The Waltons' Homecoming

Nothing about this movie felt genuine to 1930s, those are the nicest clothes I've ever seen for a poor family during the depression. I am a fan of the show and never really liked the movie even though I have to watch it every year I would now gladly watch it over this one any day. The acting and dialogue is on par for CW, so not very good. This sorta feels like it was put together by people who were fired from Hallmark and Lifetime channels. I am actually suprised that the people at CW gave the go ahead for a movie that spoke of God and churches, especially nowadays.

I wanted to like this update, but it was lacking in soul. There was a desperation to the original given the depression, the financial straits the family was in and the fear the father might be... This version was too sunny and you felt nothing of a family living in angst. Someone didn't do their homework in the language - way too contemporary references and the swearing didn't fit. I would have been open to a new holiday tradition, but alas, even the original John Boy couldn't save this half-baked turkey.

I remember watching the original Homecoming in 1970s, and the series when it ran and in reruns. This was a modernized, diversified, and sanitized version of the classic movie that I love. I was looking forward to seeing it, and sadly I was disappointed. It didn't have the feel of the original that showed the struggles of a large family during the depression in 1933. A time when money and jobs were hard to find, and most were living hand to mouth.

Everything from the clothing, to the house appeared too perfect, and new. That left me asking, did the production team do any research into what a family and home really look like in 1933 rural Virginia?

The characters were a bit too modern in the way they spoke and actions for 1933. Especially Mary Ellen, who should have been wearing a NOW button. Also, where was Ben???

I did enjoy Richard Thomas' narration.

The original, 50 years ago, I watched at least a dozen or more times, over the years. Here is the problem comparing the two. First, the house in this episode looked like a mansion for 1933. The original movie they lived poorer, like the real 1933, and lived in a cabin. Secondly, the original version showed the strain of possibly losing the husband and bread winner, on the face of the wife, Libby. She would be forced to raise them children without much. This new movie did not capture the worry on the face of the wife or children when John Sr was missing. Lastly, the beautiful house was well furnished with nice paintings. Sure didn't remind me of a depression era. The actors did their part without much feelings. They should never have done a remake. Let the original live on.

The original "The Homecoming: A Christmas" is not only one of the best Christmas movies ever made it's also one of the best made-for-tv movies ever made. So "The Waltons: Homecoming" had very big shoes to fill. I have seen the original dozens of times. Watching this movie felt strange. Nothing really clicked. It certainly didn't feel like the 1930s. But still, I found "The Waltons: Homecoming" strangely fascinating. I can't wait to see it again.