O Astronauta

If you expect First Man or Martian like I did you might be a little disappointed. It is mostly a drama focused on a main character's lifelong goal to travel to space, and people around him that believe in him and support the idea, no matter how crazy it is.

Other than a nice and somewhat believable story there is not much to offer of value. Main and supporting characters were not likeable and believable and production feels low budget, but they have everything they need which I admire.

It is not a movie I will remember or recommend to watch, but I don't feel sorry for watching it, it had its few moments and makes you feel a bit better about having somewhat impossible dreams.

The cast were great. Good acting and emotive subtitles. The story was simple and if you can get past the completely unrealistic plot and concentrate on the message it's an ok way to past the time. Nothing much happens. That's the film's problem. And what does happen is just not realistic. But I guess we don't always have to have realism in a film. I wouldn't recommend anyone go see this, it's not a must see movie, but for what it was, a film about a man perusing his dream in order to fulfil his grandfathers, then it's ok. But would have liked to have seen this cast with a more meaty script and a much more involved story. P. S. The 'love interest' looks like Sinhead O'Connor on a very bad dress down relapse day. 1 out of 10 for wardrobe in this one.

"Jim?"

I attended the film premiere at Cairo International Film Festival. Among genuinly engaged audience I had a great time. A straightforward challenge story by classic elements is put in a sublime narrative.

Very good cast and the acting was spot on. Great achievement in production design. I really liked the connections between Jim and everyone around him, family, friends and co-workers. It looked sincere and meaningful. All the tiwsts and turns came out the right way with very good directing.

The film had the biggest standing ovation I've witnessed in this round of the festival. Bravo Nicolas and all the crew.

I really liked the underlying sentiment to this film. It takes one of the most complex of scientific subjects and humanises it. This is not a film about gizmos and gadgets, there is precious little (if any) CGI. It is all essentially a love story. Not between two people, but between "Jim" (Nicolas Giraud) and his passion - going into space. His character is normal, poorly funded and maybe not the best at collaborating, but as he and "Alexandre" (Mathieu Kassovitz) gradually start to realise that the unattainable might, actually, be attainable then they - alongside what can only be described as a truly collegiate community effort - strive to try to make it work. I know absolutely nothing about rocket science, so I cannot comment with any authority on the science that underpins this, but the whole thing has a genuine authenticity to it. It's fun. Thats not meant to sound trite - it's not a laugh-a-minute; it's a story about people who galvanise each other and share in the goal - even if they haven't really much clue what's going on. Hélène Vincent turns in a strong performance as the long-suffering "Odette" and a generally engaging ensemble cast contribute well to something here that is enjoyable to watch and that ought to send a clear signal to Hollywood (and elsewhere) that it's not all about the money and the visual effects - but about the strength of the writing and the characterisation. Maybe don't show it to your kids, though, or your garden may quickly turn into "Mos Eisley" spaceport!

Unfulfilled dream, impossible and unrealistic story - but beautifully told.

Through the whole film I was on the edge of my seat, because the story grabs you in the beginning and doesn't let you go till the very end. I felt fully invested in this film and the music score helps a lot with building the right atmosphere. Also although I am no expert in space technology, I felt that all of the tech-talk, tools and space ships materials etc. Felt realistic and because of that it actually became quite believable. And I must admit I actually shed a tear in the end because of how moving and touching it was.

I can imagine this story being made into a Hollywood blockbuster or even a comedy, but director Nicolas Giraud lends this picture an intimate and modest, yet elaborate feel.

As a benefit I must also mention a great performance by Mathieu Kassovitz in the supporting role.

It actually became one of my favourite movies of the year.