Avaliações de usuários

Warts and all loving portrait of Spike Milligan the man. A mixture of remembrances from friends and family, home movies, clips from Spikes work, and several interviews with Spike this tries to set the record straight and portray Spike as a person and not the "Godfather of Comedy" . I don't know what I expected but I don't think it was what I got which is a portrait of Milligan that sort of pushes his work to the side in order to portray the man as a friend, brother or dad. Its not a bad thing but unless you're a fan already and want to know more about Spike the person the film is going to fall flat. Who was Spike? The film doesn't really make it clear. Why should you care? Unless you know his work you probably won't. This isn't to say its a bad film, its not, its just that I would have liked more of a balancing of the man and his work (which is mentioned but most of the references are going to be lost if you don't know them). Yes the film tells you a great deal about his life and family,and if that is what you're looking for this is great. If you're looking for a film to explain what all the shouting was about you'll have to look else where. 6 out of 10.

After Spike's death, there were all sorts of "true" stories coming out in the papers and after a period of mourning and affection, the tabloids started sniffing around. In an effort to try and let the world see the real Spike Milligan, his family (represented here by Jane Milligan) agreed to open the family archive and support the making of this documentary, which relies heavily on contributions from his family and friends as well as clips from other shows that Spike did in the past.

At the start the personal narration from Jane Milligan made me think that this was going to be a great little film that provides plenty of nuggets that we had never seen or heard before. At times this is true and there are nice contributions from several family members but not all that they say is that interesting – at times they just tell us what we have heard a hundred times already – many of them from Spike's own mouth. Speaking of which, the film actually relies heavily on the man himself and heavily uses clips from one or two shows he recorded where he is quite open and honest about himself. They build on this with the family comments but it is hard to get away from the fact that the film is mainly just pulling two or three separate programmes together, cutting bits out of them and using the family to string them together. Although I was interested it didn't work as a film and I felt it suffered from the lack of one clear approach.

Fans of Spike will maybe appreciate the chance to see home movie footage and hear from his offspring and siblings but even the casual viewer will wonder why more was not given. Overall this is an OK film that is interesting but not wholly successful. The mix of material is strange and mostly it feels like the film has been pulled together from other shows and interviews that many of us will have already seen. Worth seeing for Milligan fans though, just don't expect it to have more than a handful of moments of real interest.