Coming into Speak No Evil, I was told this was one of the most disturbing movies of all time. It isn't, in my opinion. Maybe I'm desensitized, because while there is a very terrifying and hard to watch sequence in this movie...there's only one, really. On some level, it's my own fault for listening to the hype, and I was somewhat disappointed the movie wasn't more intense.
Also, I can acknowledge that this movie is a, frustrating, experience to say the least. You know when you watch horror movies and scream at the screen for the characters to trust their instincts and LEAVE? Well yeah, this movie will annoy the hell out of you. (Of course, if the characters did the logical thing, the movie wouldn't happen.) I feel like there are cultural differences here too, which explains some of the character's behaviour.
That all being said, this is a good movie. It's extremely tense and uncomfortable, with a lot of the appeal coming from waiting for the shoe to drop.
The film follows a Danish family - Bjorn (Morten Burian) and Louisa (Sidsel Koch) who take up the invitation of a pleasant Dutch family they met on vacation to visit their home in the Dutch countrside. Normal stuff, until the Dutch hosts begin acting somewhat strange and begin testing the Danes' social niceties and tolerance.
As the movie unfolds, it becomes almost unbearable as every cringe inducing moment seems like the one that will bring forth the inevitable horror. The movie does a good job setting up peaks and troughs, and even adding some complexity to the narrative. The men seem to share a bond, Bjorn, somewhat emasculated and timid, embraces the primal spontaneity and energy of his Dutch counter part, Patrick.
And that's what elevates this movie from another paint-by-numbers thriller. The real message of the film, in my opinion, is an indictment of the Danish middle class, so removed from danger and hardship that their human survival instincts seem gone. That the Danes care so much about being polite that this is more important than removing themselves from a dangerous situation.
I think it was deliberate that they meet a Dutch family, people from, as Bjorn says, "a similar culture, more similar to them than the politically correct Swedes." It would've been easy for an exotic foreigner to be the cause of such horror, but I think the film purposefully does this. It's also refreshing to see a film that doesn't treat masculinity as a toxic trait that must be excised. Instead, Speak No Evil puts forth the idea that a man who has lost his masculinity, to the extent that he can barely put up a fight in the face of death, is no man at all.
Speak No Evil is dark, depressing, thought provoking, and not for everyone. But it's a pretty neat little thriller, has some interesting ideas, and is a roller coaster. Check it out.
