Avaliações de usuários

Maria (Helda Aguirre) is a young orphan who lives with her dominant aunt (Margot Cottens) . In the evening , she sings in a spectacle bar and forms a rock band with friends called Los Yakis Voladores . But while Ernesto (Enrique Guzmán) is in love with Maria , she cannot correspond these feelings for him . Then she decides to become nun and at the convent is nicknamed the Hermana Maria Sor Ye-Ye . There Maria meets a philantropic doctor (Manuel Gil) who runs the hospital and heals sick people without salary . They are two very different roles . On one hand , he is a serious and upright doctor , on the other hand , she is a beautiful and extroverted nun who's being usually adviced by a likeable , friendly old nun , Madre María de los Ángeles (Sara Garcia) . Little by little , both of whom fall in love but there's an extreme inconvenience , she is a novice nun , furthermore , there's another suitor , her old flame Ernesto Nieva (Enrique Guzmán) .

Enjoyable musical comedy with amenity , fine humor , subtle irony , traditional sense of style and nice Mexican setting . It was common in post-war cinema to deal with the most luxurious means of advertising in favor of singers , bullfighters , athletes , priests and and using , as usual , the Catholicism and holy church through some friendly nuns . The amusing and funny storyline written by Vicente Escrivá and José María Sánchez Silva , being loosely based on the Antonio Palacio Valdes novel : ¨La Hermana de San Sulpicio¨; however the adaptation is not faithful to the details . This one results to be an attempt to popularize Helda Aguirre as Maria Sor Ye-yé , a lively , fun girl who makes a surprising decision : to become a singer nun . Nevertheless , Hilda Aguirre did not sing her songs but was dubbed . She's well accompanied by the gallant Manuel Gil as good looking partenaire , as well as the famous Mexican idol Enrique Guzmán playing a singer who eventually participates in San Remo Festival singing along with Hilda Aguirre/Sor Ye Ye in order to obtain money to heal a blind boy.

The motion picture was adequately directed by Rámon Fernandez. This craftsman Rámon was a prolific artisan who directed all kinds of genres, such as thrillers : Rueda de sospechosos , 7 minutos para morir, La muerte ronda a Monica , Westerns : Las mujeres de Jeremias, Musical: Las aventuras de Enrique y Ana , A Tope . Being expert on Spanish comedies such as : Aqui estan las vicetiples , Cateto a babor , No desearas al vecino del quinto , Ahi va otro recluta , Simon contamos contigo , Sor YeYe , Margarita se llama mi amor , Los novios de mujer , El adultero , El donante , Cuando los maridos iban a la guerra , Doctor me gustan las mujeres es grave , Matrimonio al desnudo , El señorito y las seductoras, El gran mogollon , Aqui el que no corre vuela . Rating 6/10. Acceptable and passable musical comedy .

There are other versions about this novel Armando Palacio Valdés : silent rendition ¨La hermana San Sulpicio¨ (1927) by Florian Rey with Imperio Argentina , Florencia Bécquer , Ricardo Nuñez . ¨La hermana de San Sulpicio¨ (1934) by Florian Rey with Imperio Argentina , Miguel Ligero , Salvador Soler Marí. ¨La hermana San Sulpicio¨ (1952) by Luis Lucia with Carmen Sevilla , Jorge Mistral , Manuel Luna , Julia Caba Alba. Argentina TV series : ¨La hermana San Sulpicio¨ (1960) with Nelly Beltrán. ¨La novicia rebelde¨ (1972) by Luis Lucia with Rocío Dúrcal , Guillermo Murray , Isabel Garcés , Ángel Garasa.

This film is excellent, and i am always remembering its songs as part of my inner life. I like the actors the actress above all and I think this film should be regarded as one of the best films for children in Spanish language. From my point of view this film has very beautiful songs such as the ones sung by Hilda Aguirre, who for the other part is one of the best actresses i have ever seen, her performance is very credible and I think her angelical face matches the role quite well. However,I would like to highlight its faults that are its end, which is quite inexplicable according to the plot and some other parts of the plot that seem to be quite out of place.

My trouble is that I can't speak English enough to make me understand and It's very hard to me to understand English, but I'm gonna try to do it, this movie is excellent, I want to buy a DVD about this movie, but it is possible? does somebody sell DVDS about that movie? I would buy it. I admire so much ENRIQUE GUZMÁN and HILDA AGUIRRE, and I love México and all its culture, I love old Mexican movies and its actors, they are divine, the songs that played in this movie are very beautiful, in special "now, I go" I can't write its name in Spanish because the system doesn't send my comments,If I had this movie I would keep it like it were gold.

Thank you

Diana

One of my favorites movies talked in Spanish, because it makes me remember when I was a child and my sister Aura used to take me to cinema in the Holly Week times..but recently now at my 36, I discovered that the voice of María (Sor Ye yé) when she sings is not her real voice....this voice belongs to another singer named Estela Núñez...I feel a little bad because I adore this voice (specially when she sings Andando de tu mano, Adivinanza, Quiero vivir), I always though that Hilda Aguirre had sung these songs....the fact was the voice was dubbed in songs...Enrique Guzman also sings very nice in this movie, Alexis/Mérida/Venezuela