O Estrangeiro

Such a simple premise, but such a beautiful movie, and a glorious way for Satyajit Ray to end his illustrious career. Filmed in beautiful color, it touches on areas like philosophy, anthropology, religion, and science, but in ways that are light and engaging. It was made for me by the performance from Utpal Dutt, who plays the titular stranger with such presence, and imbued with worldly wisdom. It also features traditional musical performances, one with a tamboura and a native dance by the Kol people, which were quite a treat.

The story has a man who left home to travel the world long ago turning up in a family's life, and claiming to be the woman's uncle. She wants to believe him but since she was a baby when he left can't confirm it, and along with her cautious husband and vigilant friends, has doubts about his identity, particularly since an inheritance is involved. As they try to "peel the onion" on his life and who he is, he talks about his experiences in various cities around the world, and more significantly, his time with native peoples in India, as well as North and South America. The drama about his identity and whether he's cheating them seems to ebb into the background given the depth of what he's talking about and his intellectual honesty.

There were several fine scenes around that, one of which was the stranger talking to a group of kids about the incredible coincidence of the moon's diameter and distance from the earth being a nearly perfect proportion to the sun's, such that they appear the same size and 'fit' perfectly over one another during an eclipse. The way he talks about the mystery of this with the kids is natural and inspiring, and I also liked the other moments he had with the son in the family, passing not only his knowledge along, but also his wanderlust and desire to learn.

My favorite scene was when a family friend grills him in the attempt to expose him as a fraud, and we hear his views on weightier matters. As to religion, he says, "I happen to be a bit unorthodox in my views. I don't believe in something which creates barriers between people. Religion does that, particularly organized religion." He sees the miracles of life and is quite spiritual, but in a bittersweet, resigned way, says "The trouble is, it's extremely difficult to believe in a benevolent God these days. The daily papers alone make us question that belief." When pushed about the "savage" people he lived among, he points out the wisdom of native peoples, and in areas that aren't appreciated by 'advanced' cultures, e.g. Science, technology, medicine, architecture, and art. He says "Do you know the man who is really civilized?" It's the man who by using his thumb, presses a button which releases a weapon which obliterates an entire city with all its inhabitants."

These are some dark observations, but they aren't delivered in a gloomy, depressing way. They're balanced out by the man's humanity and the wisdom which comes from life experience and maturity. I felt it was Ray himself speaking here, in the grander scheme of things "no one," but a gifted, intelligent filmmaker, giving one last gift to the world.

What a beautiful film, full of subtleties and ironies. It requires one to contemplate the nature of identity and what one really wants in life. How well do we know our relatives; and, more importantly, how well do we know ourselves? The film beautifully portrays a wide range of emotions with sensitivity as well as hummer. It also includes a mesmerizing indigenous dance performance which contrasts the middle-class world of the protagonists, awakening them to another world. The "stranger" or the long-lost uncle is a marvel, evoking laughter and tears. All in all, delightful throughout. For some reason foreign cinema continues to go unrecognized, while American studios continue to invest inaction movies that only insult intelligence to an already overly ridiculed nation. Watch it you will enjoy it immensely.

It is possible and dangerous to read too much into a director's final film as being a "swan song" or a "culmination," and it seems to be an easy "insight" by those unable to come up with something better. But here we have a veritable summation and a compelling final statement of a brilliant career.

Whenever I watch an S. Ray film, I always feel lost trying to find a main theme or thrust in the story. Here we have several: ancient custom vs. technology, self-discovery, mystery/doubt, etc. But they all co-mingle in this extraordinarily complex character (based on Ray himself no doubt, hence the high level of insight). His was a cinema of life, scattered and bewildering, yet sublimely beautiful.

Still, Ray remains one of the few great directors from his era who never quite mastered the use of colour. Indeed, the lingering shots of images lacks the power of say the chandelier in "Jalsaghar," and the regret and sorrow on the faces of the family doesn't come anywhere close to the final scenes of "Pather."

On top of this we have Ray trying most explicitly to be philosophical. Some of Manmohan's laments on civilisation resemble passages from "Notes From Underground," and we even have the husband talking about having to "put two and two together," but these themes seem to be mentioned for the sake of mentioning them. Ray, like Manmohan, was an anthropologist, not a philosopher. Still, there are some deeply touching moments in this overall capably and thoughtfully made film.

3 out of 5 - Some strong elements

Simple and eloquent. The Stranger may be too charming for many of today's hipsters. A bit corny perhaps, but corn tastes great when it's cooked properly. The acting alone is worth the price of admission. If this was Ray's swan song, I'm sure he's resting in peace. Bravo, maestro!

A well-off family is paid an unexpected, and rather unwanted, visit by a man claiming to be the woman's long-lost uncle. The initial suspicion with which they greet the man slowly dissolves as he regales them with stories of his travels, tales that are at odds with their conventional middle-class perspective on the world.

This film is notable for being Satyajit Ray's final project. He may be best known for the s-called "Apu Trilogy" much earlier in his career. But, to be honest, I enjoyed "Stranger" far more. It was more polished, had a more intelligent script and dialogue. It is something of a masterful movie.

As I often say in reviews, I am not typically a fan of Indian / Bengali films. I rarely see one -- even those considered the best -- that I enjoy. But I would wholeheartedly endorse "The Stranger".