Avaliações de usuários

My Review- Red Election SBS on demand

My Rating 6/10

My Review on this 10 episode nearly 8 hour trip to nowhere will be brief as when we got to our destination which was confusing and unsatisfactory we realised the journey had been a waste of time.

I love a good John le Carré type espionage thriller and The Red Election started off with a sensational beginning that got us in straight away and then added a fictitious British Prime Minister much more appealing than Boris called Adam Cornwall ( Brian D'Arcy) . The P. M. Is trying his upmost against great odds to campaign for a NO vote in a referendum for Scottish Independence It's soon made perfectly obvious that a mysterious espionage cell code named Redback has been detected by British Intelligence and is working through agents behind the scenes to plan terrorist attacks and manipulate a YES vote to break up the United Kingdom and gain powerful influence Politically and Economically in Britain .

Red Election has a great cast all acting their socks off I particularly liked Lydia Leonard as Beatrice Ogilvy the daughter of the head of British Intelligence William Ogilvy whose also impressively played by Stephen Dillane .

Beatrice soon realises that work and family don't mix when Beatrice the most intelligent and suitable applicant for a huge promotion is vetoed by her father in favour of a much lesser qualified applicant Levi . Resentment of course causes friction and jealousy between the two but Beatrice sallies forth to investigate the mysterious events and disappearances in Copenhagen .

We're now introduced to Katrine the most mysterious and baffling character of all impressively played by Victoria Carmen Sonne that's enough no spoilers just in case anyone wants to invest 8 hours of unsatisfactory series binging.

Have you ever attempted a complicated jig saw and just as you thought the pieces were all starting to fit together the cat jumps on the table and scatters the pieces all over the place .

Well the Red Election is like that jig saw in my opinion it's far too long with far to many characters and sub plots that steer away from the bones of a great script.

I counted 9 different writers contributed to the ten episodes of Red Election a perfect example of too many cooks in the kitchen .

There was talk about a second series that's looking doubtful as I read recently because viewers haven't picked up the first series and that's a shame because if there ever was a cliff hanger ending Red Election had it .

It left us both asking is that really the last episode? Looks like it was..........

I have to agree with those of you who wrote that this is not by any means a brilliant show. However, I found the story line interesting enough to make me want to follow it through and I did actually enjoy it for that reason though I did have to allow for the far from adequate acting and dialog!

Not sure why some other reviewers simply dismiss this show, one that does make sense, but I'll admit it's not for everyone (I agree with one reviewer, maybe the sceptics ARE Americans, because this was 10 times better than any American spy thriller IMO); Is everything realistic? Are all the actors Oscar worthy? Was its writing team stellar? These questions are legitimate ones, but it's all too far to dismiss them as amateurs or that the show was dumb. Shows in Europe and the UK have a high standard when it comes to green-lighting shows, and so your better come with actual ammunition to prove this show wasn't worth a watch. I'm not sure about the sceptics, but that's not why I watch things.

The fact is the story was there, and it absolutely kept me on my toes Wondering what might the truth be. The opening line referring to powerful men putting themselves against truth actually tied the show up in a neat bow, and in my opinion justified the sometimes messy, but complex plot. The truth was certainly being messed with, to the protagonists AND the audience. Both were left fighting to figure out the truth, and wondering who might be messing with it.

Ignore the 1 stars, it's all too easy to dismiss something when you're only after a rush from amateur roasting.

Would highly recommend.

I really enjoyed this show, for once the secret service isn't depicted as full of sexy genius super heroes, they are all flawed human beings that make mistakes and then get on with it. I like the female lead, Beatrice, but the Danish one was so annoying I wanted to punch her. Some viewers were put off by the fact the main character was female but frankly, it added to the relationship between her and her Scottish contact who was clearly infatuated with her. Beatrice was strong but she screwed up, so did all the others. I loved Spooks, and I loved Stephen Dillane in GoT so I was interested in seeing him in another role after Stannis. I hope there's a Season 2, I'll be watching!

At the end of the tenth episode I had to check several times that it was, in fact, the final episode. So much was left unresolved. Felt a little like i'd wasted the best part of 10 hours of my life I will never get back! Disappointing.

My feeling is you watched the first episode with a predetermined mindset/agenda you came out of it thinking that the it was a 'girlpower special' because the two main characters are women and they do dominate the screen time. But if you actually view the series you will find that *all* of the *main* characters in the drama are flawed. They are not two dimensional, there is depth there. That to me is the mark of good TV/film.

Series was riveting from start to end. Each episode left you wanting to watch the next. However, it was massively let down by its conclusion or lack of.

The series ended much like the previous 9 episodes. It ended on a cliff hanger that left you wanting more. Unfortunately the cliff hanger was much the same. There was no conclusion to the story. It did not leave feeling there was a new series to be watched. Rather that the series had finished an episode early. With no conclusion to the main or any of the sub plots.

Would not recommend any new veiwers watch this series until if/when a second series is confirmed. The seires leaves the veiwer half way through a book.

I seen a previous review speaking about a jigsaw puzzle broken by a cat. I would describe it more as a jigsaw puzzle with the final 2 pieces missing.

God help Britain if its security was in the hands of the inept clowns who make up the secret service in this show. The "tension" and storyline relies on the bad guys continually and unbelievably evading the Keystone Cop-esque security forces. Appalling stuff.

