AVALIAÇÃO DA IMDb
7,1/10
3,8 mil
SUA AVALIAÇÃO
Adicionar um enredo no seu idiomaA dramatization of the British Expeditionary Force's 1940 retreat to the beaches of France and the extraordinary seaborne evacuation that saved it from utter destruction by Nazi Germany.A dramatization of the British Expeditionary Force's 1940 retreat to the beaches of France and the extraordinary seaborne evacuation that saved it from utter destruction by Nazi Germany.A dramatization of the British Expeditionary Force's 1940 retreat to the beaches of France and the extraordinary seaborne evacuation that saved it from utter destruction by Nazi Germany.
- Direção
- Roteiristas
- Artistas
Bud Flanagan
- Bud Flanagan
- (as Flanagan and Allen)
Avaliações em destaque
This presents a concise account of the Dunkirk operation. It avoids the "stuff upper lip" mentality that was present in a great deal of British War films of this time (with some exceptions). The film presents two separate stories around the Dunkirk operation: the lost soldiers (led by the NCO John Mills) and the cynical civilian reporter (Bernard Lee). They finally meet up on the beach at Dunkirk. A very well directed Ealing Film.
The night before I went to see the 2017 film of the events I watched this film again.It was everything that the new film is not.A faithful retelling of events told in an involving but not over emotional way.The scale of production may not have been as large as the new film,but you learned a lot more.Peopled with many fine actors including Mills,Attenborough and Lee.It captures the mood of the times which the new film does not.
I've just watched the Christopher Nolan 2017 'Dunkirk' and that offering is mediocre at best, you feel very little for the characters, nor are you told much back story.
Mr Nolan's version is not a patch on this 1958 classic where you really get a feel for the scale and depth of the military disaster and miracle evacuation
Many war films made shortly after the war, have a gritty depth & realism.
Many of the actors had been participants, they could march, salute, handle the weapons and wear a beret correctly. Because many had done it for real.
Also a lot of original aircraft/ships/vehicles were still available to use. So in many respects the old war films have an authenticity difficult to match today. (As illustrated by the 2017 mediocre film 'Dunkirk')
This follows corporal 'cor blimey' john Mills as he and his small section are separated from their unit. Their attempts to try and rejoin their unit through the chaos of the retreat to Dunkirk.
It also follows the civilians helping in the 'little ships' and the operation to save the British/French armies stranded at Dunkirk.
It is an epic tale and over the years I have watched it several times. A Sunday afternoon classic epic tale of heroism in a total disaster that nearly meant annihilation. Without the evacuation by 'the little ships' it surely would have meant Hitler conquering all of Europe
8/10
Mr Nolan's version is not a patch on this 1958 classic where you really get a feel for the scale and depth of the military disaster and miracle evacuation
Many war films made shortly after the war, have a gritty depth & realism.
Many of the actors had been participants, they could march, salute, handle the weapons and wear a beret correctly. Because many had done it for real.
Also a lot of original aircraft/ships/vehicles were still available to use. So in many respects the old war films have an authenticity difficult to match today. (As illustrated by the 2017 mediocre film 'Dunkirk')
This follows corporal 'cor blimey' john Mills as he and his small section are separated from their unit. Their attempts to try and rejoin their unit through the chaos of the retreat to Dunkirk.
It also follows the civilians helping in the 'little ships' and the operation to save the British/French armies stranded at Dunkirk.
It is an epic tale and over the years I have watched it several times. A Sunday afternoon classic epic tale of heroism in a total disaster that nearly meant annihilation. Without the evacuation by 'the little ships' it surely would have meant Hitler conquering all of Europe
8/10
A simple film, two stories, soldiers and civilians who did what needed to be done. None of the romance of "Mrs Minnever," but moving nonetheless.
I appreciated this film all the more for having seen "Pearl Harbor" a few months ago. I gave "Dunkirk" 8/10, maybe a little generous, because of the attention to detail and accuracy. The acting was better than adequate, and it was wonderful to see a youngish Bernard Lee. He was 49 when this film was released in 1958 -- there is a gap in his filmography from 41 to 45, so he probably served in the war... as did many of the other actors.
I appreciated this film all the more for having seen "Pearl Harbor" a few months ago. I gave "Dunkirk" 8/10, maybe a little generous, because of the attention to detail and accuracy. The acting was better than adequate, and it was wonderful to see a youngish Bernard Lee. He was 49 when this film was released in 1958 -- there is a gap in his filmography from 41 to 45, so he probably served in the war... as did many of the other actors.
Dunkirk is one of the best war movies ever made.
John Mills puts in a great performance as Tubby Binns, as does Bernard Lee as private boat owner "doing his bit" for the country. I thought some of the best scenes were around the battle with the artillery battery in the woods. Some good special effects and totally believable scenes. The futility of war is also shown to good effect when the Stukas arrive and bomb the battery.
One thing that really amazed me, was the inclusion of a "real" German halftrack during the scene where the bridge was being demolished. For a '50's war movie this is a special treat, much better than seeing the usual American halftracks with big crosses on their sides.
All in all, one of my favourite war movies, one that somehow captures the ambiance of those terrible times.
John Mills puts in a great performance as Tubby Binns, as does Bernard Lee as private boat owner "doing his bit" for the country. I thought some of the best scenes were around the battle with the artillery battery in the woods. Some good special effects and totally believable scenes. The futility of war is also shown to good effect when the Stukas arrive and bomb the battery.
One thing that really amazed me, was the inclusion of a "real" German halftrack during the scene where the bridge was being demolished. For a '50's war movie this is a special treat, much better than seeing the usual American halftracks with big crosses on their sides.
All in all, one of my favourite war movies, one that somehow captures the ambiance of those terrible times.
Você sabia?
- CuriosidadesWhen the troop ship taking the platoon home is bombed and sunk in Dunkirk harbor, the scene of the ship sinking is taken from Mar Cruel (1953), which depicts the sinking of H.M.S. "Compass Rose".
- Erros de gravaçãoApprox fifteen minutes into the film there is a montage of shots to represent the German attack on Belgium and France in May1940. One shot shows a German Tiger Tank. The first Tigers didn't see action until late 1942.
- Citações
Merchant Seaman: It may be a phoney war to you, but it's not to all the blokes at sea. Never has been.
- Cenas durante ou pós-créditosAfter the title is shown, it stays on screen while the rest of the opening credits roll.
- ConexõesFeatured in Film Profile: Michael Balcon (1961)
Principais escolhas
Faça login para avaliar e ver a lista de recomendações personalizadas
- How long is Dunkirk?Fornecido pela Alexa
Detalhes
Bilheteria
- Orçamento
- £ 400.000 (estimativa)
- Faturamento bruto mundial
- US$ 222
- Tempo de duração
- 2 h 15 min(135 min)
- Cor
- Proporção
- 1.66 : 1
Contribua para esta página
Sugerir uma alteração ou adicionar conteúdo ausente