena of it. The basis of the whole movement was actually shown through the character of the main character. The ideals of its members are the same but the inner struggles of the individuals are individual. Fight between good and bad, between love and hate depicted beautifully followed by excellent acting. I also found the music very good. Excellent work! Keep on working.