Don't believe the dismissive reviews already posted. Red Election is great fun - a Spooks-like spy drama based around European geopolitics, Russian expansionism, Scottish separatism and good old- fashioned Cold War espionage. The cast are great. It's tightly paced and completely binge-worthy! Bring on season 2!

Great writing completely spoiled by Lydia Leonard. All other characters are good. Certainly hope another season is proposed ad the ending was very inconclusive.

I feel like many of the negative reviews come from the fact that the two leads are women. I personally really enjoyed this show, great plot twists, well written character and great acting as well! I hope they make another season because that ending could not have been better. It will keep you on the edge of your seat for the whole time.

The first half of the show was outstanig but the latter half looked like the director had somehow lost the plot halfway through.

The only way to rectify the mess, which culminated in a rushed and laughable ending, is to come up with a Season 2 of at least six episodes - and it'd better be damn good or else... Or else what started as a potential gem will be remembered as a botched effort. The acting was decent, with Vic Carmen Sonne living uo to the hyped Danish cinmetography as she put in a stellar performance.

I'v seen worse but this had the potential to be so much better, in fact it would have ticked most boxes but for an impausible last episode.

Here's a clue for all you wannabe spy writers: watching innocent people suffer horribly, because somebody on government payroll made yet another stupid mistake at trying to manipulate terrorism in the national interest, is not entertaining. It isn't even interesting, especially when the story is so stupid and the characters so utterly inept and dimensionless. Just the lead lady alone is excruciating both as an actress and a character, a daddy's girl who has been nepotized up the ranks until she gets to give the orders now and then, and just keeps that same idiotic smirking sneer of incongruent non-plused cynicism on her face each time her lame-brained plans lead straight to catastrophe.

This is not about anything other than brainless violence, it has nothing to say of any value, it relies entirely on worn-out cliches and pop-culture bigotries in place of a story, and unless you just enjoy watching bureaucrats who think they are spies screw up everything they lay their hands to episode after grueling episode, don't even bother. Maybe you can spare yourself the severed limbs and gruesome child murders and a whole lot of horrified screaming; I can't even imagine what sort of person would even find this tolerable to watch, even less so the kind of people it must have required to produce this pointless assault on the viewership.

Really liked this show but wish the threads were tied up unless there's another season.

Although I found the main character Beatrice a bit annoying at times.

There is a lot in this series that goes unexplained especially the ending. Mostly because they hoped or planned for a second season. Bad call. On the one hand, good performances by the cast. On the other too many betrayals and plot twists that the story thread got lost. I slugged my way through all 10 episodes with anticipation, in fact many of the twists and turns were surprising. However as a viewer one is left still not knowing what or who (or why?) is Redback? Plus the whole role of the danish agent and her motives are completely ridiculous. Two key elements in the series left barely explored. As was the the double cross of the PM by his key advisor., and the nepotism angle by the lead character Beatrice. Each compelling plot fillers but never resolved. Such a waste of some good story ideas! On a positive note the series dealt with deep fakes and issues around what is truth in this age of social media. Something real as is the threat to democracy. The show simply muddled it by trying to take on too much. It's unfortunate since the geopolitics of a multipolar world are quite compelling. Certainly no TV series can accurately capture these complexities so I applaud the Red Election for trying. It just could of been told a bit more coherently.

No, this ain't good enough. What could have been a decent classic political thriller just felt like hasty "direct to TV" work with a story that gets worse and worse the longer into the series you get.

Acting is questionnable. Lydia Leonard (and most of the ensemble actually) has the same facial expression throughout all 10 episodes and the amount of frustrated "fuuu*k" is impressive. Must be the most commonly used word in the whole series...

Nothing to waste time on unfortunately.

This series was addictive and thrilling. I loved the lead characters except for the somewhat mawkish PM. The writing has a lot to be admired and the acting was generally great (IMHO and in contrast to most reviews here - perhaps other reviewers are American?). I was on the edge of my seat and really looked forward to each episode. The accents were fine for me and I liked both the female leads. That's the good news. The downsides included irritating plot holes, an MI5 staffed by half a dozen people (including two boy nerds who were the entire IT, communications and research staff), a nuclear power station that had less monitoring and control (and staff) than the average home, and a totally unsatisfactory ending. We can only assume a second series is planned to tie up the flapping strands, but looking at these comments you'd have to wonder if that's likely. I hope there is!

PS 'Le Bureau' was as thrilling and has a much better and more believable script.

July 2023 -- two years after release and still waiting on a follow-up or concluding series .... I disagree with the negative reviews about bad acting, bad dialog, bad plot that wasn't credible, etc., but I won't bore a reader with further explanation after all that's been written by others . The ending was disappointing, but if the producers ever get around to Season 2, Red Election could still turn out to be a good espionage thriller. If they don't, as appears more likely with each passing month, then I cannot recommend Session 1; in spite of its promise, it cannot stand on its own. It was left dangling with so many loose ends that it's still not possible to be sure who the good guys and bad guys really are.

Wish I'd read these reviews before I watched this series. Was ok until the last episode, which was a mega disappointment. Life is too short to spend on something which has no conclusion!

Wicked good and suspenseful! Thoroughly enjoyed the acting, writing and loved the twists and turns. Don't listen to the naysayers, this is worth the watch

Great series!